Hi Andy,

> Until the basic show-stoppers are solved, the redundant opstate objects are 
> not important.
> Removing the foo-state objects means they are now invisible wrt/ YANG 
> constraints
> (must, when, leafref, min/max, etc).  IMO this is a show-shopper.  YANG can 
> only cross-reference
> YANG statements.  Invisible opstate hiding behind a datastore label seems 
> elegant
> wrt/ <get>, but it looks like a disaster wrt/ YANG.

Nothing has been removed.  All the config false nodes are still available, but 
now they’re no longer separated into a top-level /foo-state tree for the sole 
purpose of being able to report opstate for system-generated objects.  
Likewise, all YANG constraints continue to work, but rather than reference 
nodes in /foo-state, they’ll now reference nodes in /foo.   Does this make 
sense?  Do you still have an issue?


Kent // as a contributor


_______________________________________________
netmod mailing list
netmod@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/netmod

Reply via email to