On Thu, Jan 23, 2003 at 01:10:18PM -0500, Jefferson Ogata wrote:
> But I guess I don't understand in what scenario this is actually a problem 
> for you. If you're rdr-ing to a 10 address, and you're allowing inbound to 
> that address, does it actually matter whether the rdr is invoked?

Well, the goal (per the original poster) was to keep out traffic
natively addressed to 10/8. In this case, I would not want such
traffic to reach my mail server, but only traffic which was addressed
to my real, external IP.

The reason I feel that using a reverse rdr rule is a more complete
solution is that it maintains the separation of legitimate and bogus
traffic. Otherwise, from the inside, NAT'd legitimate traffic and
bogus traffic that was natively addressed to 10/8 are no longer
distinguishable.

-c

Reply via email to