That true On Sun, Oct 18, 2009 at 3:32 PM, archytas <[email protected]> wrote:
> > I have to grant you the kitchen prowess Doris. I just think once one > has decided on equality there's no room for all this gender stuff, > though it's obviously true that women are often discriminated against > or (sometimes) treated more positively. > > On 18 Oct, 22:35, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > > Slip, thanks for the unpacking of your thoughts! > > > > More clarification on my view associated with your words follows: > > > > “…My point has been that gender recognition and consideration is not > > without importance (fact IS, gender recognition and consideration IS > > already in effect in many areas, 'Including those areas where women > > are currently holding positions' it would be imprudent to just hire > > someone for a position without considering their gender)…” – SD > > > > While I have no doubt that a person’s gender is noticed when applying > > for a job and it is a fact that employers are legally allowed (here in > > the USA) to ask about a person’s gender, I know of no one who has > > ‘just hired someone for a position’ BECAUSE of gender. Stephen Colbert > > aside, few don’t notice race when in the interview process either. In > > neither case nor all others is it suggested that such an innate > > ability to discriminate, meaning being able to see or make fine > > distinctions, need be surgically removed from our psyches nor the > > process. > > > > “… Fact is also that standards have been "lowered" in the military for > > "accommodate" women. and so gender should not be excluded forced upon > > us as a politically correct, or affirmative action decree. (exactly, a > > woman should not secure employment based upon her gender or race but > > upon her qualifications, I don't see the difficulty in that view nor > > the allusion to chauvinism)…” – SD > > > > First, I must admit some ignorance about the details surrounding women > > in the US military and associated standards. I’ve heard some things > > and seen other things implied in the media and entertainment business. > > This said, what you have said above, to me at least, implies something > > that is exactly the ‘difficulty’ I’ve been suggesting. Doing a little > > deconstruction, your commentary about the military (US only > > apparently) seems to suggest that the military is not as effective as > > it was or could be without women. I don’t see this as being > > demonstrated nor as being fact. If you don’t mean to tacitly imply > > this, OK, but it sure looks like this is your meaning. > > > > As an aside, I hold a similar prejudice about military standards being > > ‘lowered’ when applied to the last few years when they were unable to > > fill the ranks with more cannon fodder and decided to not only allow > > those with lower IQs to take up arms but to allow felons too, > > something new and appropriate for the Bush regime. End of small > > political rant/excursion. > > > > Further, you use the phrase ‘forced upon us as a politically > > correct.’ (sic.) Again, guessing at your meaning, the phrase > > ‘politically correct’ is all too often used merely as a pejorative. In > > the current context, I can only guess it is used to ‘support’ your > > view about maintaining personal right(s) when it comes to the role of > > an employer, especially when used with the term ‘forced’. The same is > > often imputed to the term ‘affirmative action decree’, although not as > > transparently. As far as I know, current law only says that one cannot > > deny employment based upon gender. It says nothing about specific > > physical, mental or emotional traits, at least not in the current > > context. Again, IF I have misconstrued your intended meaning, sorry. > > > > “… It's wrong to force companies to hire less qualified people based > > upon their gender or race….” – SD > > > > So, here is where I see our apparent divide Slip. I do not see ANYONE > > being “forced...to hire less qualified people based upon their gender > > or race”. Apparently you do. Again, I do not claim full expertise on > > the subject yet do have some experience, education and training on it. > > I do see the legal intent and word saying that people cannot deny > > employment based upon gender etc. I also see this as not a political > > issue so much as merely being a human being and knowing our full > > essential equality and the need to be able to reject the use of > > prejudice when it comes to our welfare. You continue with: > > > > “… (so what's the problem with that?) When there is a racial or > > gender quota forced upon a company the employment ad might as well > > read "........no qualifications necessary, must be dark skin female.) > > …” – SD > > > > This again appears to be presenting the view and perceived fact that > > ‘we’ are being forced to hire people when the truth, as far as I can > > tell, is something different. When one takes the defensive position > > that they do not want to have governmental impositions involved with > > their businesses, such a view all too often requires very selective > > ‘facts’. The only ‘imposition’ I see being ‘forced’ upon people is to > > require a person to demonstrate that they are not using prejudices > > when it comes to employment, something that I am sure is distasteful > > for many. This in no way makes such a codified ethos something that is > > NOT for the common good. And, your humor about the employment ad > > shines a light on the underlying belief, one that as far as I can tell > > is not well founded. Perhaps it would take a different topic to do the > > analysis justice, but an associated issue would be that of metrics. > > This is something all good business people are at least aware of. And, > > other than using metrics, what would you use to demonstrate a lack of > > prejudice? Of course, even allowing this sort of reasoning into the > > thread implies universal and universally accepted quotas, something I > > am not advocating. > > > > “..If I had a construction company, why would I want to have a female > > workforce when I can get more work done with men?...” – SD > > > > First, no one has even suggested that you, or anyone else for that > > matter, need to ‘have a female workforce’. Hyperbole has its place – > > here it distorts. And, I must admit to having a difficult time with > > the slave/master stance of ‘getting more work done with…”. However, I > > will do my best to not bring this into the discussion too. > > > > “… (It's a fact that a male work force can accomplish more and I > > repeat that the strongest woman in the world is not stronger than the > > strongest man in the world, so why would I hire her when I could hire > > him in consideration of my corporate success….” – SD > > > > Well, this includes many assumptions. A little deconstruction again is > > in order. While I accept that your personal observation/experience > > might see that this is the case, I can only guess the following: > > > > You have never had a female work force. > > Your belief that “a male work force can accomplish more” is not > > supported by peer reviewed studies. > > You equate ‘accomplishment’ with strength in the current context. > > You believe that having stronger (physically) people working for you > > is directly linked to your financial success. > > You look for no other qualities when hiring employees. (I don’t really > > believe this last one, but is my own hyperbolic comment.) > > I will not add to the length of this post by addressing your > > apparently rhetorical question of ‘why would I hire her’, but suggest > > that many answers are available. > > > > Also, I do appreciate you sharing your personal experiences in the > > work world. And, while many of them may appear to not be founded on > > chauvinism, I’m not convinced this is not the case. > > > > “…There is more to this pathetic saga and I'm wondering "who is > > raising our children and is the abandonment of traditional nurturing > > roles by women affecting our children. Is having a career, driving a > > truck, being a soldier or having a construction job more important > > than nurturing our children?” - SD > > > > Your attempt at associating many of the US’s recent apparent “pathetic > > saga” with equal rights for women in the workplace just doesn’t hold > > water. It MIGHT if one makes many unnecessary assumptions. A few would > > include: > > > > The woman is the one to raise the child. > > The man is the one to ‘bring home the bacon’. > > No other system can work. > > Your long ‘pathetic saga’ list is all caused by and based upon the > > “the abandonment of traditional nurturing roles…”. > > What has been ‘traditional’ in the recent past in the US regarding > > ‘nurturing roles’ is superior to other traditions. > > > > “The universe is change; our life is what our thoughts make it.” - > > Marcus Aurelius Antoninus (121 AD - 180 AD), Meditations > > > > On Oct 18, 2:50 am, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > > > > I think Arch is right in that feminism really hasn't accomplished much > > > save for a handful, and the rest of us are stuck with a bunch of > > > bimbos shoved on us because of rights. > > > > > Okay Orn, I 'was' in a hurry at the time, ergo, the typos. > > > > > But I'll break it down more here because it's early morning and I have > > > quiet time. > > > > > “My point has been that > > > gender recognition and consideration is not without importance (fact > > > IS, gender recognition and consideration IS already in effect in many > > > areas, 'Including those areas where women are currently holding > > > positions' it would be imprudent to just hire someone for a position > > > without considering their gender) Fact is also that standards have > > > been "lowered" in the military for "accommodate" women. > > > and so gender > > > should not be excluded forced upon us as a politically correct, or > > > affirmative action decree. (exactly, a woman should not secure > > > employment based upon her gender or race but upon her qualifications, > > > I don't see the difficulty in that view nor the allusion to > > > chauvinism) > > > > > It's wrong to force companies to hire > > > less qualified people based upon their gender or race. (so what's the > > > problem with that?) When there is a racial or gender quota forced upon > > > a company the employment ad might as well read "........no > > > qualifications necessary, must be dark skin female.) > > > > > If I had a > > > construction company, why would I want to have a female workforce > > > when > > > I can get more work done with men? (It's a fact that a male work > > > force can > > > > ... > > > > read more » > > > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
