P. Flavin wrote:
>Give us a hint ...
>
> It would be more helpful if they would tell you
>what works and what doesn't work with the 'new'
>Loaders and have a chart comparing it to the
>other loaders in terms what it can load,
>where it can work ( in a browser ? ), etc.
>
> It looks like don't want you to know :^(
>
> The Sun VRML Loaders work very well ;^)
>
We have a running RELEASE_NOTES that details all the known functionality and bugs with
the system. We are hiding nothing. And we actually support and fix the bugs in our
loader. Can you say the same thing about the loader you are espousing others to use?
Show us the code Paul, do some work, stop bitching and do something.
I'e attached the release notes.
--
Alan Hudson
President: Yumetech, Inc. http://www.yumetech.com/
Web3D Open Source Chair http://www.web3d.org/TaskGroups/source/
These are release notes for Xj3D from M1 forward. Each release will
detail its functionality in meeting the applicable specifications and document
any known issues. If a feature works differently based on an encoding(utf8 or
XML) it will be noted.
Release: M4(Feb 19, 2002)
-------------------------
The following VRML concepts work:
parsing(utf8 and XML)
DEF/USE(utf8 and XML)
routing(utf8 and XML)
Scripting(utf8)
JSAI(Java) supported
Except ReplaceWorld
ECMAScript supported
Except - ReplaceWorld
- SFNode constructor with a string (eg new
SFNode('Group[]');
- VrmlMatrix implemented, not tested.Obscure
setTransform
stuff partially implemented (missing shear
handling)
External (EAI 2.0) supported
replaceWorld not yet supported
begin/endUpdate, implemented, not fully supported
Prototypes(utf8)
Proto's cannot emulate sensors currently
Extern prototypes (utf8)
Those containing bindables do not work correctly for those nodes
ie Viewpoint, NavigationInfo, BackGround, Fog
The following nodes work:
Appearance
Box
Color
ColorInterpolator
Cone
Coordinate
CoordinateInterpolator
Cylinder
DirectionalLight
ElevationGrid
Fog
Group
ImageTexture
Scaling images looks awful. Recommend you prescale content to power 2.
If an image is not USEd it will be reloaded from disk everytime
Known issues with transparency.
No support for GIF's
IndexedFaceSet
IndexedLineSet
Lighting uses diffuseColor instead of emissiveColor
Inline
LOD
Gone backwards slightly from M3. Can't be USEd in a renderable node
parent. OK to USE with scripts. Java3D's Behaviours cannot be under a
SharedGroup, so this has been removed pending a *major* redesign of all
our dynamic behaviours system in M5.
Material
Look at turning lighting off for emissive only decls
NavigationInfo
Normal
OrientationInterpolator
PixelTexture
does not support hex encoding of values
PointSet
Lighting uses diffuseColor instead of emissiveColor
PositionInterpolator
ScalarInterpolator
Script
Shape
Sphere
Switch
TextureCoordinate
TextureTransform
TimeSensor
Transform
Viewpoint
WorldInfo
The following nodes have some implementation but are not finished:
Anchor
Background
KeySensor
ProximitySensor
Does not support position_changed or orientation_changed
Incorrectly tests for all viewpoints instead of just moving. So a PS
which encompases 0,0,10(default VP) will always be activated. Cannot be
used under a DEF scene graph due to Java3D behaviour limitations. All
parent nodes to the root of the world must be non-DEF.
SpotLight
Not really complete. Works mostly as a Point light
BeamWidth is currently ignored. Need to convert to spreadAngle
radius is currently ignored. Need to convert to spreadAngle
TouchSensor
Does not support hitpoint changed events
The following nodes are not implemented:
AudioClip
Billboard
Collision
CylinderSensor
Extrusion
FontStyle
MovieTexture
NormalInterpolator
PlaneSensor
Sound
SphereSensor
Text
VisibilitySensor
Specific Issues with example programs:
browser
Reloading a file with inlines will cause a multi_parent exception.
Switching to a SimpleLoadManager instead of a MemCacheLoadManager will
resolve.
DOMViewer
Does not support scripts or protos.
Since it sets every field of a node it can uncover bugs that DIYBrowser
won't.
editor
Really basic right now, not much testing done
Navigation does not work.
Setting appearances/material does not work
loader
No known issues
SAI_DOM_Demo
Nonfunctional as of M3 release.
