The 3750X series is as yet unknown – I don’t have direct experience yet, nor 
does anyone I know – but the older switches I’ve used in the 3750 family are 
not very good routers, in fact roughly on par with the 1800-series routers from 
Cisco.  That is, they’re not bad, but not as good as anything with hardware 
acceleration.  I don’t think you will get hardware-accelerated routing in any 
L3-capable switch, I think you have to go up to a Nexus series switch with 
Cisco to get that.  In Juniper product, you need (roughly) an MX-series or  
T-series to get h/w-accelerated routing.  Both vendors can sell you a router 
with an embedded switch, which is a completely different product.

IMHO, for lowest jitter, use a dedicated L2 switch and a dedicated L3 router, 
and use both 802.1p and IP TOS CoS markings (and use them in the router). 

 

With pfSense, you *might* experience better performance by using individual 
interfaces instead of a tagged trunk; I know from experience that QoS suffers 
noticeably as soon as you introduce LACP LAGs into the network.  When comparing 
vyatta, keep in mind that some drivers under linux not only support polling but 
also support direct card-to-card DMA (known as “zero-copy routing”, I think), 
thus avoiding a relatively-expensive copy into and back out of main memory.

 

-Adam Thompson

[email protected]

 

 

From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On 
Behalf Of Igor Battiston
Sent: Saturday, March 17, 2012 7:41 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: [pfSense] Some questions about pps performance...

 

Hi, 

  in using pfsense 1.2 like edge router/firewall in a small voip operator, it's 
working well from several years, I can give you some 'real life' benchmark.

 

Server is:

HP DL with a 3075 XEON

hw.model: Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU            3075  @ 2.66GHz

 

Ethernet card is

HP NCT-360T

dev.em.0.%desc: Intel(R) PRO/1000 Network Connection Version - 6.2.9

dev.em.1.%desc: Intel(R) PRO/1000 Network Connection Version - 6.2.9

 

I have some vlan with inter-vlan routing/firewalling, total WAN traffic is 
around 40mbit (all RTP) small packets... I have 100mbit on the VLAN trunk 
interface...

 

In this scenario and with this hardware pfsense works well, but if I try to 
increase traffic I start to see a jitter , the CPU IRQ  load start to become 
greater than 60%... I studied a little bit about polling, with linux the e1000 
drivers have a system to mitigate interrupt load ( i didn't yet tested if linux 
has better performance than freebsd) I googled and i found some test about 
pfsense and linux (vyatta) but the test was done with realtek cards, and it's 
depends too much to the quality of the drivers....

 

 

In my opinion the 'polling' is not too bad... with a 1000hz kernel means 1ms of 
additional delay and delay it's better than jitter in rtp.

 

Do you think i can continue to use pfsense or will it be better to use an L3 
switch like cisco 3750G ? 

 

 

_______________________________________________
List mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.pfsense.org/mailman/listinfo/list

Reply via email to