Arto, 

Your reasons for leaving this community are as thoroughly immoral as those 
you claim are driving you away. One assumes that the treatment of the Iraqi 
prisoners to which you object results from them simply being Iraqis, guilt by 
association. You are seriously telling us that you no longer wish to be part of 
our lute community simply because many of us are American and British, likewise 
guilt by association. This is a typical example of stereotyping, as carried 
out by the Nazis, Communists, and indeed  the fanatics who were responsible for 
the WTC attack and many other acts of barbarity. 

By assuming that you know how we feel about the goings-on in Iraq you pretend 
to a knowledge you do not have. And even worse, you either infer that we all 
agree with such things, or simply find that being in the company of  Americans 
and British people is beneath the dignity of a man from a continent which 
produced Auschwitz, the Gulags, the Inquisition, and countless other horrors in 
its history. 

Your 'protest' is not only meaningless, but the act of a person in some ways 
even worse than those soldiers you disapprove of. If education, music, the 
arts and sciences have any value over and above themselves, then it surely ought 
to include the ability to think clearly and refrain from primitive and 
insulting insinuations, let alone condemning two entire nations for the deeds of a 
few of their citizens. What you have done with your empty gesture is thus the 
ultimate betrayal, the first in a series of steps that led to Auschwitz and the 
denial of humanity for the sake of arcane and misconceived beliefs.    

TB    

--

Reply via email to