“…Many cannot take the discomforts of thinking in critical degrees. Contradictions arise everywhere….” - Neil
“…What would be important Orn, is some means of communication and stuff people can do, to glean insight without the intellectual strain….” – Neil Yes, precisely to both. As suggested by the ‘reflections’ from one of the ancient mystery schools, exact methodology which does not require intellectualism, although does not exclude it, has always been available to evoke the internal reflections that naturally produce insights along with a shared experience that evokes a similar language and understanding. It has only been the last year or so that I have become clear about this truth. On Oct 30, 8:28 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > He almost predicted the fizzle out in 'The Plate Cracked' (something > like that) - a great short story on burn out. You are spot on on 'not > listening or incapable of such' Orn. > > I claim to be a 'tropical fish realist'. I am not deeply > philosophical, even if friends over the years would disagree. My > upbringing was in English, Irish and Scots philosophers like Locke, > Berkeley and Hume. I don't particularly agree with them, but admire > the 'blank page thinking' which we can all rise to in here from time > to time. Kant provides insightive summary and all tend to long > sentences, perhaps juggling a lot of balls. Kant referred to 'a > scandal of Reason', a futile attempt to pry into the 'really real', a > region outside our mental atmosphere, causing us to collapse into > fallacies and fabrications. Examples would be god, infinity and > immortality. These are not irrelevant, yet pure Reason can become a > kind of philosophical Titanic. > 'And yet, and yet. If an inclination is so firmly lodged in us, so > ineradicable and vital, can it be dismissed as a mere nothing, an > empty falsehood? Is it of no significance whatever? ... It's not so > much 'what I know?' and 'What is the human being?' - Rousseau's > influence ... Seen from the human perspective, metaphysical conjecture > cannot be pushed out of sight. It is both important and > necessary' (from Campbell 'The Liar's Tale' - a good intro to > philosophy). > > Kant goes on to say what has previously been considered metaphysics > cannot satisfy any critical mind. There is a libidinous character in > this sort of metaphysics. Even after the deception is unmasked, the > illusion will not cease to play tricks. The intellect wants to grasp > experience only as it is provided by the 5 senses (yet there are more > in nature). Reason strives to understand meaning and this is a > craving as urgent and insatiable as sexual desire, Darwinian in its > irresistible momentum and priority as a universal characteristic of > the human species. Hannah Arendt had it that truth and meaning are > not the same and that it is the activity of thought on its own, > regardless of the particular forms it takes that is ' probably the > aboriginal source of our notion of spirituality'. In a sense we need > concepts like 'soul' (even if this is a bedtime story) as a guide to > the workaday task of becoming a successful human being - yet later > there is a moral assertion we must, across cultures, tell the truth > and reflection on compassion, a great mystery of ethics, which cannot > always tell the truth. > > Perhaps a book length later, I would say science has moved us on, > though like prayer it falls on deaf ears. It has, to an extent, > fought off the miracle believers and their instruments of torture. > Yet we still have, in our mainstream, varieties of that 'objective > voice' that pretends to separate what it is to be human from > 'rationally enforceable power'. Our feelings not only don't matter, > but to express them renders our credibility to that of the slave who > must obey the master's voice. Perversely, this 'masters' voice' works > on the collective emotion, and its speakers must know they are > manipulating. Many do not move from Vernunft that makes us feel at > home in the reliable world of the everyday, and are scared of Verstand > which removes the comforts of home and the easy tranquillity of custom > and habit. I believe much of this is biological in a way Kant could > not have known. Kierkegaard continues these questions. > > Many cannot take the discomforts of thinking in critical degrees. > Contradictions arise everywhere. Some seek to pretend they were not > born with racist, sexist, selfish potentials that form very libidinal > drives and confuse a purification of rhetoric with real change in > themselves and what self can be in social context. The world is full > of people peddling old remedies that have failed again an again. > Eventually, with Kierkegaardian irony, these failures are > metaphysically subsumed as part of the fatalistic process. Those > speaking out are branded 'confused' or worse, a sure sign of just how > nasty all the repression required can be as they project the failings > they cannot see in themselves on others. One has to forgive, of > course, as one is inevitably a perpetrator from time to time. > > What would be important Orn, is some means of communication and stuff > people can do, to glean insight without the intellectual strain. I > feel much the same about 'Tank Man' as you and it may be all we can > have is a glimpse. I hope not though. > > When I first started teaching, I was untrained (thank goodness), > though had experience in industrial training. I was appointed as a > senior lecturer in 'organisational analysis and behaviour' (having > avoided reading any books on same - they still make me nauseous). > Another lecturer set the exam questions (a matter of kindness to a > newbie). This was one of them and quite typical: > 'Critically evaluate process and content theories of motivation at > work'. > > A somewhat heated conversation ensued - 'I don't teach my students to > regurgitate ****ing awful textbooks' - ''For f***s sake mate, it's all > we can get the idle b******s to do'. Anyone in here can answer this > question, even though even I would be hard put to answer it in exam > conditions. We would just go to 'chapter 6' and copy crud about > Maslow, Herzberg, Porter and Lawler, zzzz - I can't remember who is > process and who content (and don't want this useless information). > > The question should be something like 'What do you think motivates > people to work and might control work behaviour?' We can all have a > go at that with or without textbooks. Some of us might need several > books. I would see some spirituality involved in the educational aims > here. I also have to say most students (thank god not all) prefer to > be set stuff where they can copy from textbooks. They appear to know > nothing else and also to be scared of personal expression. Similar > concerns arise in 'spiritual training'. > > On 30 Oct, 12:12, rigsy03 <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > Thank you. I would add society and think F. Scott Fitzgerald caught > > the truth/falsehood- but he fizzled out. > > > On Oct 30, 12:20 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > The denial of sainthood story more or less gets to Kierkegaard's type > > > of humour Riggers. The 'poverty sketch' in Monty Python is another - > > > each tells a story of desperate poverty only to be capped by the > > > next. The claim to have lived in a shoebox on the M6 central > > > reservation capped by the envious question, 'you had a shoebox'? The > > > classic work is 'Humour and Irony in Kierkegaard's Thought' by John > > > Lippitt (about 2000 and vastly expensive). He never tired of teasing > > > Danish Christians that they could not be so because of how they lived. > > > > There's a point in satirical work when one tires of the laughter, > > > recognising the truth is being told, including the hopeless truth that > > > all we can do is mock, perhaps only be spectators to the mocking by > > > the professional mocksters when what we need is actual politics. It > > > becomes a safety valve that prevents the direct action we need. My > > > own reticence on the 'power of prayer' stems from something similar - > > > it's a sort of Samizdat in which we can get private relief but dare > > > not be associated with in public. Maybe we could consider today's > > > politicians as priests who prevent us (metaphorically) communing > > > directly with god. They certainly read to us from hymn sheets in > > > Latin! > > > > I watched some dreadful BBC thing the other night on Warren Buffett. > > > The presenter is an odious crawler. In the course of an hour, I learn > > > his success is down to Dale Carnegie and techniques anyone could > > > master in a few weeks. This explains precisely nothing, no doubt the > > > point. The BBC butt-licker earns his corn, slimeing about like Uriah > > > Heep. Gates makes a brief appearance, but is not asked why inferior > > > Microsoft products dominate the world. We get to know nothing other > > > than chronic lies about 'success'. The BBC toady ponces about being > > > sincere, whilst actually lying through his teeth. There is, of > > > course, no secret revealed, just naff lies. Kierkegaard teaches this, > > > that we back off from any real search for truth and this was Freud's > > > point. > > > > It's no secret, I hope, that I like Orn. He's helped turn me on > > > again. In academe, much of what he says is represented by the > > > phenomenological turn (it's holy scripts are the unreadable Husserl), > > > perhaps the process of revelation of the introspection of flow of > > > consciousness. Kierkegaard is in this line. It is not as lost to > > > science as Allan Wallace claims, but it is lost in the mannered > > > society of glossed presentation (including, to use Gabby's term, > > > 'Mind's Ayer' - a gem). What I'm interested in is the loss of > > > religious trust (I do not hanker for the old ways back), something we > > > can grok without losing intellectual critique, but does not give us up > > > to the intellectual knower and brings about a fellowship in which > > > Reason arises. This cannot be a Reason of the intellectuals, > > > precluding those (most) who do not reason well. People like Gadamer > > > (not of Galactica) and Habermas have sought to use techniques of > > > hermeneutics (once double, now quadruple) to guarantee truth or at > > > least communication with ideology extirpated to leave only the force > > > of Reason in mutual understanding - this has much similarity with > > > contemplation and meditation - yet if the proof of the pudding is in > > > the eating we can rest assured we will not get to taste. The question > > > in religion and politics might well be how we come to truth without > > > hierarchy (a word with very religious origins) with secret > > ... > > read more »- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text - --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
