Al-Qaeda & the Muslim Brotherhood: United by Strategy, Divided by Tactics By
Lydia Khalil
[From: Terrorism Monitor (The Jamestown Foundation,USA) Volume 4, Issue 6,
23 March 2006]
For many years, Ayman al-Zawahiri has denounced Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood
for what he claims is the misguided direction they have taken political
Islam. In a recent statement, al-Zawahiri renewed his criticism of the
Ikhwan al-Muslimun ("Muslim Brotherhood") for their participation in Egypt's
parliamentary elections. The Muslim Brotherhood responded to al-Zawahiri's
attack and continues to defend its participation in elections. This recent
public spat between the Muslim Brotherhood and al-Qaeda is emblematic of a
growing rift between the Ikhwan and militant salafists over the most
effective means to promote Islamic governance and combat Western hegemony.
On January 6, al-Zawahiri, former leader of Egypt's Islamic Jihad and
al-Qaeda's leading strategist, recorded a videotape released on al-Jazeera
television. Referring to the Muslim Brotherhood, although not specifying the
organization by name, and sarcastically alluding to the position of Egypt's
Hosni Mubarak regime, al-Zawahiri states, "Today you are winning 80 seats
and after five years you will win 100 seats. Hence, at whatever time your
behavior improves, we will offer you more. Once you become secular and
falsely affiliated with Islam.we will let you assume power provided that you
forget about the rule of Sharia, welcome the Crusaders' bases in your
countries, and acknowledge the existence of the Jews who are fully armed
with nuclear weapons, which you are banned to possess."
Despite what al-Zawahiri claims, the Muslim Brotherhood has not relinquished
the goal of Islamic governance, although their methods to achieve it may
have changed. Nor have the Ikhwan embraced the United States. For the Muslim
Brotherhood, Islam cannot be separated from governance or political life.
According to their slogan, "Allah is our goal; the Messenger is our model;
the Quran is our constitution; jihad is our means; and martyrdom in the way
of Allah is our aspiration."
Although the Muslim Brotherhood has moderated its rhetoric, tactics and
approach over the years, its overarching goal of Islamic governance has not
wavered despite its efforts to publicly de-emphasize this fact.
Al-Qaeda also promotes religious governance in the Muslim world but, as
al-Zawahiri's statement indicates, remains critical of the Muslim
Brotherhood's approach to elections. There is a distinct divergence in
perception regarding the significance of the Muslim Brotherhood's increased
representation in the Egyptian parliament. Clearly, al-Zawahiri perceives
the Muslim Brotherhood's election victory not as a positive step for the
Islamist cause, but as a win for the apostate Egyptian government. He
believes that the Muslim Brotherhood only achieved greater representation in
governance because they moderated in a manner that suited the Egyptian
regime and sold out the salafist vision in order to gain a piece of
political power.
The Muslim Brotherhood's strong showing in the recent elections has made the
Ikhwan's participation in government more visible, but elements of the
Muslim Brotherhood have been entrenched in the Egyptian government for
decades. For instance, their influence within the Egyptian Education
Ministry has been ongoing since the 1970s.
Al-Zawahiri sees the Ikhwan's election victory as part of a long trend of
Islamic dilution and acquiescence to the apostate Egyptian regime.
In reality, however, the insidious penetration of the Egyptian government by
the Muslim Brotherhood has enabled the latter to steadily and covertly
Islamize Egyptian society at all levels.
In a recent opinion piece, Issam al-Aryan provides insight into this
sophisticated strategy: "Implementation on the ground [of democratic
development] portends a great victory for the peaceful democratic Islamic
trend, which is represented by the school of the Muslim Brotherhood. This
victory was achieved in all the elections that were held in the region, in a
process of peaceful change in the center of events and the location of the
historical struggle over the future of the region" (al-Hayat, February 24).
Although they share the same end goal, the Ikhwan's divergent strategy is
problematic for al-Qaeda. For salafists, the Muslim Brotherhood is a
cornerstone organization. They articulated the original philosophy on which
all subsequent Salafi-Jihadist activism is based. The writings of Sayyid
Qutb are the intellectual and theological underpinnings behind organizations
like Egypt's Islamic Jihad, a group headed by al-Zawahiri that ultimately
merged with al-Qaeda. If the Muslim Brotherhood is working through
elections, it disrupts al-Qaeda's agenda for the Middle East.
For al-Qaeda, Egypt features prominently in the vision for an Islamic
caliphate in the Middle East and beyond. This is evident in previous
statements made by al-Zawahiri. In his July 9, 2005 letter to Abu Musab
al-Zarqawi, al-Zawahiri outlines a broad strategy for al-Qaeda in the Middle
East. According to al-Zawahiri's plans, Iraq is only a foothold for
establishing a greater Islamic caliphate to include Syria and Egypt
(DNI.gov, October 11, 2005).
The Muslim Brotherhood's participation in elections that were
state-sponsored and encouraged by the United States seriously disrupts those
plans for a number of reasons. First and foremost, there is the potential
for democracy's moderating influence on the Muslim Brotherhood. By working
with other parties and interests, the Muslim Brotherhood may have to
accommodate other visions and policies in the give and take of parliamentary
politics. According to al-Zawahiri, even if all of the Muslim Brotherhood's
candidates win, they will still be a minority in parliament, never fully
controlling politics or the government. Elections have only allowed Egypt's
governing National Democratic Party to continue its monopoly on power,
stifled the Muslim Brotherhood by token representation in governance and
"produced a parliament that is incapable of making any real change"
(al-Jazeera, January 6).
Second, the elections were encouraged by the United States and any policy
promoted by the U.S. in the region, short of complete withdrawal, is
condemned by al-Qaeda. Al-Zawahiri criticizes the U.S.
for promoting "rigged" elections and manipulating the Muslim
Brotherhood: "The elections were rigged in Egypt while America, the West,
and the United Nations blessed the elections or remained silent.America
organized the game of elections and allowed some currents that belong to
Islam to participate in them with a limited number of candidates.The Muslim
people will be later told, this is the parliament that represents you.This
is the truth of the game run by America in Egypt in the presidential and
parliamentary elections with the aim of deceiving the Muslim masses, who
they instigated and exploited their love of Islam" (al-Jazeera, January 6).
Third, al-Qaeda views the promotion of democracy and elections in Egypt (no
matter how limited or controlled) as a success for the apostate West and not
as a positive development for Muslim society.
The success of U.S. policy of political change through democracy in the
region is at the expense of al-Qaeda's vision of change through militant
jihadist struggle. According to al-Zawahiri: "It is a game of cheating the
Muslim peoples to make them forget their basic rights; that is, the rule of
Sharia, liberation from the occupiers, protection of their sanctities, and
bringing their rulers to account"
(al-Jazeera, January 6).
Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood has not remained quiet in the face of such
criticism. Issam al-Aryan, the Muslim Brotherhood's spokesman, responded to
al-Zawahiri's comments by putting him in the same camp as secularists and
supporters and apologists of the Egyptian regime who oppose the
Brotherhood's participation in elections (al-Sharq al-Awsat, January 7).
Other senior members of the Brotherhood, such as Abdel Moneim Aboul Fotouh,
have used al-Zawahiri's criticism to further distance themselves from the
taint of al-Qaeda's violent tactics and to prove their credentials as
serious politicians who are capable of moderation and compromise. Referring
to al-Zawahiri and al-Qaeda, Fotouh states, "Those people aren't
politicians. They believe in change through violence. That's not what we're
about.If there is anything to be realized from these elections, it is that
people will choose a moderate Islam" (Ikhwanweb.com, March 10).
Al-Zawahiri's criticism of the Muslim Brotherhood's election strategy has
not compelled the Ikhwan to change tactics, but neither has it caused them
to forgo sympathizing with the militant jihadist struggle coordinated by
al-Qaeda. Moreover, while al-Zawahiri has criticized the Muslim
Brotherhood's strategy, the Brotherhood has not reciprocated. Egyptian MP
and Muslim Brotherhood member Ragib Hilal Hamida has been on the record
stating that he supports al-Qaeda and that the Quran condones terrorism. He
clarifies his position by claiming that terrorism is not a criminal act, but
rather a resistance to occupation and the influence of non-Islamic powers,
which is legitimate in the eyes of the Quran.
In an interview with Roz al-Yousef, an Egyptian weekly, Hamida states:
"Terrorism is not a curse when given its true meaning. [When interpreted
accurately] it means opposing occupation as it exists in Palestine,
Afghanistan and Iraq.From my point of view, bin Laden, al-Zawahiri and
al-Zarqawi are not terrorists in the sense accepted by some. I support all
their activities since they are a thorn in the side of the Americans and the
Zionists" (Roz al-Yousef, January 28-February 3).
Like any political organization, the Muslim Brotherhood has its hardliners,
reformers and centrists, and Hamida's views are not universally held by the
Muslim Brotherhood. They are, however, representative of the Brotherhood's
broader thinking. The disagreement with al-Qaeda is over tactics, not
ideology, even though this particular MP supports al-Qaeda's tactics as
well.
Hamida's comments are a boon for the Egyptian regime, which was badly shaken
by the Brotherhood's election victory. The closer the association between
al-Qaeda and the Muslim Brotherhood, the better it is for Mubarak and his
supporters. As long as they can make the argument that the Muslim
Brotherhood and al-Qaeda are two sides of the same coin, they can continue
arresting Brotherhood members and postponing municipal elections where the
Ikhwan are likely to make a strong showing.
The crux of the debate between al-Qaeda and the Muslim Brotherhood is not
over the ends, but rather the means by which to realize the greater goal of
Islamic governance throughout the Muslim world.
Al-Zawahiri's criticism of Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood is evocative of a
larger, ongoing debate in salafist circles over which strategy-militancy or
elections-will achieve the larger goal of Islamic governance and
independence from Western influence. The debate is not resolved, but the
Ikhwan are aware and careful not to make their election strategy a cause of
schism among salafist activists, despite occasional public disagreements.
http://www.jamestown.org/terrorism/news/article.php?articleid=2369939
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
Great things are happening at Yahoo! Groups. See the new email design.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/TISQkA/hOaOAA/yQLSAA/TySplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->
--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.intellnet.org
Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods,
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,'
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/