Thanks for the summary Albert. I can confirm a few points but I prefer to abstain on those I don't have a strong opinion. Answers and comments inline.
Thanks, Alberto On Fri, Jan 12, 2018 at 5:20 PM, Albert Cabellos <albert.cabel...@gmail.com> wrote: > A.- Remove definitions of PA and PI Confirm. I'm fine with LISP not being so focused on the original Internet use-case. > B.- Change definitions of EID and RLOC as ‘identifier of the overlay’ and > ‘identifier of the underlay’ respectively. Abstain. I'd prefer to avoid using "identifier" in anything regarding the underlay but I could be fine with the proposed text. > C.- In section 5.3, change the description of the encap/decap operation > concerning how to deal with ECN and DSCP bits to (new text needs to be > validated by experts): Confirm. The new text looks good to me. > D.- Simplify section ‘Router Locator Selection’ stating that the data-plane > MUST follow what´s stored in the map-cache (priorities and weights), the > remaining text should go to an OAM document. Abstain. I see the value of an independent OAM document but I don't see it as a requirement to advance 6830bis. > E.- Rewrite Section “Routing Locator Reachability” considering the following > changes: > > * Keep bullet point 1 (examine LSB), 6 (receiving a data-packet) and > Echo-Nonce > * Move to 6833bis bullet point 2 (ICMP Network/Host Unreachable),3 (hints > from BGP),4 (ICMP Port Unreachable),5 (receive a Map-Reply as a response) > and RLOC probing Abstain. I'd personally prefer to move those mechanisms that rely on control-plane messages (i.e. 5 - receive a MapReply) to the control-plane document but I'd not oppose to keep them on the data-plane doc. > F.- Move Solicit-Map-Request to 6833bis Confirm. This is one of the major results I hope to see out of this discussion. > G.- Move sections 16 (Mobility Considerations), 17 (xTR Placement > Considerations), 18 (Traceroute Consideration) to a new OAM document Abstain. Same comment as above regarding a separate OAM document. _______________________________________________ lisp mailing list lisp@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/lisp
