Quoth Brian Holtz:

-----
TK) in point of fact, every convention subsequent to the LNC's
illegitimate/non-authoritative proclamation has affirmed the bylaws
rather than the LNC's ad hoc alteration thereof (TK
 
I'm not aware that each NatCon formally affirms the Bylaws (e.g. like
Platform retention), but Susan made the same claim, so maybe I'm
missing something.
-----

At every national convention, it is possible to modify the bylaws,
either through an agendaed process for considering amendments, or from
the floor via a suspension of the rules for consideration of
amendments. If a convention passes without the bylaws, or any
particular part thereof, being modified, then the bylaws, and all
particular parts thereof, have presumptively been affirmed.

-----
At any rate, the LNC's language was adopted nearly verbatim in 1998 as
a Bylaw purpose, so I don't understand your suggestion that the 1998
and subsequent NatCons have somehow disagreed with the LNC's mission
statement.
-----

The key there is "NEARLY verbatim." The LNC bull session outcome was
"_the_ mission." The convention bylaws outcome was "_a_ purpose."

I suppose we could argue word meanings. Is there any reason why
"mission" and "purpose" should be interpreted to have different
meanings from each other in this context?

"A mission statement is a brief statement of the purpose of a company
or religious or other organization."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mission_Statement

The LNC is bound by, not in a position of plenary authority to modify
or supersede, the bylaws. An attempt to impose a constraint on the
party to other purposes than, or to a limited subset of, the purposes
laid out in the bylaws would by definition be void, since the LNC
simply has no authority to do it.

-----
I'm curious what you think of my purpose proposal: "The Party's
purpose is to implement and give voice to the Statement of Principles
by uniting voters who want more liberty behind the electoral choices
that will most move public policy in a libertarian direction."
-----

Actually, I'm fairly agnostic on the whole question of what kind of
organization the LP should be. I'd just like it to decide what kind of
organization it is. If that's not a kind of organization I'm
comfortable in, I know where the door is.

Regards,
Tom Knapp

Reply via email to