Just remember, Tesla gave up on his "wireless power" idea when it became obvious that the only way to do that was with lightning.
The sun is an amazing source of energy, in fact all the energy on this planet, except for a few deep sea thermal vents, has come from the sun (meteors aren't really a useful or abundant source of energy). Photosynthesis is the real goal, and all the oil that we have comes not from dead dinosaurs but from dead algae, the most abundant form of solar energy conversion. If we could figure out how a green plant works, taking in light and water and CO2 and turning it into sugar, but stop that reaction at the point where the hydrogen atoms are liberated from the water, we would have a clean source of energy that relies only on the sun and can reuse the water over and over again. Mark On Mon, Jun 23, 2008 at 2:36 PM, Joe Perez <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > ---- [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >> >> You're assuming that the radio waves must be broadcast, that the frequencies >> must be what they are today, > > I used VHF broadcast as an example because FM and VHF television stations are > the second most powerful form of RF emission to be found in North America. > UHF television stations are the most powerful, with Equivalent Radiated Power > ratings in the 1 to 4 megawatt class, however even these must comply with > exposure guidelines, and their output power is being reduced as stations turn > off their analog carriers and go fully digital. Other sources of RF energy > such as cellular towers, satellites, 2-way radio and the like are many orders > of magnitude lower in strength. > > Additionally, the trend over the past 30 to 40 years in general has been > towards decreasing the output power of all transmitters in general, as RF > "pollution" (ie: interfereance) becomes a problem, receivers become more > sensitive and selective, and the transition towards digital modulation > increases the tolerance of receivers to noise and allows them to recover > useful signals at much lower input amplitudes than an analog system. > > So it really doesn't matter what the source is or what the frequency is- > ambient RF is simply too weak to drive a toy car, much less a real one. It's > not a matter of advanced technology, there simply isn't enough energy > floating around in the form of RF to do any useful work to begin with. > > >> ... and that the waves would be the primary source >> of "power" or "fuel" for the vehicle. As mentioned several times, if the >> waves were used to power/generate light, the light could power photovoltaic >> cells to produce electricity. > > You're joking, right? Putting aside everything we know about the state of > modern technology, it's a basic law of physics that you cannot get more power > out of a system then you put into it. By taking RF energy, rectifying it, > using it to drive a light bulb, pointing the light bulb at a photovoltaic > cell, and then using the electricity coming out the other end you will get > far less power out of the system than if you'd used the energy that drove the > light bulb directly. Even if we are using magical light bulbs and > photovoltaic cells that are 100% efficient, the power coming out the back > will only be equal to the power going in the front, which is simply too > miniscule to be of any use in the first place. > > Let's take a very simple example. You connect an AC motor directly to an AC > generator. Don't laugh, these do exist- they're called rotary phase > converters. Now, you plug the motor into an outlet, you apply a load to the > output of the generator, and you measure the work being done. No matter what > you do, no matter how efficient everything is, the amount of electricity > coming out of the generator will never be greater than the amount of > electricity going into the motor. You can wind the generator to produce a > higher voltage than the motor is getting, however the output current will be > reduced by an equal factor. Likewise you can wind for higher current, at > reduced voltage. You can change the phase, you can do all sorts of useful > things, but you cannot get more actual power out than you put in. Same as if > you shone a light bulb at a solar cell, or pointed an electric fan at a > windmill, or any other wild fantasy scenario you can come up with. > > >> As a Radio Engineer, you're aware of the progression in electronics >> capbilities today from that of only 40 years ago. What may not seem >> possible today is only development-time away. > > Yes, I am. IC semiconductor technology, DSPs, fiberoptic transmission, > satellite carriers, COFDM, all wonderful things which were probably > unimaginable to Farnsworth and Sarnoff. However none of these things violate > the First Law of Thermodynamics regarding conservation of energy in a closed > system, a basic tenet which has gone pretty much unchanged since Thales of > Miletus started pondering the nature of water in the mid 500s BC. > > > Please, just stop embarrassing yourself now. > _______________________________________________ > Miatapower mailing list > [email protected] > http://list.miatapower.net/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/miatapower > _______________________________________________ Miatapower mailing list [email protected] http://list.miatapower.net/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/miatapower
