Quoth Brian Holtz: ----- Sounds like your dispute has expanded to include whoever at LP News decided that such LNC resolutions -- I mean, "mutterings" -- and their retractions are worthy of front-page treatment over multiple issues. -----
Well, before I didn't _have_ a "dispute." Now you're pointing to something that may constitute a dispute. If the LNC has misappropriated party funds, staff time and equipment to fraudulently portray its resolutions as trumping the bylaws, then it's gone beyond bull session mutterings and into the realm of official misconduct. Hell, I may stir myself to look into the matter! ----- Since you've been a member of LNC and I haven't, I'll defer to your expertise in divining which LNC resolutions are mere "mutterings" from "bull sessions". :-) ----- Sorry, not an LNC expert here -- I was briefly a regional alternate, but I ran out of Maalox. However, the organizational principle involved is probably most easily described as similar to the legal/political equivalent in Madison v. Marbury: If the LNC does something it has no legitimate authority to do, then that action is not legitimate or authoritative. And, as courts subsequently held in the realm of government/politics, that illegitimacy/non-authoritativeness applies from the time of the action, not from the later time that some jurisprudence _finds_ it to be illegitimate/non-authoritative. In summary, the LNC has no legitimate authority to modify the bylaws, and any attempt to do so is on its face null and void, whether or not the matter has been taken up by the Judicial Committee, the national convention, etc. But in point of fact, every convention subsequent to the LNC's illegitimate/non-authoritative proclamation has affirmed the bylaws rather than the LNC's ad hoc alteration thereof, so we're in pretty good shape de jure as well as de facto. Regards, Tom Knapp
