I keep thinking about broadcast power and wondering what happens when
you accidentally make an antenna for it. The right length of fence wire,
a carelessly cut piece of metal...yikes.

Keith Tanner
Flyin' Miata
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.flyinmiata.com
1-800-FLY-MX5s (orders)
1-970-464-5600 (tech)
2008 FM Open House: August 14-17
 

> -----Original Message-----
> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
> [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Mark Cookson
> Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 3:07 PM
> To: [email protected]
> Subject: Re: NPC: NMC: Energy from Radio Waves
> 
> Just remember, Tesla gave up on his "wireless power" idea 
> when it became obvious that the only way to do that was with 
> lightning.
> 
> The sun is an amazing source of energy, in fact all the 
> energy on this planet, except for a few deep sea thermal 
> vents, has come from the sun (meteors aren't really a useful 
> or abundant source of energy).
> Photosynthesis is the real goal, and all the oil that we have 
> comes not from dead dinosaurs but from dead algae, the most 
> abundant form of solar energy conversion.
> 
> If we could figure out how a green plant works, taking in 
> light and water and CO2 and turning it into sugar, but stop 
> that reaction at the point where the hydrogen atoms are 
> liberated from the water, we would have a clean source of 
> energy that relies only on the sun and can reuse the water 
> over and over again.
> 
> Mark
> 
> On Mon, Jun 23, 2008 at 2:36 PM, Joe Perez <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > ---- [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
> >>
> >> You're assuming that the radio waves must be broadcast, that the  
> >> frequencies must be what they are today,
> >
> > I used VHF broadcast as an example because FM and VHF 
> television stations are the second most powerful form of RF 
> emission to be found in North America. UHF television 
> stations are the most powerful, with Equivalent Radiated 
> Power ratings in the 1 to 4 megawatt class, however even 
> these must comply with exposure guidelines, and their output 
> power is being reduced as stations turn off their analog 
> carriers and go fully digital. Other sources of RF energy 
> such as cellular towers, satellites, 2-way radio and the like 
> are many orders of magnitude lower in strength.
> >
> > Additionally, the trend over the past 30 to 40 years in 
> general has been towards decreasing the output power of all 
> transmitters in general, as RF "pollution" (ie: 
> interfereance) becomes a problem, receivers become more 
> sensitive and selective, and the transition towards digital 
> modulation increases the tolerance of receivers to noise and 
> allows them to recover useful signals at much lower input 
> amplitudes than an analog system.
> >
> > So it really doesn't matter what the source is or what the 
> frequency is- ambient RF is simply too weak to drive a toy 
> car, much less a real one. It's not a matter of advanced 
> technology, there simply isn't enough energy floating around 
> in the form of RF to do any useful work to begin with.
> >
> >
> >> ... and that the waves would be the primary  source of "power" or 
> >> "fuel" for the vehicle.  As mentioned several times,  if the waves 
> >> were used to power/generate light, the light could power  
> >> photovoltaic cells to produce electricity.
> >
> > You're joking, right? Putting aside everything we know 
> about the state of modern technology, it's a basic law of 
> physics that you cannot get more power out of a system then 
> you put into it. By taking RF energy, rectifying it, using it 
> to drive a light bulb, pointing the light bulb at a 
> photovoltaic cell, and then using the electricity coming out 
> the other end you will get far less power out of the system 
> than if you'd used the energy that drove the light bulb 
> directly. Even if we are using magical light bulbs and 
> photovoltaic cells that are 100% efficient, the power coming 
> out the back will only be equal to the power going in the 
> front, which is simply too miniscule to be of any use in the 
> first place.
> >
> > Let's take a very simple example. You connect an AC motor 
> directly to an AC generator. Don't laugh, these do exist- 
> they're called rotary phase converters. Now, you plug the 
> motor into an outlet, you apply a load to the output of the 
> generator, and you measure the work being done. No matter 
> what you do, no matter how efficient everything is, the 
> amount of electricity coming out of the generator will never 
> be greater than the amount of electricity going into the 
> motor. You can wind the generator to produce a higher voltage 
> than the motor is getting, however the output current will be 
> reduced by an equal factor. Likewise you can wind for higher 
> current, at reduced voltage. You can change the phase, you 
> can do all sorts of useful things, but you cannot get more 
> actual power out than you put in. Same as if you shone a 
> light bulb at a solar cell, or pointed an electric fan at a 
> windmill, or any other wild fantasy scenario you can come up with.
> >
> >
> >> As a Radio Engineer, you're aware of the progression in 
> electronics 
> >> capbilities today from that of only 40 years ago.  What 
> may not seem 
> >> possible today is only development-time away.
> >
> > Yes, I am. IC semiconductor technology, DSPs, fiberoptic 
> transmission, satellite carriers, COFDM, all wonderful things 
> which were probably unimaginable to Farnsworth and Sarnoff. 
> However none of these things violate the First Law of 
> Thermodynamics regarding conservation of energy in a closed 
> system, a basic tenet which has gone pretty much unchanged 
> since Thales of Miletus started pondering the nature of water 
> in the mid 500s BC.
> >
> >
> > Please, just stop embarrassing yourself now.
> > _______________________________________________
> > Miatapower mailing list
> > [email protected]
> > http://list.miatapower.net/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/miatapower
> >
> _______________________________________________
> Miatapower mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://list.miatapower.net/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/miatapower
> 
_______________________________________________
Miatapower mailing list
[email protected]
http://list.miatapower.net/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/miatapower

Reply via email to