Slip, thanks for the unpacking of your thoughts!

More clarification on my view associated with your words follows:

“…My point has been that gender recognition and consideration is not
without importance (fact IS, gender recognition and consideration IS
already in effect in many areas, 'Including those areas where women
are currently holding positions' it would be imprudent to just hire
someone for a position without considering their gender)…” – SD

While I have no doubt that a person’s gender is noticed when applying
for a job and it is a fact that employers are legally allowed (here in
the USA) to ask about a person’s gender, I know of no one who has
‘just hired someone for a position’ BECAUSE of gender. Stephen Colbert
aside, few don’t notice race when in the interview process either. In
neither case nor all others is it suggested that such an innate
ability to discriminate, meaning being able to see or make fine
distinctions, need be surgically removed from our psyches nor the
process.

“… Fact is also that standards have been "lowered" in the military for
"accommodate" women. and so gender should not be excluded  forced upon
us as a politically correct, or affirmative action decree. (exactly, a
woman should not secure employment based upon her gender or race but
upon her qualifications, I don't see the difficulty in that view nor
the allusion to chauvinism)…” – SD

First, I must admit some ignorance about the details surrounding women
in the US military and associated standards. I’ve heard some things
and seen other things implied in the media and entertainment business.
This said, what you have said above, to me at least, implies something
that is exactly the ‘difficulty’ I’ve been suggesting. Doing a little
deconstruction, your commentary about the military (US only
apparently) seems to suggest that the military is not as effective as
it was or could be without women. I don’t see this as being
demonstrated nor as being fact. If you don’t mean to tacitly imply
this, OK, but it sure looks like this is your meaning.

As an aside, I hold a similar prejudice about military standards being
‘lowered’ when applied to the last few years when they were unable to
fill the ranks with more cannon fodder and decided to not only allow
those with lower IQs to take up arms but to allow felons too,
something new and appropriate for the Bush regime. End of small
political rant/excursion.

Further, you use the phrase ‘forced upon us as a politically
correct.’ (sic.) Again, guessing at your meaning, the phrase
‘politically correct’ is all too often used merely as a pejorative. In
the current context, I can only guess it is used to ‘support’ your
view about maintaining personal right(s) when it comes to the role of
an employer, especially when used with the term ‘forced’. The same is
often imputed to the term ‘affirmative action decree’, although not as
transparently. As far as I know, current law only says that one cannot
deny employment based upon gender. It says nothing about specific
physical, mental or emotional traits, at least not in the current
context. Again, IF I have misconstrued your intended meaning, sorry.

“… It's wrong to force companies to hire less qualified people based
upon their gender or race….” – SD

So, here is where I see our apparent divide Slip. I do not see ANYONE
being “forced...to hire less qualified people based upon their gender
or race”. Apparently you do. Again, I do not claim full expertise on
the subject yet do have some experience, education and training on it.
I do see the legal intent and word saying that people cannot deny
employment based upon gender etc. I also see this as not a political
issue so much as merely being a human being and knowing our full
essential equality and the need to be able to reject the use of
prejudice when it comes to our welfare. You continue with:

“…  (so what's the problem with that?) When there is a racial or
gender quota forced upon a company the employment ad might as well
read "........no qualifications necessary, must be dark skin female.)
…” – SD

This again appears to be presenting the view and perceived fact that
‘we’ are being forced to hire people when the truth, as far as I can
tell, is something different. When one takes the defensive position
that they do not want to have governmental impositions involved with
their businesses, such a view all too often requires very selective
‘facts’. The only ‘imposition’ I see being ‘forced’ upon people is to
require a person to demonstrate that they are not using prejudices
when it comes to employment, something that I am sure is distasteful
for many. This in no way makes such a codified ethos something that is
NOT for the common good. And, your humor about the employment ad
shines a light on the underlying belief, one that as far as I can tell
is not well founded. Perhaps it would take a different topic to do the
analysis justice, but an associated issue would be that of metrics.
This is something all good business people are at least aware of. And,
other than using metrics, what would you use to demonstrate a lack of
prejudice? Of course, even allowing this sort of reasoning into the
thread implies universal and universally accepted quotas, something I
am not advocating.

“..If I had a construction company, why would I want to have a female
workforce when I can get more work done with men?...” – SD

First, no one has even suggested that you, or anyone else for that
matter, need to ‘have a female workforce’. Hyperbole has its place –
here it distorts. And, I must admit to having a difficult time with
the slave/master stance of ‘getting more work done with…”. However, I
will do my best to not bring this into the discussion too.

“…  (It's a fact that a male work force can accomplish more and I
repeat that the strongest woman in the world is not stronger than the
strongest man in the world, so why would I hire her when I could hire
him in consideration of my corporate success….” – SD

Well, this includes many assumptions. A little deconstruction again is
in order. While I accept that your personal observation/experience
might see that this is the case, I can only guess the following:

You have never had a female work force.
Your belief that “a male work force can accomplish more” is not
supported by peer reviewed studies.
You equate ‘accomplishment’ with strength in the current context.
You believe that having stronger (physically) people working for you
is directly linked to your financial success.
You look for no other qualities when hiring employees. (I don’t really
believe this last one, but is my own hyperbolic comment.)
I will not add to the length of this post by addressing your
apparently rhetorical question of ‘why would I hire her’, but suggest
that many answers are available.

Also, I do appreciate you sharing your personal experiences in the
work world. And, while many of them may appear to not be founded on
chauvinism, I’m not convinced this is not the case.

“…There is more to this pathetic saga and I'm wondering "who is
raising our children and is the abandonment of traditional nurturing
roles by women affecting our children.   Is having a career, driving a
truck, being a soldier or having a construction job more important
than nurturing our children?” - SD

Your attempt at associating many of the US’s recent apparent “pathetic
saga” with equal rights for women in the workplace just doesn’t hold
water. It MIGHT if one makes many unnecessary assumptions. A few would
include:

The woman is the one to raise the child.
The man is the one to ‘bring home the bacon’.
No other system can work.
Your long ‘pathetic saga’ list is all caused by and based upon the
“the abandonment of traditional nurturing roles…”.
What has been ‘traditional’ in the recent past in the US regarding
‘nurturing roles’ is superior to other traditions.

“The universe is change; our life is what our thoughts make it.” -
Marcus Aurelius Antoninus (121 AD - 180 AD), Meditations






On Oct 18, 2:50 am, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote:
> I think Arch is right in that feminism really hasn't accomplished much
> save for a handful, and the rest of us are stuck with a bunch of
> bimbos shoved on us because of rights.
>
> Okay Orn, I 'was' in a hurry at the time, ergo, the typos.
>
> But I'll break it down more here because it's early morning and I have
> quiet time.
>
> “My point has been that
> gender recognition and consideration is not without importance (fact
> IS, gender recognition and consideration IS already in effect in many
> areas, 'Including those areas where women are currently holding
> positions' it would be imprudent to just hire someone for a position
> without considering their gender)  Fact is also that standards have
> been "lowered" in the military for "accommodate" women.
> and so gender
> should not be excluded  forced upon us as a politically correct, or
> affirmative action decree. (exactly, a woman should not secure
> employment based upon her gender or race but  upon her qualifications,
> I don't see the difficulty in that view nor the allusion to
> chauvinism)
>
>  It's wrong to force companies to hire
> less qualified people based upon their gender or race.  (so what's the
> problem with that?) When there is a racial or gender quota forced upon
> a company the employment ad might as well read "........no
> qualifications necessary, must be dark skin female.)
>
> If I had a
> construction company, why would I want to have a female workforce
> when
> I can get more work done with men?  (It's a fact that a male work
> force can accomplish more and I repeat that the strongest woman in the
> world is not stronger than the strongest man in the world, so why
> would I hire her when I could hire him in consideration of my
> corporate success.  I've seen women on construction jobs and the truth
> is they can't perform consistently all day, they get tired earlier and
> their periods and pms interferes as well.  This is not chauvinism,
> it's observation and personal experience.  When I was in retail the
> women were the best sales reps, when I was in construction the women
> were competent painters but failed in tapping and floating, carrying
> lumber and mixing cement and other physically demanding roles.
>
> I don't have a problem with women doctors, lawyers, scientists or any
> other role where they can perform equally but that is not the case in
> all areas, across the board.)  Women should be anything they "Could"
> be but they shouldn't be anything they "Cant" be.   I don't see what
> the big fuss is all about.  Women will always be and nothing is going
> to change it.
>
> As a wealthy nation we are failing miserably.
> More than three out of four of those on welfare, 85% of unwed mothers
> and 68% of those arrested are illiterate. About three in five of
> America's prison inmates are illiterate>Washington literacy council
>
> More than 20 percent of adults read at or below a fifth-grade level -
> far below the level needed to earn a living wage. >National Institute
> for Literacy
>
> Approximately 50 percent of the nation's unemployed youth age 16-21
> are functional illiterate, with virtually no prospects of obtaining
> good jobs. >U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
>
> 44 million adults in the U.S. can't read well enough to read a simple
> story to a child.>National Adult Literacy Survey (1992) NCED, U.S.
> Department of Education
>
> Nearly half of America's adults are poor readers, or "functionally
> illiterate." They can't carry out simply tasks like balancing check
> books, reading drug labels or writing essays for a job. >National
> Adult Literacy Survery of 1993
>
> There is more to this pathetic saga and I'm wondering "who is raising
> our children and is the abandonment of traditional nurturing roles by
> women affecting our children.   Is having a career, driving a truck,
> being a soldier or having a construction job more important than
> nurturing our children?
>

--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
""Minds Eye"" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to