On 22/Feb/10 23:29, Franck Martin wrote:
> it seems point 5 should be extended to "forwarding including mailing lists"

What do you mean exactly? Section 3.9.2. of RFC 5321 identifies 
"Lists" as a forwarding technique, contrasted to alias expansion. That 
technique just implies changing the envelope sender, which is fairly 
generic. Point 5 is apparently about full blown mailing lists, which 
also have, e.g., RFC 2369's List-* fields.

IMHO, "forwarding" also includes any instance of mass mailing where 
the list or recipients is expanded on a server. Technically, it is not 
a very precise term... --that's why I'm asking.

> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Barry Leiba"<[email protected]>
>[...]
>    5. Consider issues related to mailing lists, beyond what is
>       already documented.  This includes considerations for mailing
>       list software that supports or intends to support DKIM, as well
>       as considerations for DKIM/ADSP deployment in the presence of
>       mailing lists that do not have such support.  Include
>       recommendations in the informational documents, or produce a
>       new informational document about mailing-list considerations.
_______________________________________________
NOTE WELL: This list operates according to 
http://mipassoc.org/dkim/ietf-list-rules.html

Reply via email to