Get your tickets to this flame war early...

Matanio Opheo wrote:

> If you are saying that some Austrians used Italianized names, you are
> breaking the lock on an open door. We know that already. If you
> intimate that just because one Austrian football coach working in
> Italy had an Italianized name, then an Austrian guitarist who was
> born in 1818 and was never in Italy could also have an Italianized
> name, without any evidence that he was so called, then allow me to
> introduce you to Giovanni Sebastiano Bach, Francesco Haydn, Roberto
> Schumann, Francesco Dolcevillico (Franz Suessmayr) and Federico Handel.

I don't know about them, but Beethoven's original title page for his 
third symphony said, in his handwriting:

Sinfonia Grande
Intitolata Buonaparte

     del Sigr

Luigi van Beethoven

According to Ferdinand Ries, when he learned that Napoleon had
crowned himself emperor, Beethoven scratched out "Buonaparte,"
leaving a hole in the page.   A new title page for the first edition 
says:

      S I N F O N I A    E R O I C A

                composta
per festiggiare il sovvenire di un grand Uomo
                 e dedicate
A Sua Altessa Serenissima in Principe di Lobkowikz
                da
          Luigi van Beethoven



To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

Reply via email to