I agree except the issue is really wider. The big thing we haven't recognised is that we have become very productive, but not learned to focus work around what needs doing, or our populations around what they can do and need to do to be healthy, citizens and expect a fair share. I don't think families are the only way to bring up kids; we could have more communal alternatives as well. Kids are definitely used here by a large number of crap parents (single and otherwise) to draw benefits and engage in welfare-sponsored crime and drug habits. Schools work OK until kids are about ten. The they get too big. Utterly crap adult behaviour is responsible for making these problems generational. I doubt the problems have got much worse because of one single factor. Most of the kids causing trouble don't come from homes where there would be a 'feminist'. My guess is we need to be able to raise 'restructuring' as an issue that can attract and keep attention. Feminism was able to do this because the chattering classes loved it. Racism has been much the same, though I hardly meet anyone who knows what it really is. Sweden, Norway and Finland have great child care systems compared to ours and I always felt the ethos was about everyone's kids not just your own. Feminism and racism aren't real attacks on 'citadel wealth and unfairness' somehow. They can always stick up a token black or female person without changing anything. I only mentioned the blind thing because I just don't see why my mate or my partner are not equals because they are disabled. Underlying this is the rather confusing notion that equality starts in wanting to be fair to and help others, not some crazy idea we all have to sprint like Ussain Bolt to be equal. Any idiot can see we are not equal, and that not all work or non-work deserves equal reward. This doesn't prevent equality from containing a levelling-up notion, or one of levelling-down in some aspects. And we have to be 'particular', recognise individual circumstances and that some cases won't fit our model.
On 18 Oct, 17:35, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote: > It's all good Archy, though I don't get the blind analogy, the gender > issue has varying degrees of complexity, I think Fran's post > definitely covers the most of it. The fuzzy boundaries as you put it > is by all accounts a problem with analysis. Internet communication and > interpretation leave contribute much the the fuzzy. But consider that > when I'm posing the question of nurturing and the abandonment of such > I'm not really suggesting that women go back to barefoot and pregnant > as has been mostly perceived in the thread but in all reality what I'm > looking at is recognition of a problem with that abandonment and the > challenge to society to address it IF they are just going to hand out > rights without evaluation of the ramifications. Sure it's okay for to > change traditional roles but did the government ever think about who > was going to take care of the kids? Serious contemplation should > have been put into enacting laws and regulations to allow corporate > accommodation of such transitions. Instead kids come home to an empty > house or go off to some day care place while at the same time are > eating less nutritionally. If I'm not clear here let me say that we > have let the chickens out of the coop and no one is sitting on the > eggs. Sure there are exceptions like stay at home dads but that is > not the majority. > I think many corporate job roles can be accomplished in a work at home > environment, we as society need to "restructure" to allow for feminism > without the "fallout". Can we expand on that? > > On Oct 18, 7:47 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > Inequality sickens me Slip and by equality I don't mean uniformity. > > Terms like this that we can't pin down should not deter us. My best > > mate is blind. I don't think of him as unequal when I show him across > > a road (etc. - some might say the dog tows both of us). I'm just > > doing something I'm better at. Want to placate the university > > administration, send in my mate to do something he's better at. Sure > > there are examples that don't fit even these fuzzy boundaries, but > > even science is like that. One can establish a core principle and see > > what happens in the practice of evidence, without all being crashed by > > a counterexample (otherwise we would have no logic at all). > > > In some areas, we have almost no ability for open discourse (maybe > > most). Connections, such as the speculative links between functional > > illiteracy-innumeracy and nurturing mothers (where are the fathers > > too?), perhaps families, may be wrong but we should be looking into > > them. I'd guess our crappy celebrity society has a lot to do with all > > that. Finland manages to be much better in education, yet life- > > expectancy there ain't good (booze). I'm not keen on solutions > > involving a return to the kitchen and children for women, but if there > > is some kind of 'gap' we should identify it and look for > > alternatives. Indeed, it's much too late. We need to engage here > > without simply trying to rationalise the reactionary cause (no > > accusations here mate). > > > My sense is the equality we are looking for is fuzzy (but not > > woolly). I don't see gender having much to do with what I want as it > > follows if we're equal we're equal. Someone's just repeated some > > research I did 30 years ago - sending job applications of equal merit > > to employers but with race-identifying names. The black and brown > > names were about half as likely to get an interview. They didn't > > repeat my disability study (where things were much worse), or the > > gender one in which declaring homosexuality proved a no no. There's a > > lot we could work out from some basic numbers, but even this is > > stopped for fear of looking sexist, racist and so on or exposing the > > same. > > > Personally, I sick of the category 'women'. 'Women' don't make it to > > the top jobs. Well triple A women actually do and do better at first > > than the equivalent men. By the time you are in your thirties are you > > still primarily categorisable as a girl or boy, straight or gay (you > > want to see research here on how many 'categories' there are in gay > > language)? Surely we should be looking at experience, ability and so > > on. Do women with all this actually do any worse than men? Stuff > > like taking time to rear kids doesn't wash. I can't say that I took 5 > > or 10 years out for 'personal reasons'. However, the issue here is > > not gender inequality (increasingly operating by stiffing men), it's > > the fact we are still serfs. All our work lives could and should > > allow us all time out. And we should remember that research always, > > year on year, shows recruitment and selection is just a hornswaggle > > industry. And what about the 'top jobs' - millionaires kicking pigs' > > bladders and bwankers waving Sooty's Magic Wand over routine counting > > process and software they don't understand, bastard bureaucrats lying > > about performance while kids die - the system is bent. Women have > > changed none of this and it's been getting worse. > > > Police sick leave is up and so are the numbers of women officers. Who > > knows, but we should be able to ask the questions. If women need more > > time off, then let men have it too. > > > I believe we could get to a fairer society, consume less yet have more > > (let alone be more). If you look at the PISA studies of the OECD, > > you'll find only 1.3% of 15 year-olds can handle 'difficult' (old > > hands like me can do it with eyes shut kind of stuff) science. I've > > years of experience teaching critical reasoning and would suggest a 5% > > competence and 20% 'likely to get more right than wrong' samples in > > our general population (this doesn't vary that much with education if > > one uses tests relevant to specific societies). The rest are a herd - > > in fact more than this, plenty who can reason don't once someone else > > has made a public decision. The idea of shaping-up to the facts of > > human society is surely that things don't need to be so bad and > > wouldn't be if we were more honest and thought a lot more through. > > > I'd say men's attitudes towards women are still broadly dismal. If > > Sue and I were younger and having kids, we'd at least try and share > > the work (home and employment). But there is really no balance > > available because we are serfs who have to work, we are not really in > > charge of ourselves or our lives. This is largely because most effort > > in the world is wasted, most jobs are bullshit and politics run by > > children. My guess is most jobs could be done by almost anyone after > > a few weeks immersion in them and some training (most training is > > wasted and really amounts to 'ranking'). It's a mistake to confuse > > the mainstream with sporting freakery. > > > Good start Slip, but more traces to kick over - I mean why would we > > want to send women back into the kitchen when men are so much the > > better chefs! > > > On 18 Oct, 10:50, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > I think Arch is right in that feminism really hasn't accomplished much > > > save for a handful, and the rest of us are stuck with a bunch of > > > bimbos shoved on us because of rights. > > > > Okay Orn, I 'was' in a hurry at the time, ergo, the typos. > > > > But I'll break it down more here because it's early morning and I have > > > quiet time. > > > > “My point has been that > > > gender recognition and consideration is not without importance (fact > > > IS, gender recognition and consideration IS already in effect in many > > > areas, 'Including those areas where women are currently holding > > > positions' it would be imprudent to just hire someone for a position > > > without considering their gender) Fact is also that standards have > > > been "lowered" in the military for "accommodate" women. > > > and so gender > > > should not be excluded forced upon us as a politically correct, or > > > affirmative action decree. (exactly, a woman should not secure > > > employment based upon her gender or race but upon her qualifications, > > > I don't see the difficulty in that view nor the allusion to > > > chauvinism) > > > > It's wrong to force companies to hire > > > less qualified people based upon their gender or race. (so what's the > > > problem with that?) When there is a racial or gender quota forced upon > > > a company the employment ad might as well read "........no > > > qualifications necessary, must be dark skin female.) > > > > If I had a > > > construction company, why would I want to have a female workforce > > > when > > > I can get more work done with men? (It's a fact that a male work > > > force can accomplish more and I repeat that the strongest woman in the > > > world is not stronger than the strongest man in the world, so why > > > would I hire her when I could hire him in consideration of my > > > corporate success. I've seen women on construction jobs and the truth > > > is they can't perform consistently all day, they get tired earlier and > > > their periods and pms interferes as well. This is not chauvinism, > > > it's observation and personal experience. When I was in retail the > > > women were the best sales reps, when I was in construction the women > > > were competent painters but failed in tapping and floating, carrying > > > lumber and mixing cement and other physically demanding roles. > > > > I don't have a problem with women doctors, lawyers, scientists or any > > > other role where they can perform equally but that is not the case in > > > all areas, across the board.) Women should be anything they "Could" > > > be but they shouldn't be anything they "Cant" be. I don't see what > > > the big fuss is all about. Women will always be and nothing is going > > > to change it. > > > > As a wealthy nation we are failing miserably. > > > More than three out of four of those on welfare, 85% of unwed mothers > > > and 68% of those > > ... > > read more » --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
