>
> > Sorry, but HTML has (or can be used for) a semantic markup in a quite
> > comparable way. So, keeping sections, links, emphasized text, quotes,
> > ... as an option would be an enhancement.
>
> What we could do is implement some extended paste option that runs a
> converter
> (HTML->LaTeX->LyX in that case). In the same vein, LyX could import LaTeX
> snippets on the fly.
>
> But this should not _replace_ the current paste functionality, but rather
> complement it.
>
>
I agree, this could be the way to go. There could be 'paste plain' and
'paste formatted' options.
I think this is harder than it seems. Very few notetakers do this. An zero
do this consistently. On linux, none.

I use lyx for journal articles, and notetaking. On linux, it offers a better
notetaking solution than any other tool (before I was using keepnote). This
is telling: a tool that was not intended as a notetaker beats all the
specialized ones. On win, onenote does everything I need, but I wanted to
not have vendor lock-in and a plain text format. So lyx does this for me.
This is why pasting snippets from the web is important. And outputting html
trough the clipboard (something that we can sorta do with lyxblogger, but it
misses images) is damn important for me too.

One big disadvantage of using lyx is that it's hard to collaborate. Even
though the 'track changes' option is superior to anything plain latex can
offer, I still get comments on pdf edits... or worse, handwritten notes and
scanned as pdf again. this sets me back dozens of hours. I've never been
able to convince anyone to use lyx. Word users, even when show were to click
to track changes and insert notes, still edit the pdf. And you do have to
muck around with styles, layouts etc. You need to know some latex. Never
converted anyone.

For latex users, I convert to latex to get their comments. This has the
nasty property that the latest version, with all corrections, is latex, not
lyx.

All in all, I'm torn. I'm not sure I can ever circunvent the disadvantages,
and the advantages are not that great. Even though I'm a linux person, I
admit that using office well can get you close to what you want in terms of
writing structured docs. I just don't like the vendor lock-in... or having
to run windows to write papers :)


> Jürgen
>

Reply via email to