I'll chime in with the recommendation that this extra command be enabled only when building OpenAFS with Amanda support. The normal AFS tape backup service doesn't need this functionality, backing up using the TSM (XBSA) enabled butc doesn't need this functionality, its only necessary for Amanda. Therefore, wouldn't it make sense to enable it in the command suite when you specifically require Amanda support?

Maybe an autoconf argument for configure could be "--enable-amanda", and when triggered it is compiled into the command suite.

The main reason I have this point of view was due to something Derrick B. said a few months ago when I was working on some TSM/XBSA stuff. And I quote:
"Everyone and their mom has the idea for a backup system. How are we going to convince everyone to agree on one of them?"


Should the AFS backup system development become more fractured due to several supported commercial backup options, I believe it is prudent to try to keep each one self contained, modular.

Just my opinion.

-Matt



_______________________________________________
OpenAFS-devel mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.openafs.org/mailman/listinfo/openafs-devel

Reply via email to