Thomas L. Knapp wrote:

TK) every convention subsequent to the LNC's illegitimate/non-authoritative
proclamation has affirmed the bylaws (TK

BH) I'm not aware that each NatCon formally affirms the Bylaws (e.g. like
Platform retention) (BH

TK) At every national convention, it is possible to modify the bylaws (TK

At every LNC meeting, it has been possible to rescind the Dec 1992 mission
statement -- just as a 1993 LNC meeting rescinded other statements adopted
at that Dec 1992 meeting.  I guess that means that every LNC meeting since
1993 has affirmed the mission statement.  I hadn't realized that the mission
statement has commanded such an overwhelming and enduring consensus.  :-)

TK) An attempt to impose a constraint on the party to other purposes than,
or to a limited subset of, the purposes laid out in the bylaws would by
definition be void (TK

If you think that every missed opportunity to change something is a decision
to "affirm" it, then it's not surprising that you think that an attempt to
focus and inspire is actually an "attempt to impose a constraint" via open
rebellion against the Bylaws.  In reality, the radical LNC member who
resigned in response to the Dec 1992 resolutions cited only the statements
about the Pledge and the Platform, and those were precisely the two
statements that were rescinded by the LNC in 1993.  In the extensive LP News
coverage of this episode, and in the LNC email traffic on it that Carol
Moore has archived, not a single critic of the resolutions noticed that the
LNC had usurped the Bylaws.

TK) I'm fairly agnostic on the whole question of what kind of organization
the LP should be. I'd just like it to decide what kind of organization it
is. (TK

Cool, then how about helping the delegates decide whether it should be what
the Radical Caucus wants it to be, by persuading the Radical Caucus to
declare where it stands on each of the thirty provisions of my Pledge?

Reply via email to