On 2010-08-21 22:35 , Macs R We wrote:

On Aug 21, 2010, at 5:55 PM, [email protected] wrote:
okay, so caches slow applications down? i suppose it can happen, but in general caches 
speed things up (why have them otherwise?) and deleting them actually slows things down 
in the short term (without even considering the time spent "cleaning" then 
rebooting)

deleting the spotlight "library" then waiting several hours for the index to 
rebuild, on the uncertain prospect that it will save a few seconds -- great strategy

This argument would be true if all the above mechanisms were implemented 100% 
correctly and suffered from no data rot or corruption problems.  But the fact 
is that it's easy to get a corrupt or inefficient Spotlight database that is 
way slower than one that is freshly rebuilt; and after months (or sometimes 
years) of use, it's worth deep-cleaning the system caches to get some boot 
speed back.

my spotlight db's never been rebuilt; it's around a year old; searches aren't slow; i'll rebuild it when i want (probably when things that should be found aren't), and without paying $19

and the OS often clears caches during OS updates anyway, which is plenty often enough for me; i rarely reboot, but if i did it a lot i'd most certainly not clear caches regularly because it would make my boot times _slower_

so i think these specific strategies are rarely needed individually, and when they are truly needed is not something an average user can discern; but my main point is that these tools are sold based on generating FUD, and with encouragement to use all of the strategies at once whenever people are not sure what to do, which will usually produce results opposite of what Mainmenu claims

_______________________________________________
MacOSX-talk mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.omnigroup.com/mailman/listinfo/macosx-talk

Reply via email to