You have implied many things in this post which I refute. You have implied that I am a part of a problem rather than of a solution. You have implied that I am a tea bagger. You have implied that I support fascism, totalitarianism and other (similar) ideologies. You have implied that I do not wish to explore "the truth" which I take to mean your truth. You have implied that my logic and reason are not only false but childish and irrational. You have implied that I am naïve. You have implied that I do not know the simple definition of words. You have implied that I have conducted a "takeover" of the original theme of this post. And you have implied that I am in favor of force over agreement. I contend that you have no basis for these contentions and that perhaps you are merely being a contrarian or an instigator. That said, I will attempt to rebut much of what you say or at the very least explain my reason and logic more clearly for your edification.
First and foremost, I am very much in favor of peace on earth. Yet however much we pay lip service to that phrase, there is no evidence whatsoever in our entire past nor in our contemporary world that such a condition is currently possible and with that lack of evidence or even inclination on the part of the world, recommending that we disband our military and lay down our arms seems to me just plain foolishness. As an aside and regards your criticism of my argument through asking questions, was this not the highly regarded method used by Socrates? It also works very well in the practice of law. You confirm that “…Laws are the glue that holds society together and allow us to live with each other in reasonable certainty of making it to tomorrow…” is true, then ask what my point is and state that it has nothing to do with rights and freedoms. Let me point out that every law, every rule, every regulation is a limitation on individual and societal freedom and rights and without such limitations we would have chaotic anarchy. I have no idea how Chomsky defines anarchy but I do know he declares himself to be an adherent of libertarian socialism. Socialism requires extensive laws, rules and regulations. Where is the freedom and anarchy in that? Human beings are excellent practitioners of the seven deadly sins and without laws, rules and regulations (i.e., anarchy) we'd be at each others throats with every weapon we could find at hand. Chomsky believes that science is a good way to understanding history and social affairs and goes on to say that science is a way of learning what argument means, what evidence means and what makes sense to postulate as well as what is going to be convincing. I've always been quite open to being convinced of something through argument and evidence but I've yet to see either one in the postings you've made, and I do believe I have a fairly firm grip on both argument and evidence since both were tools of my profession for many years. Orn, probably much to your displeasure, Chomsky does not present an end-all, be-all solution to the world's problems. He has been challenged quite successfully by many notable thinkers, among which are as Jean Piaget, Michel Foucault, William F. Buckley, Jr., Christopher Hitchens, Richard Perle, Hilary Putnam, and Alan Dershowitz. Chomsky believes in justified power yet feels that any wage earner is a mere slave and that workers should own and control their own workplace, which does nothing to reduce his contention that earning a wage is slavery whether the slave owns the business or not. Chomsky has made some partially valid criticisms of society including his indictment that the mass media is largely propaganda but fails to mention anything about an educated populace being able to sift through that propaganda to discern truth, and that there are also some media which work very hard to present a balanced and honest portrait of various aspects of the world. I offer The Christian Science Monitor as but one example. Another favorite of mine is The Financial Times. Chomsky has claimed that the United States remains the greatest country in the world then turns around and contradicts himself by saying that such evaluations are senseless. He is an avowed anti-war activist but then claims that WWII was justified. He is anti- capitalism and and avowed unionist, the latter part of which has been the cause of many of this nations jobs moving to other countries. Unions have raised the cost of labor so high that it is impossible for heavily unionized companies from making a profit. Years ago I began advising investors I knew to avoid putting their money into companies that were so unionized because they would eventually go bankrupt. Chomsky is a radical socialist claiming libertarian principles which do not comport with much of what he says. He claims status in the left wing of U.S. politics yet many of his critics are liberal and progressive and he gives solid foundation to all conservative critics. My personal opinion is that he should stay in his initially chosen field of linguistics in which he has received the majority of his accolades and stay out of politics. I think you make a huge and incorrect leap of logic when you say that by my interchanging the words power and rights "(you) could interchange any words at all and it would have the same meaning." That statement makes no sense on its face within the meaning of the Constitution. I never said that Chamberlain was evil. All I said was that his plan of appeasement was ill thought and clearly didn't work. Nor does appeasement equate with not keeping a standing army. In the case of Chamberlain it meant giving Poland as a gift to Hitler with the hope that he wouldn't go any further. Of course I wasn't there but in hindsight it seems pure lunacy. Nor am I forgiving the ills and abuses of the military industrial complex but that does not mean I am in favor of eliminating them either. I do agree with you that if there were NO militaries in existence there would likely be no wars. But the fact is that virtually every nation on earth has a standing military as do many corporations (i.e., security and mercenary forces) and until such time as they all disbanded none should disband. It also seems ill-informed to say that if we are not under direct attack that we are at peace. I have noted several examples of this in previous posts and will not burden you with a repetition of them. Nor do I find much value or substance in your contention that peace reigns when one "side" has been disarmed. All that means is that they are under the power and control of the side that has not disarmed. Of course agreement is preferable to force, but until such time as we have such agreement, a standing, trained and armed military is the preferable stance. It certainly isn't laying down our arms and armies unilaterally and without achieving agreement. On Oct 31, 11:03 am, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > “…Ben Franklin was wrong on that one. Giving up some selected > personal > rights and freedoms for a bit of security does not make one deserving > of neither. Helmets and seat belts are poor examples but they do > save > the people monies in that they prevent a lot of people from severe > injuries which does cost each of us either through taxes or higher > insurance premiums….” – gruff > > Ben Franklin was precise and exactly correct ‘on that one’. You merely > disagree. And, as I see it, are more a part of the problem than a part > of the solution by conflating monies and freedoms in the above > example. Yes, on one level assets provide us more access to > activities. On the other hand, monies are not freedom. At the risk of > appearing inflammatory, are you missing a tea bagger party somewhere > now? ;-) > > “…Laws are the glue that holds society together and > allow us to live with each other in reasonable certainty of making it > to tomorrow….” – gruff > > Yes, true. And, your point is what? I agree with what you have said > here. However, it has nothing to do with rights and freedoms. > > “… It sounds like what you and Chris are proposing is anarchy…” – gruf > > In the sense of the way Chomsky defines anarchy, I would say that I am > proposing it as being a preferable stance than that of supporting and > participating in fascism, totalitarianism and other ideologies. > > “…I don't see much difference between a power and a right. They seem > naturally conflated…” – gruff > > Yes gruff, I know. And, this is why I pointed it out to you. > Apparently you retain your focus and wish to not explore the truth > that they are quite different. > > “…you could exchange the words right and power and the document would > still have the same meaning.” - gruff > > Using this logic, I could interchange any words at all and it would > have the same meaning. I reject your logic, reasoning and continued > conflations. > > “Orn, it seems Neville Chamberlain tried it your way and was slapped > down mightily for it….” – gruff > > I almost mentioned Neville in my post but thought better of it. While > I had guessed that the comparison would be brought up, I had hoped > that the pacifist analogy using Neville like the ‘evil’ analogy of > using Hitler wouldn’t have been used. It was. I reject the analogy on > numerous grounds. It attempts to take a specific event and generalize > it. It takes that point in time and assumes the chain of events there > are applicable to all points in time. It is a fallacy. > > “…Do you really think appeasement would have > satisfied and contained the USSR or China, or going back even > further, > would any form of appeasement have stopped old King George from > stomping on our independence?...” – gruff > > Yet again you appear to equate (conflate) appeasement with not keeping > a standing army. This is a fallacy used merely to support your point > of view and I reject the logic. > > “…That said, let me ask you your view on war and maintaining a > military > force at this time in our history.” – gruff > > I, like you and all sane people do not wish war. And, at the same > time, recognize that being naïve is an invitation to destruction. I > believe that Eisenhower was correct about the dangers of the military > industrial (and congressional) complex. I believe that if there were > no militaries in existence, there would be no wars. I believe, like > Sun Tzu said, that the war is won or lost before it begins. I believe > that the notion of ‘victory’ in war is a misnomer even though Sun Tzu > uses it extensively. I believe that ‘we’ (USA) do not need a standing > military in peace time. I believe that the notion of ‘peace time’ > includes, for the USA, all of the time that ‘we’ were not under direct > attack upon our actual homeland. Here I do not include the artificial > extensions of ‘our land’ to places in other countries. I believe that > I have met the enemy and it is us. I believe that the phrase ‘military > force’ can be used in differing ways from ‘standing army’. I believe > that when directly attacked, I would do what was necessary to remain > alive. On another level, I also, at the same time, hold the view that > if we all were willing to accept being attacked and, as some believers > hold, that turning the other cheek is a valid response too. The former > is the reasoning of the living organism. The latter is that of the > spirit. > > I believe that most of what I have been posting about this takeover of > a topic from her objectification to our warfare has been directed to > the expected results from an entire string of actions ‘we’ have taken > throughout history and if a break in that chain of events had been > made, a much different and most likely preferable result for ‘this > time in our history’ would have been the result. I believe that as > long as ‘we’ maintain the largest military in the history of the globe > and spend more on it than all other countries combined other countries > will feel the need to maintain a standing military an justifiably so. > I believe that ‘our’ adventuring globally imposing ‘our’ will using > force has been and will continue to be seen as a direct attack on all > of the sovereign nations of the world. I believe that this cause/ > effect is just that. I believe that the only peace has been brought > about historically is when one ‘side’ disarmed. I believe in the > principle of universality and that it is not only the only sane way to > approach this but the only possible one to use that is entirely > logical, practical and even moral and spiritually astute at the same > time. I give Noam Chomsky the credit for helping me to gain clarity on > what until then were only intuitions rather than intellectual wisdom > in this area. I believe that there are only two ways to unity and the > resulting peace. One is force, the other is agreement. I believe that > the latter is preferable to the former. > > On Oct 31, 9:58 am, gruff <[email protected]> wrote: > > > Orn, it seems Neville Chamberlain tried it your way and was slapped > > down mightily for it. Do you really think appeasement would have > > satisfied and contained the USSR or China, or going back even further, > > would any form of appeasement have stopped old King George from > > stomping on our independence? > > > Allow me to cite a paragraph from Wikipedia on the morality of war: > > "Throughout history war has been the source of serious moral > > questions. Although many ancient nations and some modern ones have > > viewed war as noble, over the sweep of history, concerns about the > > morality of war have gradually increased. Today, war is seen by some > > as undesirable and morally problematic. At the same time, many view > > war, or at least the preparation and readiness and willingness to > > engage in war, as necessary for the defense of their country and > > therefore a just war. Pacifists believe that war is inherently immoral > > and that no war should ever be fought." > > > That said, let me ask you your view on war and maintaining a military > > force at this time in our history. > > > On Oct 30, 7:47 pm, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > “Then there is the fact that in the past 150 years there has never > > > been > > > a time of peace (except for one week in 1974 ... I have the > > > headline).” – gruff > > > > There is also the fact that the US has only been directly attacked a > > > couple of times during that time and the standing military did not nor > > > could it stop the attacks. And, if the military had not been out > > > adventuring in an arrogant and global way, neither the one bomb sent > > > to the West Coast from Japan nor the bombings of the WTC would have > > > occurred. Here, for clarity, I am ignoring all of the internal > > > continental attacks which have been much more devastating, from the > > > civil war and the assignation of Lincoln to the Unabomber and Oklahoma > > > City.- Hide quoted text - > > > - Show quoted text - --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
