Discussion with gruff moved to a new and more appropriate topic. Attempted Disambiguation.
On Oct 31, 12:57 pm, gruff <[email protected]> wrote: > You have implied many things in this post which I refute. You have > implied that I am a part of a problem rather than of a solution. You > have implied that I am a tea bagger. You have implied that I support > fascism, totalitarianism and other (similar) ideologies. You have > implied that I do not wish to explore "the truth" which I take to mean > your truth. You have implied that my logic and reason are not only > false but childish and irrational. You have implied that I am naïve. > You have implied that I do not know the simple definition of words. > You have implied that I have conducted a "takeover" of the original > theme of this post. And you have implied that I am in favor of force > over agreement. I contend that you have no basis for these > contentions and that perhaps you are merely being a contrarian or an > instigator. That said, I will attempt to rebut much of what you say > or at the very least explain my reason and logic more clearly for your > edification. > > First and foremost, I am very much in favor of peace on earth. Yet > however much we pay lip service to that phrase, there is no evidence > whatsoever in our entire past nor in our contemporary world that such > a condition is currently possible and with that lack of evidence or > even inclination on the part of the world, recommending that we > disband our military and lay down our arms seems to me just plain > foolishness. > > As an aside and regards your criticism of my argument through asking > questions, was this not the highly regarded method used by Socrates? > It also works very well in the practice of law. > > You confirm that “…Laws are the glue that holds society together and > allow us to live with each other in reasonable certainty of making it > to tomorrow…” is true, then ask what my point is and state that it has > nothing to do with rights and freedoms. Let me point out that every > law, every rule, every regulation is a limitation on individual and > societal freedom and rights and without such limitations we would have > chaotic anarchy. I have no idea how Chomsky defines anarchy but I do > know he declares himself to be an adherent of libertarian socialism. > Socialism requires extensive laws, rules and regulations. Where is > the freedom and anarchy in that? > > Human beings are excellent practitioners of the seven deadly sins and > without laws, rules and regulations (i.e., anarchy) we'd be at each > others throats with every weapon we could find at hand. > > Chomsky believes that science is a good way to understanding history > and social affairs and goes on to say that science is a way of > learning what argument means, what evidence means and what makes sense > to postulate as well as what is going to be convincing. I've always > been quite open to being convinced of something through argument and > evidence but I've yet to see either one in the postings you've made, > and I do believe I have a fairly firm grip on both argument and > evidence since both were tools of my profession for many years. > > Orn, probably much to your displeasure, Chomsky does not present an > end-all, be-all solution to the world's problems. He has been > challenged quite successfully by many notable thinkers, among which > are as Jean Piaget, Michel Foucault, William F. Buckley, Jr., > Christopher Hitchens, Richard Perle, Hilary Putnam, and Alan > Dershowitz. Chomsky believes in justified power yet feels that any > wage earner is a mere slave and that workers should own and control > their own workplace, which does nothing to reduce his contention that > earning a wage is slavery whether the slave owns the business or > not. > > Chomsky has made some partially valid criticisms of society including > his indictment that the mass media is largely propaganda but fails to > mention anything about an educated populace being able to sift through > that propaganda to discern truth, and that there are also some media > which work very hard to present a balanced and honest portrait of > various aspects of the world. I offer The Christian Science Monitor > as but one example. Another favorite of mine is The Financial > Times. > > Chomsky has claimed that the United States remains the greatest > country in the world then turns around and contradicts himself by > saying that such evaluations are senseless. He is an avowed anti-war > activist but then claims that WWII was justified. He is anti- > capitalism and and avowed unionist, the latter part of which has been > the cause of many of this nations jobs moving to other countries. > Unions have raised the cost of labor so high that it is impossible for > heavily unionized companies from making a profit. Years ago I began > advising investors I knew to avoid putting their money into companies > that were so unionized because they would eventually go bankrupt. > > Chomsky is a radical socialist claiming libertarian principles which > do not comport with much of what he says. He claims status in the > left wing of U.S. politics yet many of his critics are liberal and > progressive and he gives solid foundation to all conservative > critics. My personal opinion is that he should stay in his initially > chosen field of linguistics in which he has received the majority of > his accolades and stay out of politics. > > I think you make a huge and incorrect leap of logic when you say that > by my interchanging the words power and rights "(you) could > interchange any words at all and it would have the same meaning." > That statement makes no sense on its face within the meaning of the > Constitution. > > I never said that Chamberlain was evil. All I said was that his plan > of appeasement was ill thought and clearly didn't work. Nor does > appeasement equate with not keeping a standing army. In the case of > Chamberlain it meant giving Poland as a gift to Hitler with the hope > that he wouldn't go any further. Of course I wasn't there but in > hindsight it seems pure lunacy. > > Nor am I forgiving the ills and abuses of the military industrial > complex but that does not mean I am in favor of eliminating them > either. I do agree with you that if there were NO militaries in > existence there would likely be no wars. But the fact is that > virtually every nation on earth has a standing military as do many > corporations (i.e., security and mercenary forces) and until such time > as they all disbanded none should disband. > > It also seems ill-informed to say that if we are not under direct > attack that we are at peace. I have noted several examples of this in > previous posts and will not burden you with a repetition of them. Nor > do I find much value or substance in your contention that peace reigns > when one "side" has been disarmed. All that means is that they are > under the power and control of the side that has not disarmed. > > Of course agreement is preferable to force, but until such time as we > have such agreement, a standing, trained and armed military is the > preferable stance. It certainly isn't laying down our arms and armies > unilaterally and without achieving agreement. > > On Oct 31, 11:03 am, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > “…Ben Franklin was wrong on that one. Giving up some selected > > personal > > rights and freedoms for a bit of security does not make one deserving > > of neither. Helmets and seat belts are poor examples but they do > > save > > the people monies in that they prevent a lot of people from severe > > injuries which does cost each of us either through taxes or higher > > insurance premiums….” – gruff > > > Ben Franklin was precise and exactly correct ‘on that one’. You merely > > disagree. And, as I see it, are more a part of the problem than a part > > of the solution by conflating monies and freedoms in the above > > example. Yes, on one level assets provide us more access to > > activities. On the other hand, monies are not freedom. At the risk of > > appearing inflammatory, are you missing a tea bagger party somewhere > > now? ;-) > > > “…Laws are the glue that holds society together and > > allow us to live with each other in reasonable certainty of making it > > to tomorrow….” – gruff > > > Yes, true. And, your point is what? I agree with what you have said > > here. However, it has nothing to do with rights and freedoms. > > > “… It sounds like what you and Chris are proposing is anarchy…” – gruf > > > In the sense of the way Chomsky defines anarchy, I would say that I am > > proposing it as being a preferable stance than that of supporting and > > participating in fascism, totalitarianism and other ideologies. > > > “…I don't see much difference between a power and a right. They seem > > naturally conflated…” – gruff > > > Yes gruff, I know. And, this is why I pointed it out to you. > > Apparently you retain your focus and wish to not explore the truth > > that they are quite different. > > > “…you could exchange the words right and power and the document would > > still have the same meaning.” - gruff > > > Using this logic, I could interchange any words at all and it would > > have the same meaning. I reject your logic, reasoning and continued > > conflations. > > > “Orn, it seems Neville Chamberlain tried it your way and was slapped > > down mightily for it….” – gruff > > > I almost mentioned Neville in my post but thought better of it. While > > I had guessed that the comparison would be brought up, I had hoped > > that the pacifist analogy using Neville like the ‘evil’ analogy of > > using Hitler wouldn’t have been used. It was. I reject the analogy on > > numerous grounds. It attempts to take a specific event and generalize > > it. It takes that point in time and assumes the chain of events there > > are applicable to all points in time. It is a fallacy. > > > “…Do you really think appeasement would have > > satisfied and contained the USSR or China, or going back even > > further, > > would any form of appeasement have stopped old King George > > ... > > read more »- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text - --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
