Hi,
IMO this is a requirement for which we didn't come up with a clean
solution yet. While I agree that it is probably not possible to just fit
this into the "commit hook" framework, this should still be a single
concern in one place instead of spreading it all over.
Please report an improvement issue so it doesn't drop of the agenda.
Michael
On 26.3.15 2:53 , Francesco Mari wrote:
I was not aware of this design decision, thanks for clarifying.
Anyway, the remote API is currently implemented on top of the
ContentRepository API. This means that I have to take care of
providing values for autocreated properties. Is there anything that
can be done do prevent this?
I was thinking that maybe, when the "JCR plugins" are installed, a
wrapper of Tree may be installed as well. This wrapper could take care
of the generation of autocreated properties in the transient space.
This is kind of a big change, because the ContentRepository API is not
meant to be extended this way.
2015-03-26 14:26 GMT+01:00 Angela Schreiber <[email protected]>:
hi francesco
well... so far we claimed that it's the responsibility of the
Oak API caller to make sure that items defined to be autocreated
from a JCR point of view must be created. as the Oak API itself
doesn't know about autocreated items.
afaik delegating this to the TypeEditor will not work, because
JCR mandates for various autocreated items that they are already
present in the transient state (before being saved).
as you can see it's not only the NodeDelegate that autocreates
items but e.g. also the user management implementation, the versioning
etc.
kind regards
angela
On 26/03/15 14:10, "Francesco Mari" <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi all,
when using the ContentRepository API with the JCR plugins (as
installed by the Jcr builder), autocreated properties are not
generated.
IIUC, this happens because
org.apache.jackrabbit.oak.util.TreeUtil#autoCreateItems is only called
when using a org.apache.jackrabbit.oak.jcr.delegate.NodeDelegate,
instead of being part of the logic executed by
org.apache.jackrabbit.oak.plugins.nodetype.TypeEditor.
I think that TypeEditor, instead of NodeDelegate, should take care of
autocreated items. What do you think?
