Your analysis is quite to the mark Neil.

In some universal sense,  Vox populi, vox dei is valid commentary.
Yet, we do know the apparent madness involved too. There is no
contradiction. All great ‘priests’ that I know of say to validate and
prove all for one’s own self. With this, I agree, thus the scientific
method remains pure in this sense too.

History is peppered and illuminated by those who venture into
Tiananmen Square. Anything else is the stuff of eternal death.

Hierarchies exist and are natural...although when it comes to essence,
being one, the notion is not applicable. And, there are countless
paths on the road – each having its function – each appropriate for a
specific stage/state of development. Great teachers can speak to each
existent level of apprehension.

“Chants not heard” are only missed by those without ears to hear. The
music of the spheres is one with it.

Vox populi, vox dei!!!


On Oct 29, 10:20 pm, archytas <[email protected]> wrote:
> The denial of sainthood story more or less gets to Kierkegaard's type
> of humour Riggers.  The 'poverty sketch' in Monty Python is another -
> each tells a story of desperate poverty only to be capped by the
> next.  The claim to have lived in a shoebox on the M6 central
> reservation capped by the envious question, 'you had a shoebox'?  The
> classic work is 'Humour and Irony in Kierkegaard's Thought' by John
> Lippitt (about 2000 and vastly expensive).  He never tired of teasing
> Danish Christians that they could not be so because of how they lived.
>
> There's a point in satirical work when one tires of the laughter,
> recognising the truth is being told, including the hopeless truth that
> all we can do is mock, perhaps only be spectators to the mocking by
> the professional mocksters when what we need is actual politics.  It
> becomes a safety valve that prevents the direct action we need.  My
> own reticence on the 'power of prayer' stems from something similar  -
> it's a sort of Samizdat in which we can get private relief but dare
> not be associated with in public.  Maybe we could consider today's
> politicians as priests who prevent us (metaphorically) communing
> directly with god.  They certainly read to us from hymn sheets in
> Latin!
>
> I watched some dreadful BBC thing the other night on Warren Buffett.
> The presenter is an odious crawler.  In the course of an hour, I learn
> his success is down to Dale Carnegie and techniques anyone could
> master in a few weeks.  This explains precisely nothing, no doubt the
> point.  The BBC butt-licker earns his corn, slimeing about like Uriah
> Heep.  Gates makes a brief appearance, but is not asked why inferior
> Microsoft products dominate the world.  We get to know nothing other
> than chronic lies about 'success'.  The BBC toady ponces about being
> sincere, whilst actually lying through his teeth.  There is, of
> course, no secret revealed, just naff lies.  Kierkegaard teaches this,
> that we back off from any real search for truth and this was Freud's
> point.
>
> It's no secret, I hope, that I like Orn.  He's helped turn me on
> again.  In academe, much of what he says is represented by the
> phenomenological turn (it's holy scripts are the unreadable Husserl),
> perhaps the process of revelation of the introspection of flow of
> consciousness.  Kierkegaard is in this line.  It is not as lost to
> science as Allan Wallace claims, but it is lost in the mannered
> society of glossed presentation (including, to use Gabby's term,
> 'Mind's Ayer' - a gem).  What I'm interested in is the loss of
> religious trust (I do not hanker for the old ways back), something we
> can grok without losing intellectual critique, but does not give us up
> to the intellectual knower and brings about a fellowship in which
> Reason arises.  This cannot be a Reason of the intellectuals,
> precluding those (most) who do not reason well.  People like Gadamer
> (not of Galactica) and Habermas have sought to use techniques of
> hermeneutics (once double, now quadruple) to guarantee truth or at
> least communication with ideology extirpated to leave only the force
> of Reason in mutual understanding - this has much similarity with
> contemplation and meditation - yet if the proof of the pudding is in
> the eating we can rest assured we will not get to taste.  The question
> in religion and politics might well be how we come to truth without
> hierarchy (a word with very religious origins) with secret rituals of
> purification or secret relations with god (Pope Blair's last refuge as
> a war criminal).
>
> On 30 Oct, 04:03, rigsy03 <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>
>
> > There was a story that Thomas A Kempis was buried alive and when
> > considered for sainthood they discovered he had tried to claw his way
> > out of his coffin thus Church officials deemed he despaired of God's
> > everlasting mercy. He wrote "The Imitation of Christ"- meditations/
> > devotions.
>
> > On Oct 29, 4:47 pm, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> > > While being a bit of the pop philosophy/psychology, some interesting
> > > points are made here. What do you think?
>
> > > “All progress paves over some bit of knowledge or washes away some
> > > valuable practice. Within a few years, e-mail and Twitter moved the
> > > art of letter writing to the trash bin. And in an age when all psychic
> > > life is being understood in terms of neurotransmitters, the art of
> > > introspection has been become passé. Galileos of the inner world, such
> > > as Soren Kierkegaard (1813-1855), have been packed off to the museum
> > > of antiquated ideas. Yet I think that the great and highly quirky Dane
> > > could help us to retrieve a distinction that has been effaced.
>
> > > These days, confide to someone that you are in despair and he or she
> > > will likely suggest that you seek out professional help for your
> > > depression. While despair used to be classified as one of the seven
> > > deadly sins, it has now been medicalized and folded into the concept
> > > of clinical depression. If Kierkegaard were on Facebook or could post
> > > a You Tube video, he would certainly complain that we, who have
> > > listened to Prozac, have become deaf to the ancient distinction
> > > between psychological and spiritual disorders, between depression and
> > > despair.
>
> > > There is abundant chatter today about “being spiritual” but scarcely
> > > anyone believes that a person can be of troubled mind and healthy
> > > spirit. Nor can we fathom the idea that the happy wanderer, who is all
> > > smiles and has accomplished everything on his or her self-fulfillment
> > > list, is, in fact, a case of despair. But while Kierkegaard would have
> > > agreed that happiness and melancholy are mutually exclusive, he warns,
> > > “Happiness is the greatest hiding place for despair.” …” – Gordon
> > > Marino, Kierkegaard on the Couch, The New York Times, 10/28/09
>
> > > For the rest of the story, go 
> > > to:http://happydays.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/10/28/kierkegaard-on-the-couch/-
> > >  Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
""Minds Eye"" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to