Adorno was frankly bloody awful - Marcuse once said he couldn't understand half of it and that was what made it good as critique needed to rise above the power relations embedded in normal speech acts. Orwell presents a rather different heroine in a woman who cannot but swear and Doublespeak and the rest because she actually works. It is much worse than your last line Justin - now the politicians are back to the fascist ethics and seek the slaughter of anyone who disagrees. The vicious levels of satire are back where they were in fascist days too. I tend to believe there is much only fit for ridicule and am game for a laugh - yet what is going on now isn't funny and tends only to be possible because we aren't looking at the real problems.
Whatever the answers are, it's hard to see how they can merely be intellectual - this doesn't preclude intellectual knowers or knowing - or anything that remains individually subjective (for this is fascism). Nitpicking sometimes helps but usually attempts to stop progress rather than help. My guess is this is an age of madness and we may not shape up without ridicule and forms of protest that are not rational - yet springtimes are short. I can answer some of my questions in science fiction - a GROCS (genetically relative open communications system) and by dispensing with most of the world's population with a future setting with little need of leaders. One might do some scenario planning to come back to problem identification now. There is a contradiction for Orn - Chomsky and Orn's concern on propaganda do not fit well with ancient orders building refined individuals who cannot communicate to those who have not "undergone the 7th Dan" - this does not have to mean Orn has found nothing - though my own journeys have come up dry (in terms of my goal, not personal insight). This should be something worked on, not subjected to sarcastic swipe - though we also should be able to take this from each other in friendship. The jibe can sometimes be the mover needed. It may be that the intellectual knower (and politician) needs to be able to demonstrate she is not merely acting in her own interests. I do believe our politicians are mad and extremely weak - they have reversed much of what is needed in civilisation and use power and ridicule themselves at the drop of a hat - how long before the current excesses and failure of police they allow (whilst telling us of the great job they are doing) reaches some kind of Nazi-Stazi proportion? My guess is the keys to this are in technology. I should explain why - but perhaps like Orn wondering if anyone can understand without the 'training', I doubt most have a definition of technology. With some luck, my ideas will be worthless and the problems wither away for those who survive the asteroid ... On 1 Nov, 09:43, Justintruth <[email protected]> wrote: > > all we can do is mock, perhaps only be spectators to the mocking by > > the professional mocksters when what we need is actual politics. It > > becomes a safety valve that prevents the direct action we need. My > > own reticence on the 'power of prayer' stems from something similar - > > it's a sort of Samizdat in which we can get private relief but dare > > not be associated with in public. > > Check out Adorno's "The Jargon of Authenticity". I don't subscribe to > his ideas but he does point out some easy pitfalls to fall into. > > "What remains after the removal of existential bombast are religious > customs cut off from their religious content. There is no recognition > of the fact that cult forms, the subject matter of folklore, like > empty shells, outlive their mystery. This state of affairs is in fact > defended with the aid of the jargon" > > "Awe, in the face of that existent which pretends to be more than it > is, beats down all that is unruly. One is given to understand that > that which occurs is so deep that language could not un-hallow what > has been said by saying it. Pure clean hands recoil from the thought > of changing anything in the valid property-and-authority > relationships; the very sound of it all makes that idea contemptible, > as the merely onitc is to Heidegger. One can trust anyone who babbles > this jargon; people wear it in their buttonholes, .... In the jargon > that division between the destructive and the constructive with which > fascism had cut of critical thought, comfortably hibernates. Simply to > be there becomes the merit of a thing. It is guaranteed in the > protection of the double sense of the positive: as something existent, > given, and as something worthy of being affirmed." > > There seems to be a common thread of mockery stalking western > philosophical thought. While I think it Adorno and the other "mockers" > missed their mark, a slight misinterpretation, or a failure to live > and act in accordance with one's ideals, brings one squarely into the > line of its fire and the mockery finds its mark dead center. --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
