On Mon, 21 Sep 2026 18:04:44 GMT, Andy Goryachev <[email protected]> wrote:

>> tests/manual/dnd/DndBasic.java line 103:
>> 
>>> 101:             modifiers =
>>> 102:                     "macOS: Use no modifier for COPY, 'Command' for 
>>> MOVE, " +
>>> 103:                             "and 'Control+Option' for LINK.";
>> 
>> On my macOS 15 system, netierh CMD+Option nor Control+Option will enable 
>> LINK. I tested this by dragging from the top box on the left to the top box 
>> on the right. The "Move" keyboard modifier works, but the "Link" doesn't 
>> work for me.
>
> control-option drop works for me on the LINK target.
> 
> My issue with this test is that pass-fail criteria are not clear.  there is a 
> wall of text that tries to explain things for various tests but I imagine the 
> testers will have hard time trying to parse that out.
> 
> Instead, perhaps, the window should have a third column saying what the 
> tester should do in each case, and the exact pass (or fail) criteria for each 
> case.
> 
> alternatively, since the tester is supposed to match text shown in the source 
> and target area, the test can do it by itself?
> 
> also, we probably should have the test name in the title.

I realized my complaints go way beyond simple "update instructions" task, so we 
could take it as a training exercise for the testers.

-------------

PR Review Comment: https://git.openjdk.org/jfx/pull/2315#discussion_r4065043718

Reply via email to