On 2012-03-15 09:49, Stefan Guggisberg wrote:
On Wed, Mar 14, 2012 at 2:54 PM, Julian Reschke<[email protected]>  wrote:
Hi there,

I'm looking at MicroKernel.getNodes(), and I believe the semantics might
perform non-optimal unless we get the property filtering right.

A typical use case always is browsing a repository using a tree view.

A tree view usually needs, given a node N:

- all or a subset of all properties of node N

- the set of child node names, and for each of these child nodes, a
predefined set of properties that will allow the caller to decorate the node
properly -- such as whether it's a container, and maybe the type).

Another problem is the String-fits-all return type; it would make it
impossible to implement streaming of the result to the client; which will
make the behavior for large collections non-optimal (the caller needs to
wait for the complete JSON string to be ready before it can start forwarding
information up the stack).

good point. how about returning a character stream (Reader/Readable)
instead of a string?
...

I think it would help.

A more general issue is the reliance on a JSON-type tree; this looks simple, but it means that returning information about lots of nested child nodes makes it harder to process the result, unless you're willing to wait for the end.

I always wondered why WebDAV multistatus messages contain a flat list of response elements (with the path being part of the response), instead of nesting. I believe I now know why; it makes streaming *much* easier (and before somebody claims that's academic; I have implemented that in a server in the past).

Best regards, Julian

Reply via email to