Jeez..

Ok, there were "viable" other bids, but how many remained at the end of the
process, when the owners said they would only sell to Bates?  We had lots of
buyers the first time around, but when push came to shove they all
disappeared.

Simon Morris *was* involved in the ultimate redbus bid though right?

Of course the resale to Bates was the plan from the outset, who said any
different.  My point (again) is that the owners did not say they would only
sell to Bates until the last moment when it looked like another bid might be
voted for by the other creditors.  Up until that point there was no decision
to be made by them as there were no threats to Bates own bid.  Or, for the
sake of clarity, they did not have to play that card until that card needed
playing, which was right at the end, which suggests all these other bids
which were so great for the creditors, did not actually exist/were not
serious/were not viable.  If they were then the other creditors would have
indicated immediately their preference for one of those bids, and the "only
bates" card would have been played then.

And it seems you find it hard to understand how selling players to "asset
strip" could work - funny that because that's exactly what some people are
saying Bates is doing now.  Let me explain.  Sell your best players, make a
profit, trouser that profit.  Morris (and by association redbus) was alleged
to be only interested in the land, not the club itself, at the time, were
they not?

Anyway, this is all old old history, all I was trying to say was that just
as we cannot for sure say Bates was our saviour, we cannot say he was not
our saviour because we have no idea what the other owner(s) would have done
with the club, even with the best intentions (Ridsdale anyone?).

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On
Behalf Of Rick Duniec
Sent: 17 August 2011 16:15
To: [email protected]
Subject: [LU] Saviour - this old debate again (hit delete if you don't want
to read it)

The saviour issue is relevant as it was in last nights match programme.

Morris was interested and was bidding. By the final "sale" of the club by
KPMG - which was the second lot of sale bids, Redbus (who were fine on their
own) had been forced into a joint bid with Morris in order to reduce
(share) the financial risk perceived to be with regard to the Golden Share.
Redbus had previously been bidding on their own. I don't think that Redbus
would have allowed Simon Morris to front the joint bid.

The resale to Bates was THE PLAN from the outset. It wasn't something that
came up "late in the day".
What was necessary to achieve the planned objective changed as things
developed. What you describe as being the 'only option' was a deliberate
strategy to prevent the sale to any other party.
 
As far as I am aware ALL of the alternative bids were viable.  From an
ongoing  funding of the club point of view they were probably all
substantially MORE viable than the Bates position. You must have noticed
that we are underfunded since KPMGs sale to Bates' friends.

I'm NOT agreeing that somebody could have come in and sold off the players
to make a fast buck because you haven't thought it through, nor have you
added up the numbers. If you spell out what you are saying would have taken
place then that might be something to discuss. Sell off the players and then
what ? What are you suggesting ? Would the sale of the players even have
been possible ?  What types of organisations can "own" players registrations
and sell them to other clubs ?
Has what you are suggesting been done at a club before and if not, why not ?
Consider what would have happened to the Golden Share in whatever scenario
you have in mind.
_______________________________________________
Leedslist mailing list
Info and options:
http://mailman-new.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
To unsubscribe, email [email protected]

MARCHING ON TOGETHER (There's it)

_______________________________________________
Leedslist mailing list
Info and options: http://mailman-new.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
To unsubscribe, email [email protected]

MARCHING ON TOGETHER (There's it)

Reply via email to