Another more rigorous approach would be to only allow authenticated users to
edit and comment (so anonymous or asserted users can no longer
edit/comment), and expand the user registration process with an email
confirmation step.

Yes, but that will cut down on contributing users; the threshold of participation goes way up. Which I don't really like.

But looking at the amount of spam-edits done so far, this might give a
little bit too much collateral damage.

Well, the current statistics is

grey:~/Projects/JSPWiki> cat /var/log/jspwiki/jspwikispam.log* | grep ACCEPTED | wc -l
1152
grey:~/Projects/JSPWiki> cat /var/log/jspwiki/jspwikispam.log* | grep REJECTED | wc -l
63259

So the spamfilter seems to be mostly working :-)

(I also had a quick look at the registered users, and it seems to me that there are quite a few with invalid email adressess, I think those should be removed, what might also be a good idea is an extra attribute that holds the last access date of the user, this allows for removing users that haven't
been used for a long time).

Yup, I've been cleaning those away every now and then.

/Janne

Reply via email to