created_by is deprecated, but JOSM will take care of that. source belongs on the changeset
Is it possible to include brand:wikidata=Q154950 ? US, Canada and Nigeria seem to have different wikidata ids. I'm not sure about operator, shouldn't that be the person/company operating that particular branch? Maybe it's a good idea to be careful with name. Aren't there cases where this includes the name of the operator/subsidiary/franchise + the brand? Polyglot 2017-05-11 18:15 GMT+02:00 Christoph Hormann <[email protected]>: > On Thursday 11 May 2017, Ilya Zverev wrote: > > > > The import is done with the OSM Conflator script. It matches dataset > > points to all amenity=fuel nodes and polygons inside a 50 meter > > radius. > > So if current mapping in OSM is off more than 50m you get duplicates? > > What do you do if the location you want to add a node at is in the > middle of a road or a lake as mapped in OSM? > > > If found, the object is not moved, but tags are updated from > > the dataset. The object gets correct opening hours, uniform brand and > > operator tags, and so on. > > So if Shell 'knows' a station opens at 8 am although mappers have > verified locally that it actually is not open before 8:15 you replace > that information with the 'correct' one? > > > Every object is given a "ref:navads_shell" tag with an identifier, > > which will later be used for updating the data. > > I think we long ago established that proprietary IDs not verifiable by > mappers have no place in OSM. > > > After this import there will be others of similar nature and quality. > > To be clear - import review is always for the specific import as > planned, there is no carte blanche for future supposedly similar > imports. > > In any case you need to follow the import guidelines which means you > have to write a page on the OSM wiki documenting your import plans (in > particular what tags to use) and you have to make clear the data you > want to import is either published under a compatible license or > document the owner of the data has given explicit permission for use in > OSM. > > > Uploading will be done with a dedicated account (not created yet). > > The NavAds company specializes in putting businesses on maps, and we > > are helping them to include OpenStreetMap in their choice of target > > maps. I hope you are okay with this. > > Who is 'we' here? > > Overall and to be perfectly honest i hope you set aside a decent > fraction of what they are paying you to donate to the OSM project as > compensation for the review of a half baked import plan you present > here. ;-) > > -- > Christoph Hormann > http://www.imagico.de/ > > _______________________________________________ > Imports mailing list > [email protected] > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports >
_______________________________________________ Imports mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
