On 10/10/2014 12:09 PM, Jay Pipes wrote: > Thanks for getting this going, Everett! Comments inline... > > On 10/08/2014 07:05 PM, Everett Toews wrote: >> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/API_Working_Group >> >> This is the start of the API Working Group (API WG). > > yay! :) > >> To avoid bike shedding over the name of the working group, I decided >> to title the wiki page API Working Group. Simple, to the point, and >> avoids loaded terms like standards, best practices, guidelines, >> conventions, etc. > > Yup, ++ > >> The point isn’t what we name it. The point is what action we take >> about it. I propose the deliverables in the API WG wiki page. >> >> Speaking of the wiki page, I wrote it very matter-of-factly. As if >> this is the way things are. They’re not. The wiki page is just a >> starting point. If something was missed, add it. If something can be >> improved, improve it. Let’s try to keep it simple though. > > The wiki content looks fine, with the exception that I really do feel > the working group needs to have some ability to review and enforce > consistency within proposed REST APIs. The wording right now is: > > "The API WG is focused on creating guidelines for the APIs" > > which of course is fine, but I think that the Technical Committee should > essentially grant the working group the power to enforce guidelines and > consistency for proposed new REST APIs -- whether it's a new REST API > version in an existing project or a REST APi for a newly-proposed > OpenStack server project.
I think that's a great goal. I'd like to see the group earn this level of influence based on its own merit rather than have the TC just grant it up front. I'd say let's give the group a cycle to build up, generate guidelines, and participate in API design reviews. I'd rather see it as the TC making something official that was effectively already happening in practice. -- Russell Bryant _______________________________________________ OpenStack-dev mailing list OpenStackemail@example.com http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev