On Thu, 2 Feb 2023 18:09:23 GMT, Andy Goryachev <ango...@openjdk.org> wrote:

>>> one way to do it is to describe the expected result in the comment 
>>> immediately preceding the string.
>>> ...
>>> 
>>> Also, for testing purposes, we could consider pseudolocalization
>> 
>> These are good suggestions that should be captured in the follow-up issue 
>> that Alex said he will file.
>> 
>> Localization and testing is out of scope for this PR. Alex did the minimum 
>> needed to correct the fact that the string wasn't internationalized at all, 
>> which makes sense only because he had to modify the string as part of this 
>> PR (even then, I would have been OK with no i18n changes in this PR, leaving 
>> them for a separate issue as well).
>> 
>>> Better discuss this with Naoto Sato.
>> 
>> Good idea.
>
> Definitely out of scope for this PR, I just wanted to mention this.
> @azuev-java please link the follow up JBS ticket for localization.
> Thank you!

Still, I would recommend adding a comment (since now is the time when we know 
all the context, and in the future we might forget or lose the context), may be 
something like


# {seriesName} {xAxisName} is {currentX} {yAxisName} is {currentY}
XYChart.series.accessibleText={0} {1} is {2} {3} is {4}

-------------

PR: https://git.openjdk.org/jfx/pull/1016

Reply via email to