Well this has gone off in a odd direction hasn't it?  Just to try to keep 
things practical, here's my tried and true method for playing and teaching 
"clean" fingering changes.  Take your mouthpiece out and put the end of the 
leadpipe right up next to your ear like a stethoscope.  Now pick a fingering 
change, let's say from 2+3 to 1st and go back and forth a few times, striving 
to hear one click rather than several at each change.  Surprisingly this works 
quite well and has quickly cleaned up fingering problems for every student I've 
had do it.  The lesson tends to stick permanently as well, so I give it good 
marks on the "simple yet effective" scale.  
    How "clean" do these changes need to be?  well, only as clean as humans are 
able to perceive.  Naturally you can slow things down with a computer and hear 
all kinds of things.  Slow down the hum of a mosquito and you hear the 
individual vibrations, but as humans we can't distinguish them individually.  
Hugh Cooper taught a wonderful acoustics class at the University of Michigan 
for many years and was also a bassoonist.  He would spend one entire class 
demonstrating that because of this "smear factor", it made no sense to play 
Beethoven 4th that damn fast!!!!  Ha Ha!  But what's the lower limit?  32 cps I 
think or something like that.  Below that, you hear it as individual 
vibrations, above that you hear it as a note.  So anyway, clean - yes but 
probably no need for it to be inhumanly clean.
   To comment on William's finger changing chart, this change for example:  
> 1st to open
> all valves open for a millisecond
>
 2nd to closed
If you think about it, that would only be true if you wait until the 1st valve 
is all the way up before starting to push the 2nd valve down.  I think it would 
be more true to say both 1st and 2nd valves are half open for a millisecond, 
3rd stays completely open.  Interestingly (well to me anyway) if you run water 
through your horn, take a valve slide out and push that valve down, the water 
will come out of one of the slide tubes.  If you push the valve half way down, 
it will come out of the Other tube.  Wassup with that?  
    BTW, those printed piano fingerings are usually calculated to give a smooth 
flow from one chord to the next without having to use the pedal to cover up the 
big holes.  I hear an alarming number of soloists these days just holding the 
pedal down through everything.  In that case, the fingerings don't matter but 
the sound suffers.

- Steve Mumford
    


_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to