Hi Struan, Roger and others
On 31 Jan 99, at 1:05, Struan Hellier wrote:
> >ROGER QUESTIONS WHY PEOPLE ARE REWRITING
> >HISTORY. PERHAPS SOME MEMBERS ARE TAKING
> >THE TITLE TO THIS POST LITERALLY AND MAKING
> >UP THEIR OWN TRUTHS AS THEY GO ALONG
>
> I've been pondering this one since I pretty much said the same thing,
> albeit prefaced by an apposite observation. Perhaps an addition to the
> rules could be formulated making it clear that the behaviour you highlight
> is not acceptable. This 'truth creation' has permeated a number of
> postings recently. It is lazy and/or dishonest and really needs to stop.
Considering the cavalier attitude that a number of contributors to this forum display
towards the Charter and Rules I think it would be a pointless exercise and a waste of
time to try and formulate such a rule. I agree completely with your sentiments but
short
of making moq_discuss a moderated list, enforcing such a rule would be impossible.
Point two of the Charter should prevent this but inflammatory and intelletually
dishonest posts will continue where those involved wish to distort what others say for
their own purposes and all the rules in the world can't prevent fools from being
fools.
Probably the best thing to do is to hit the delete button and let the intellectually
dishonest continue in their own self-deception. Alternatively, when someone wishes to
become involved in constructive debate and question or challenge anothers view they
should provide the original quotation to which they are referring. But as you point
out
those that participate in this practice are also lazy so will presumably be too lazy
to
produce those parts of the post they are distorting.
Horse
MOQ Homepage - http://www.moq.org
Mail Archive - http://alt.venus.co.uk/hypermail/moq_discuss/
