Perhaps my communication isn't clear. Perhaps there is a language barrier - I don't know. Let me try one more time for the final time.
Look, I know you have a lot of great advice, and if you are at the top of the section it is your call on things like that. I never argued against that. If I am told to play a certain fingering by the principal, I do it. What I was suggesting was in a solo. Which means, I am by myself. It is at my discretion to do what I feel is necessary. If it works, then great. I'm not the only one who plays pieces in E like that. Schmid recommends it on his horns. There are a few professionals with just as much experience as you who do exactly what I'm doing. But I guess, you'd only listen to me if I was one of those professionals even if I am copying what they say verbatim? I've also done this in front of a few very well-known players - one or two probably had more experience than you. I've explained this idea to them. Here's the difference... They were OPEN to the idea, were interested in it, and didn't sh*t all over me for trying something different. They encouraged me to use my method. I'm very well aware of your method of playing it transposed into E on an F horn. I can perform like that. I choose not to because to me there is a simpler way with my Schmid. I don't know how else to explain this to you. What works for you isn't going to always work for everyone. You do not possess the end-all solutions to everything. The best musicians I've ever met are very Socratic. They know what they don't know. They're intellectually honest. They're open to new ideas. They don't crap all over you because you happen to disagree. They are in the minority though. The smartest people in the world and the best people at their respective fields are humble, know they don't know everything, and when faced with someone who has a different approach to something doesn't insult them and judge them. They listen. If it works, it works. Most professional musicians walk around as if they own the world. These are not the best of the best I mentioned earlier. If you guys can't see the attitude you purvey to everyone else around you, I'm sorry. But, I can tell you that if you ever get outside of the world of music and find out how people perceive you, you might be quite surprised at what you find. I've talked to a few non-musicians that have to regularly hire union professional orchestra members and you wouldn't believe the things they have to say about the attitudes they find. The funny thing out of all of this is that I have sent you a live performance of a piece in E a few years ago using this exact method and never told you what I was doing. You liked it. I guess now that you know I used a method you didn't like you're just going to change your opinion on me. -William -----Original Message----- From: Hans Pizka <[email protected]> To: The Horn List <[email protected]> Sent: Wed, Jul 21, 2010 2:22 am Subject: Re: [Hornlist] von Krufft Sonata Hello William, that´s exactly, why you did not make it to a professional orchestra. You see all professionals as stubborn, prejudiced & egocentric, which is your greatest mistake. We have a valid saying: "Why doing it simply, if it can be done the complicate way !" We try to understand your opinion, analyze it & respond with a recommendation for an easier (less confusing) & simpler solution. But you never listen to such. That is your problem. If you would sit in my section, I would have fired you. Believe me, there are some individual players, I worked with, who responded to my demand playing written f2 (top line) with 1 on the Bb-side for Goetterdaemmerung beginning chord (safer, better in tune, more lucide, etc.): "no, I am in tune with my way fingering it." You know what I did the next try ? I just mimed playing & such blamed the other player because he was flat definitely playing the written f2 as open on the Bb stubbornly. He never questioned my advise again !!!! The next time, he questioned my rhythm. How can two horn players cooperate, if the 2nd horn is not willing to accept the leadership of the first. I proceeded as done with the f2, - most successfully. You would call this egocentrism. Blame you. _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
