[Platt]
It's one thing to argue a point of view with vigor. It's quite
another to decree there is one a right way to think, regardless. That
you can't tell the difference speaks volumes.
[Arlo]
Kindly point out where I say "there is one right way to think", all
I've done is point Bo to valid and sound ground. Or are dishonesty
and distortion the only ground you care to stand on?
Now how about an attempt at substance?
[Arlo repeats]
Why is the following such a seemingly alien concept for you, Platt and Bo?
(1) Bo's formulation for a metaphysics is a critical revision of
Pirsig's metaphysics.
(2) Bo might say "A metaphysics of Quality that holds the
intellectual level to SOM is better than A metaphysics of Quality
that considers SOM to be one on many intellectual patterns", instead
of "THE metaphysics of Quality holds the intellectual level to SOM".
Why are you all so obsessively hung up on the word "THE", and what
value do you think it has?
Do you disagree with me that we use the phrase "THE metaphysics of
Quality" as a conventional way of referring specifically to Pirsig's
ideas, but that it would in fact be more accurate to say "Pirsig's
metaphysics"?
Do you not see that obsessing on the "THE" objectifies the "MOQ" into
some "reality"... that even Pirsig can be "wrong" about? This makes
no sense. Pirsig can't be wrong about his ideas, but his ideas can be
wrong. In the same way, Bo's ideas are not "THE MOQ", they are his ideas.
If we drop the word "THE", and instead simply talk about people's
ideas, do you not see how all this interpretive nonsense and need for
authoritative legitimacy would disappear?
In other words, what do you think is wrong with saying "A metaphysics
of Quality that holds the intellectual level to SOM is better than A
metaphysics of Quality that considers SOM to be one on many
intellectual patterns"?
Does that not sum up your position? Why is it more important for you
to say instead "THE metaphysics of Quality holds the intellectual
level to SOM"?
Moq_Discuss mailing list
Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc.
http://lists.moqtalk.org/listinfo.cgi/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org
Archives:
http://lists.moqtalk.org/pipermail/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org/
http://moq.org/md/archives.html
