Sorry, William, you describe YOUR DILEMMA exactly as it is. 
You are surrounded by ignorant egocentric professionals, - after your opinion.

You also have a very special idea about me. I just judge recordings after what 
I hear,
the description, how it has been done, does not interest me.

Our disagreement is just one simple fact:

You cannot agree that the simpler way is the safer way, as it leaves more time &
energy for music making. Anything complicated technically should be avoided
when in "combat situation", where stress is an important factor.

I do not ask you to follow my simpler technical advise, if yours works better
for you. But you try to persuade/confuse others to follow your ear-wise 
confusing
tuning adaptation recommendations, resulting in easier fingerings, perhaps, but
confusing, because the brain/fingerings automatic will detect "wrong" fingerings
for the sounds produced. As a professional you have not the time to switch 
hearing-fingering automatic back & forth (I point to the E.Schmid converted
tripel disaster in Pjoenyang with New World symphony).
Just that is the problem. If it works for a solo piece, fine, but not in the 
symphony,
where you have to be responsible for the success of the ensemble.

If I explain in details, you never respond to the exact things, you just came up
with other reasons why to do so (see smoothness - in the special case of the
Krufft sonata the smoothness issue is a no issue; would it be an issue for all
the triplet passages, perhaps ?

And using the possible problems with the language barrier is simply
stupid.
(Koennen Sie etwa in halbwegs verstaendlichem Deutsch antworten ?)

##############################################################


Am 21.07.2010 um 08:53 schrieb [email protected]:

> 
> Perhaps my communication isn't clear. Perhaps there is a language barrier - I 
> don't know. 
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to