--qxfKREH7IwbezJ+T
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Jaco Swart is on permanent record as saying:
:
:So I'm just wondering: is it worthwhile to stay with RH7.3, or should I=20
:go on to more recent distributions?  If so, which one, and why?  Opening=
=20
:a beehive here :-)

Beehive is right.  Distros and religion, dangerous territory.  I hail
from the Debian camp, but I set my sister up with Mandrake (and still
stand by that decision, although it's been ages sinc looked into suse)

Around here, you'll generally see two vocal camps: drake and gentoo.
There seems to be a fairly decent base of debian (partly thanks to
Knoppix), but we're a less vocal bunch around here.

Choose your distro based on what you want out of the system.  Gentoo is
a great learning experience, but it favours those with a good connection
and quick compiles.  Drake and suse are very much packaged user systems.
Red hat is moving into the business market. (my keyboard seems to be
dropping keystrokes.  Apologies for spelling).  Debian is still a bit of
an odd one.  It used to be the geek's own distro, but gentoo has been
picking up a lot of that, but the community still embodies the spirit.

What Debian brings to the table:
-damn good package management.
-a solid policy regarding system design.
-(a wee bit of snootiness)

on the downside:
-debian releases (official ones) are _slow_
-policies can get in the way of functionality.  If you look in the
changelog for the kernel, you'll see a list of non-free things removed.

what keeps me with Debian:
-I like the community spirit.  I send in my bug reports and occassional
patches, and try to be a good little citizen.
-I like most of the policies.  A lot of people have put together great
formulas for working system, and how to keep it as stable and safe as
possible.
-I've been using it for years, and I'm quite familiar with the layout
and the tools.  I could alias "apt-cache search", but my fingers know
the motions.

what keeps me from running off to Gentoo:
-apt-src/deb-src.  I can compile what interests me, and get the same
sort of opimisation that gentoo-ers rave about (useful, since x86 debian
packages compiled for i386)

why I originally shifted from Slackware to Debian:
-I didn't have time to keep up with maintenance.  I was generally
opposed to package management at the time (because I didn't understand
enough about how to use is properly), but I just couldn't keep
everything properly updated.  I was hit by a wu-ftp exploit and needed
to start again.  I chose Debian because it was the best of the package
management options.

All that said, each distro is a resource.  Regardless of what you
install, you can make use of any of the tools.  Look at alien for
cross-distro packaging, or apt for rpm.  Even better, look at the
documentation at each of the sites.  Especially the docs at Linux From
Scratch (www.linuxfromscratch.org)  The appendix of the documentation is
a worthy entry in the bookmarks of anyone trying to figure this whole
thing out.

Now to answer your questions. ;)

You are probably better off with a more recent distribution if you have
the opportunity to switch up.  Things change over time, and even good
choices can be superceded.

Your choice of distro is not ours to make.  We can share opinions and
experiences, but that's about it. =20

I hope that makes sense.  Don't fall into a distro just because it's got
loud supporters.  It's still just a tool.  Get what you want out of it.

(And with that, I head out of country for a few days and let mail pile
up.  Be gentle...)

Greg
--- -

--qxfKREH7IwbezJ+T
Content-Type: application/pgp-signature
Content-Disposition: inline

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.2 (GNU/Linux)

iD8DBQE/MNycGRGKEmkMxe4RAvlVAJ9UWS5sijyaQUUJaaOnWhXSpbZPIQCfR/dt
xtLA/yJceLiNZwDdJnQ15eY=
=qUw3
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--qxfKREH7IwbezJ+T--

Reply via email to