I'd like to know how - I feel it must be possible from the ways I have taught.
On 30 Oct, 21:54, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > “…Many cannot take the discomforts of thinking in critical degrees. > Contradictions arise everywhere….” - Neil > > “…What would be important Orn, is some means of communication and > stuff people can do, to glean insight without the intellectual > strain….” – Neil > > Yes, precisely to both. As suggested by the ‘reflections’ from one of > the ancient mystery schools, exact methodology which does not require > intellectualism, although does not exclude it, has always been > available to evoke the internal reflections that naturally produce > insights along with a shared experience that evokes a similar language > and understanding. It has only been the last year or so that I have > become clear about this truth. > > On Oct 30, 8:28 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > He almost predicted the fizzle out in 'The Plate Cracked' (something > > like that) - a great short story on burn out. You are spot on on 'not > > listening or incapable of such' Orn. > > > I claim to be a 'tropical fish realist'. I am not deeply > > philosophical, even if friends over the years would disagree. My > > upbringing was in English, Irish and Scots philosophers like Locke, > > Berkeley and Hume. I don't particularly agree with them, but admire > > the 'blank page thinking' which we can all rise to in here from time > > to time. Kant provides insightive summary and all tend to long > > sentences, perhaps juggling a lot of balls. Kant referred to 'a > > scandal of Reason', a futile attempt to pry into the 'really real', a > > region outside our mental atmosphere, causing us to collapse into > > fallacies and fabrications. Examples would be god, infinity and > > immortality. These are not irrelevant, yet pure Reason can become a > > kind of philosophical Titanic. > > 'And yet, and yet. If an inclination is so firmly lodged in us, so > > ineradicable and vital, can it be dismissed as a mere nothing, an > > empty falsehood? Is it of no significance whatever? ... It's not so > > much 'what I know?' and 'What is the human being?' - Rousseau's > > influence ... Seen from the human perspective, metaphysical conjecture > > cannot be pushed out of sight. It is both important and > > necessary' (from Campbell 'The Liar's Tale' - a good intro to > > philosophy). > > > Kant goes on to say what has previously been considered metaphysics > > cannot satisfy any critical mind. There is a libidinous character in > > this sort of metaphysics. Even after the deception is unmasked, the > > illusion will not cease to play tricks. The intellect wants to grasp > > experience only as it is provided by the 5 senses (yet there are more > > in nature). Reason strives to understand meaning and this is a > > craving as urgent and insatiable as sexual desire, Darwinian in its > > irresistible momentum and priority as a universal characteristic of > > the human species. Hannah Arendt had it that truth and meaning are > > not the same and that it is the activity of thought on its own, > > regardless of the particular forms it takes that is ' probably the > > aboriginal source of our notion of spirituality'. In a sense we need > > concepts like 'soul' (even if this is a bedtime story) as a guide to > > the workaday task of becoming a successful human being - yet later > > there is a moral assertion we must, across cultures, tell the truth > > and reflection on compassion, a great mystery of ethics, which cannot > > always tell the truth. > > > Perhaps a book length later, I would say science has moved us on, > > though like prayer it falls on deaf ears. It has, to an extent, > > fought off the miracle believers and their instruments of torture. > > Yet we still have, in our mainstream, varieties of that 'objective > > voice' that pretends to separate what it is to be human from > > 'rationally enforceable power'. Our feelings not only don't matter, > > but to express them renders our credibility to that of the slave who > > must obey the master's voice. Perversely, this 'masters' voice' works > > on the collective emotion, and its speakers must know they are > > manipulating. Many do not move from Vernunft that makes us feel at > > home in the reliable world of the everyday, and are scared of Verstand > > which removes the comforts of home and the easy tranquillity of custom > > and habit. I believe much of this is biological in a way Kant could > > not have known. Kierkegaard continues these questions. > > > Many cannot take the discomforts of thinking in critical degrees. > > Contradictions arise everywhere. Some seek to pretend they were not > > born with racist, sexist, selfish potentials that form very libidinal > > drives and confuse a purification of rhetoric with real change in > > themselves and what self can be in social context. The world is full > > of people peddling old remedies that have failed again an again. > > Eventually, with Kierkegaardian irony, these failures are > > metaphysically subsumed as part of the fatalistic process. Those > > speaking out are branded 'confused' or worse, a sure sign of just how > > nasty all the repression required can be as they project the failings > > they cannot see in themselves on others. One has to forgive, of > > course, as one is inevitably a perpetrator from time to time. > > > What would be important Orn, is some means of communication and stuff > > people can do, to glean insight without the intellectual strain. I > > feel much the same about 'Tank Man' as you and it may be all we can > > have is a glimpse. I hope not though. > > > When I first started teaching, I was untrained (thank goodness), > > though had experience in industrial training. I was appointed as a > > senior lecturer in 'organisational analysis and behaviour' (having > > avoided reading any books on same - they still make me nauseous). > > Another lecturer set the exam questions (a matter of kindness to a > > newbie). This was one of them and quite typical: > > 'Critically evaluate process and content theories of motivation at > > work'. > > > A somewhat heated conversation ensued - 'I don't teach my students to > > regurgitate ****ing awful textbooks' - ''For f***s sake mate, it's all > > we can get the idle b******s to do'. Anyone in here can answer this > > question, even though even I would be hard put to answer it in exam > > conditions. We would just go to 'chapter 6' and copy crud about > > Maslow, Herzberg, Porter and Lawler, zzzz - I can't remember who is > > process and who content (and don't want this useless information). > > > The question should be something like 'What do you think motivates > > people to work and might control work behaviour?' We can all have a > > go at that with or without textbooks. Some of us might need several > > books. I would see some spirituality involved in the educational aims > > here. I also have to say most students (thank god not all) prefer to > > be set stuff where they can copy from textbooks. They appear to know > > nothing else and also to be scared of personal expression. Similar > > concerns arise in 'spiritual training'. > > > On 30 Oct, 12:12, rigsy03 <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > Thank you. I would add society and think F. Scott Fitzgerald caught > > > the truth/falsehood- but he fizzled out. > > > > On Oct 30, 12:20 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > The denial of sainthood story more or less gets to Kierkegaard's type > > > > of humour Riggers. The 'poverty sketch' in Monty Python is another - > > > > each tells a story of desperate poverty only to be capped by the > > > > next. The claim to have lived in a shoebox on the M6 central > > > > reservation capped by the envious question, 'you had a shoebox'? The > > > > classic work is 'Humour and Irony in Kierkegaard's Thought' by John > > > > Lippitt (about 2000 and vastly expensive). He never tired of teasing > > > > Danish Christians that they could not be so because of how they lived. > > > > > There's a point in satirical work when one tires of the laughter, > > > > recognising the truth is being told, including the hopeless truth that > > > > all we can do is mock, perhaps only be spectators to the mocking by > > > > the professional mocksters when what we need is actual politics. It > > > > becomes a safety valve that prevents the direct action we need. My > > > > own reticence on the 'power of prayer' stems from something similar - > > > > it's a sort of Samizdat in which we can get private relief but dare > > > > not be associated with in public. Maybe we could consider today's > > > > politicians as priests who prevent us (metaphorically) communing > > > > directly with god. They certainly read to us from hymn sheets in > > > > Latin! > > > > > I watched some dreadful BBC thing the other night on Warren Buffett. > > > > The presenter is an odious crawler. In the course of an hour, I learn > > > > his success is down to Dale Carnegie and techniques anyone could > > > > master in a few weeks. This explains precisely nothing, no doubt the > > > > point. The BBC butt-licker earns his corn, slimeing about like Uriah > > > > Heep. Gates makes a brief appearance, but is not asked why inferior > > > > Microsoft products dominate the world. We get to know nothing other > > > > than chronic lies about 'success'. The BBC toady ponces about being > > > > sincere, whilst actually lying through his teeth. There is, of > > > > course, no secret revealed, just naff lies. Kierkegaard teaches this, > > > > that we back off from any real search for truth and this was Freud's > > > > point. > > > > > It's no secret, I hope, that I like Orn. He's helped turn me on > > > > again. In academe, much of what he says is represented by the > > > > phenomenological turn (it's holy scripts are the unreadable Husserl), > > > > perhaps the process of revelation of the introspection of flow of > > > > consciousness. Kierkegaard is in this line. It is not as lost to > > > > science as Allan Wallace > > ... > > read more » --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
