Floating rules are useful for complex situations.

We requested several times the possibility to add a rule once, instead of repeating it for each interface.

If you have ten DMZ offering services, all services should ve available to WAN and to all nine DMZ, so you should add an incoming rule for each service and each interface.

With floating rule you can write this rule once and apply to all interested interfaces.

Regards,

Tonino


Il 15/12/2011 17:56, Seb ha scritto:
So, Tonino, in your example you would select all interfaces except OPT1 in your rule, and also select OUT. Correct? Because if you also select OPT1, then OUT would mean an unncessary hole in the firewall out from OPT1. On the other hand, if you didn't care about a few extra small holes in the firewall like this, you could just select all interfaces (or none, which is the same for floating rules), and then either IN or OUT or ANY and it would still pass traffic. Because it would either match the IN on the near interface, or it would match OUT on the far interface (or it would match ANY on both interfaces). Hence why I said it seems to have little relevance. But I suppose one should care about those extra few small holes in the firewall and just select all interfaces except OPT1 and IN (Or OPT1 only and OUT)... Although in my case I have a destination IP anyway - so it will not create any extra holes. Or am I still not getting what 'OUT' rules are for? I've just created 1 and it seems to work fine. [A further option with your example, I guess would be to just select OPT1 and OUT.]
Yes, I understand the benefits of floating rules.

Kind regards,

Seb

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    *From:* [email protected]
    [mailto:[email protected]] *On Behalf Of *Tonix
    (Antonio Nati) tonix-at-interazioni.it
    *Sent:* 15 December 2011 14:57
    *To:* pfSense support and discussion
    *Subject:* Re: [pfSense] 'direction' of firewall rules for
    floating rules?

    If you speak only about WAN and LAN, yes, but if you have other
    interfaces interested all changes.

    You could enable a service on the OPT1, available to all existing
    interfaces.
    So in this case, floating rule would permit any 'OUT' connection
    to that service offered inside OPT1.

    This permit you to avoid adding an incoming rule for every
    existing interface.

    Tonino



    Il 15/12/2011 15:50, Seb ha scritto:
    ...or the WAN interface and 'out'?  Is that not the same as LAN
    interface and 'in'?  And if you are selecting all interfaces,
    then surely the direction would have no effect?  Because it would
    either match on the LAN side, or the WAN side...  Or am I just
    not getting what 'out' rules are for?

    Kind regards,

    Seb

        ------------------------------------------------------------------------
        *From:* [email protected]
        [mailto:[email protected]] *On Behalf Of *Fuchs,
        Martin martin.fuchs-at-trendchiller.com
        *Sent:* 15 December 2011 13:30
        *To:* pfSense support and discussion
        *Subject:* Re: [pfSense] 'direction' of firewall rules for
        floating rules?

        Hi !

        Yes, the direction has some relevance for the floating rules,
        because when the direction  is wrong, the packets will not
        pass the firewall...

        When you want to allow a packet to pass the firewall from the
        LAN side to the WAN side you have to select the LAN interface
        and as direction you have to select "in" (from the view of
        the firewall)

        Regards,

        martin

        *Von:*[email protected]
        [mailto:[email protected]] *Im Auftrag von *Seb
        *Gesendet:* Donnerstag, 15. Dezember 2011 14:06
        *An:* 'pfSense support and discussion'
        *Betreff:* [pfSense] 'direction' of firewall rules for
        floating rules?

        Hi list,

        Does the 'direction' of a firewall rule have any relevance
        for floating rules?  I can't find any explanation for what
        direction means in the docs, even when it applies to
        individual interfaces (where I can see what it might mean),
        but for floating rules that apply to all interfaces - I don't
        suppose it changes much?  Perhaps just affects connections
        from the firewall itself if you have it set to out but not in?

        pfSense 2.0

        Kind regards,

        Seb



    _______________________________________________
    List mailing list
    [email protected]
    http://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list


-- ------------------------------------------------------------
             Inter@zioni            Interazioni di Antonio Nati
        http://www.interazioni.it       [email protected]
    ------------------------------------------------------------



_______________________________________________
List mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list


--
------------------------------------------------------------
        Inter@zioni            Interazioni di Antonio Nati
   http://www.interazioni.it      [email protected]
------------------------------------------------------------

_______________________________________________
List mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list

Reply via email to