John B. Reynolds a �crit:
> This is am unfortunate but entirely predictable consequence of allowing the
> initial constituencies to "self-organize" - easily the worst Paris Draft
> provision to have found its way into the final DNSO structure. In the
> absence of explicit, non-ambiguous eligibility guidelines, interest groups
> are encouraged to attempt to define constituencies narrowly in order to
> control outcomes.
Possibly true, as far as the eventuality is concerned. But your
characterization of it as a consequence of the Paris Draft is
inaccurate. The other draft wanted to pre-define the constituencies
as excluding individuals, which was worse. Before making your
mistaken statements and rewriting history, you'd be better off
studying the facts and trying to get them right.
> An example of this is the case of the NCDNHC, where one
> prospective organizer is ignoring ICANN's clear mandate for individual
> participation,
Are you referring to ISOC here? I'm not aware that they have
actually said anywhere that they exclude individuals. Maybe you can
give a reference before making accusations. Unless you want to fall
into the class of posters whose members include Jeff Williams and
William Walsh.
> while the other would redefine "non-commercial" in a way that
> would disenfranchise many legitimate non-commercial organizations.
I take it you are referring to the ICIIU here. If so, your statement
is untrue. The ICIIU definition is worded specifically NOT to
disenfranchise legitimate non-commercial organizations, and to
exclude those which are illegitimately pretending to use the
non-profit corporation cover as a smokescreen for commercial
activities.
Your characterizations are inaccurate and untrue. You are spreading
false information. What is your purpose? Do you think you will get
attention by spreading lies? Maybe you will, but it won't be the
sort of attention you want, I don't think.
I am removing your name from the list of sign-ups through the ICIIU
procedure. The ICIIU is under no obligation to assist you in joining
the NCDNHC when you are spreading lies about us. You can join the
constituency on your own, or through another organization.
