17.01.11 Tunisia: The Struggle for Legitimacy by Dyab Abou Jahjah http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/2011/jahjah170111.html
In Tunisia, a new government is being formed under the leadership of the RCD (the party of the fallen dictator) and with the participation of some legalized opposition parties. All parties that were illegal under the old regimes are being excluded, however, and this is stirring up a lot of controversy among parts of the Tunisian population who feel that the Revolution is being driven away from its ideals. The main view of the opposition is that the people who made the revolution are not represented and that by keeping the RCD on board and even at the steering wheel the former regime is perpetuating itself. On the other hand, the pro-coalition voices stress that this is only a transition, necessary to avoid plunging the country in chaos. Some argue that, now that the revolution deposed the tyrant, the country must seek reconciliation, and they also argue that the RCD has hundreds of thousands of members and excluding them would exclude important segments of society. However, most of these members were in the RCD not for an ideology or a vision, but because a party card was synonymous with personal advancement under the old regime. I wonder if the RCD will have more than a few thousand hardcore Ben Ali loyalists if things are left to take their natural course. But even if the RCD were a real party with a real base of supporters, it is now the duty of these people -- if they want national reconciliation -- to distance themselves from the past and its crimes by changing their party's name and going to the opposition. "Why should national reconciliation be the responsibility of the oppressed?" many rightly ask. And they also believe that the best strategy to use now is a transitional committee representing all currents of the people and its trade unions and excluding the RCD as such while including some independents who are not far from it and that this committee should lead the country into transition towards a free and fair election where the chances of all the parties are equal. In my opinion, the Americans and the French have certainly played a role in convincing parts of the mild opposition to support this government in order to guarantee continuation of the old economic structure and its integration as a service economy for France, plus the political and military alliance with the U.S and NATO. The risk is that this government will not be so transitory after all and will only serve as an excuse to win more time and allow intelligent services and regime loyalists to work on their strategy to take back control of the country, albeit under another leader who will govern slightly differently than Ben Ali but will be just as autocratic and corrupt and pro-Western. This is a real risk and the people started protesting against this government today and in Tunis the governmental police used tear gas against the demonstrators. On a side note: 6 Algerians, 1 Egyptian, and a Mauritanian burned themselves in clear attempts to emulate the igniting act of the Tunisian revolution. Dyab Abou Jahjah is founder and former president of the Arab European League. This article was first published in his blog Abou Jahjah Comments on 17 January 2011; .................................................................... Tunisia: the need for vigilance http://www.al-bab.com/blog/2011/blog1101b.htm#tunisia_the_need_for_vigilance Having got rid of Ben Ali and his family, the question now for Tunisians is how to dismantle the system of control that he established over the last 23 years and it's looking far from easy. Without continuous pressure from the public, the Ben Ali loyalists are likely to retrench and continue running the country much as before minus Ben Ali of course, and perhaps in a slightly less repressive way. The "new" government announced yesterday is not a good start. Give or take a few opposition figures, it looks suspiciously like the old one: same prime minister, same people in all the key positions. And all the opposition parties included in it are those that Ben Ali approved of with none of the parties that he banned. This can be excused, to some extent, on the grounds of maintaining legitimacy: that constitutional procedures have to be followed and that the outlawed parties are well still technically illegal. It has be remembered, though, that the legitimacy such as it is comes from a constitution that was never designed to be genuinely democratic and is derived from a regime that many would not regard as legitimate in any case. The crucial issue is whether this new government is one to set the country on a path to transition of whether it will merely try to consolidate whatever can be salvaged from the old regime. Either way, the new government may only last a couple of months. Under the constitution, a presidential election must be held within 60 days of Ben Ali's departure (no later than March 12 by my reckoning). The new president is then empowered to form a new government and dissolve the existing parliament. Sixty days is a very short time to organise a presidential campaign from scratch and this probably gives Ben Ali's Constitutional Democratic Rally (RCD) party, with its structure still largely intact, a considerable advantage regardless of any other attempts to manipulate the result. Another question here concerns the presidential candidates. As Ibn Kafka points out in his blog, in order to contest the election they need 30 signatures from members of parliament or presidents of city councils. It's not clear at present how much of an obstacle that might become, but the RCD currently holds 161 of the 214 parliamentary seats. In order to muster 30 parliamentary signatures without RCD support, candidates will need backing from at least three of the smaller opposition parties. However, if the RCD wants to avoid generating more hostility among the public it would be well-advised not to use this power to block any serious opposition candidates. I have been trying to find out how the voting is supposed to work in Tunisian presidential elections but so far I don't have an answer. If there are more than two candidates, does the winner need more than 50% of the votes, or is it a first-past-the-post system? The question was irrelevant before, because Ben Ali always won with majorities that were never less than 89%, but it's relevant now. If it's a first-past-the-post system, there's a risk of splitting the opposition vote among multiple candidates and letting the RCD candidate slip through by default. A new president is empowered by the constitution (article 57) to dissolve parliament and hold elections within 30 days. However, he (or she??) is not obliged to do so and in theory the existing parliament could remain in place until its term ends in October 2014. I'm not suggesting this is necessarily what will happen but it's worth keeping in mind that without extreme vigilance on the part of the Tunisian public, the country might find itself, a few months from now, with another RCD president and a parliament still dominated by Ben Ali's party. Tunisians are going to have to remain very watchful, and keep up the pressure for change. Posted by Brian Whitaker, 18 Jan 2011. Comment. ................................................................... Tunisia's tide of defiance As revolutionary zeal engulfs the region, the people must be on their guard against the forces seeking to smother it. Mohammed Khan Last Modified: 18 Jan 2011 08:29 GMT http://english.aljazeera.net/indepth/opinion/2011/01/20111178151948130.html Eastern European nations, for decades shackled under the weight of Communism, were the last geographical bloc to break the chains of oppression en masse, and in the process shed a history of subservience to a far off and, to many, an alien political culture. How that landscape has now changed. While Eastern Europe is now free, the plight of the majority of the Arab world is reminiscent of the worst excesses of Soviet rule: Political repression is the norm, civil society is suffocated while a political elite operates in a parallel existence intoxicated by the stench of absolute power. Lest anyone think oppression breeds indifference, however, the people of Tunisia have just turned history on its head and unleashed a defiance that is bound to resonate with the people of neighbouring nations and to shake the thrones of Arab despots. Do not underestimate the psychological impact of what Tunisians have just achieved. Arab regimes have had a free hand at imposing their will on reluctant populations through the use of a single instrument: Fear. In the space of just a few weeks, masses of Tunisians have demonstrated to the Arab region the limits of dictatorial rule. The death of one young Tunisian who set fire to himself in an act of desperation lit the fuse of popular protests against mounting economic turmoil, blistering corruption and a massive breach of trust with the ruling class. Where perhaps just a month ago such anger would have been momentary and the rage dowsed by pure state brutality, the strength of feeling that has propelled Tunisians to fight the state has proven overwhelming and irreversible. It is such sentiment which has resonated so profoundly across the region. The rage is not specific to Tunisia: almost identical conditions fester right across the Middle East. Tunisia in this instance could just as well be Algeria, Libya, Morocco, Egypt, Jordan or Syria. (This is to momentarily ignore the political situation in the Gulf region.) What is not lost on most of the protest voices in the region is the sheer complicity of Western nations which have long waved an abstract, need one say meaningless, flag of freedom. The violent protests that greeted the result of the Iranian election were utilised to maximum effect by governments in the US and Europe. Iranian leaders, rightly so, were at the end of some heavy political vitriol from Western powers. The popular revolution that many had thought - wished - would materialise in Iran has forced itself on Tunisia. No words of praise for Tunisians, however, from Western quarters for toppling their dictator, unsurprisingly. Beware the French As the former colonial overlord in Tunisia, France has a history of deceit, mendacity and, to boot, hypocrisy in relation to North Africa. How often are the French wont to proclaim liberté, égalité, fraternité as their most fundamental values? As far as French policy in North Africa is concerned, we may add another: Fallacy. The Tunisian despot's closeness to France was legendary. Despite achieving independence from France, Tunisia remained subject to its puppet master's whims under its dictatorial regime. Something of a similar revolution spread across Algeria some two decades ago. Back then, with the avowed backing of the French state, Algerian security forces trampled over Algerian democracy precipitating a brutal civil war. For Tunisia's revolution not to be short-lived, the population will need to be alert to the behind-the-scenes machinations and manoeuvrings of the French. That France refused refuge to the deposed despot was not a sign of the former's solidarity with the Tunisian people. Rather a play at real politik by the French and a little forward thinking in how best to influence future events in Tunisia. If a new system beckons in Tunisia, the people would do well to distance themselves from France. The Arab world has had little cause for celebration of late. At the mercy of long-standing kingdoms and hereditary life-time autocrats, political suffocation has been the order of the day. Defeatism had taken hold over civil society. But the momentous events in Tunisia show how no amount of bloodletting will kill peoples' spirit. Platitudes from foreign powers are unnecessary now. The people of the Middle East are capable of building their own futures as they see fit. Despite such optimism, however, do not be surprised if the new revolutionary zeal is buried prematurely given what it may mean for Western policy. The tide of defiance will not easily be pushed back. That is not to say there will not be many forces out there employing all means necessary to smother it. Tunisians and Arabs are only at the very early stages of their struggle for freedom and must be on their guard against the difficult obstacles ahead. Mohammed Khan is a political analyst based in the UAE. .................................................................. 18 January 2011 Last updated at 11:40 GMT Tunisia: Key players http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-12214649 It is less than a week since the ousting of Tunisia's long-time president, Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali, in a popular uprising that has shaken up the North African country. Already, a transition government is taking shape, and fresh elections have been promised within six to seven months. Here are some of the key players inside the new administration, and some other important figures to watch outside the country. Old guard Ministers: The country is being led by interim President Fouad Mebazaa, the former parliamentary speaker. Six ministers from ousted President Ben Ali's old administration have reappeared in the new unity government of Prime Minister Mohammed Ghannouchi, himself an ally of the former president who has served as premier since 1999. Foreign Minister Kamal Morjane, Interior Minister Ahmed Friaa, Defence Minister Ridha Grira and Finance Minister Mohamed Ridha Chelghoum are among those who held on to key posts. Army: It is widely believed that the Tunisian army's chief of staff played a key role in undermining Mr Ben Ali in the days before he fled Tunisia. Gen Rachid Ammar is believed to have resigned, refusing to order the army to fire on unarmed protesters and effectively withdrawing the military's support from the former president. Analysts say that the chief of staff is now the power behind the scenes in Tunisia and may have political ambitions of this own. Political parties: Under President Ben Ali, Tunisia was effectively under one-party rule. But several other parties exist. They include the Movement of Socialist Democrats, Party of People's Unity, Unionist Democratic Union, Renewal Movement (Ettajdid), Democratic Initiative Movement, Social Liberal Party and the Green Party for Progress. New faces Nejib Chebbi Najib Chebbi has been one of the most outspoken critics of the Tunisian government In a first for Tunisia, Prime Minister Ghannouchi has included three opposition politicians in the interim government. Ahmed Ibrahim, leader of the Ettajdid party, becomes minister of higher education. Mustafa Ben Jaafar, of the Union of Freedom and Labour (FDTL), is to serve as health minister. And Najib Chebbi, founder of the Progressive Democratic Party, was named Tunisia's new development minister. Slim Amamou, a dissident blogger who was arrested during the protests, was named Tunisia's new secretary of state for youth and sport. Exiled opposition The main Tunisian parties in exile include the al-Nahda party (Renaissance), based in Britain, and the Congress for the Republic in France. It is not known if they have a support base inside the country. Al-Nahda is a banned Islamist party led by Rachid Ghannouchi, who was sentenced to life in prison under the old regime for plotting against the state. Prime Minister Ghannouchi (no relation) has banned him from returning until an amnesty law is approved. The party, based in London, says it advocates democracy, recognises political pluralism, and backs dialogue with the West. It seeks an Islamic constitution for the country. The Congress for the Republic is a banned secular party led by Moncef Marzouki from Paris. Mr Marzouki has denounced political parties in Tunisia for co-operating with the Ben Ali regime and says he plans to return to the country to contest elections. The party has campaigned for human rights, an independent judiciary and free elections. .................................................................. Tunisia: the first Arab revolution Mona Eltahawy http://www.hindu.com/2011/01/18/stories/2011011855871300.htm Every July 23 for the past 58 years Egypt, my country of birth, has celebrated its July revolution that overthrew King Farouk and ended the monarchy and British occupation once and for all. It was no revolution: it was a coup staged by young Army officers. And so it has been with a series of revolutions around the Arab world in which a succession of military men went on to lead us in civilian clothes some kept the olive drabs on and rob generations of the real meaning of revolution. For years I looked at the Iranians with envy not at the outcome of their 1979 revolution, but because it was a popular uprising, not a euphemism for a coup. So you'll understand why, along with millions of other Arabs, I'll forever cherish January 14, 2011 the day Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali fled Tunisia, his 23-year rule toppled by 29 days of a popular uprising. A real revolution for a change. It's the first time Arabs have toppled one of their dictators, so you'll understand why, despite the reports of chaos, looting and a musical chairs of caretaker leaders, I'm still celebrating. Let's have no whining about how those pesky Tunisians who risked their lives in their thousands to face down a despot ruined the idyllic package-holiday-in-a-police-state for so many European tourists. The equations circling Tunisia right now are very clear: we have no idea who or what kind of coalition of leaders will emerge but there is no doubt who's rooting for the failure of this revolution: every Arab leader who has spent the past month watching Tunisia in fear. You can be sure the region's dictators are on their knees right now praying for chaos and collapse for Tunisia. Some Arab countries have simply ignored what happened: no official statement from Algeria or Morocco. Others said they respect the wish of Tunisians but filled their state-owned media with reminders that they weren't anything like Tunisia: Egypt. Leave it to Muammar Gaddafi, the world's longest-serving dictator, to best portray that panic. Addressing a nation where thousands had faced down the bullets of Mr. Ben Ali's security to protest at unemployment, police brutality and the corruption of the regime, Mr. Gaddafi told Tunisians they were now suffering bloodshed and lawlessness because they were too hasty in getting rid of Mr. Ben Ali. If every Arab leader has watched Tunisia in fear, then every Arab citizen has watched in hope because it was neither Islamists long used by our leaders to scare many into acquiescence nor foreign troops that toppled the dictator: it was ordinary and very fed up people. Tunisians must remember that during these days of chaos. We're hearing reports that neighbourhood watch committees have sprung up to protect against looting and violence, which many blame on Mr. Ben Ali's loyalists. Interestingly, both Western observers and Mr. Gaddafi have been crediting WikiLeaks, but for different reasons. By buying into the idea that leaked U.S. embassy cables about corruption fuelled the revolution, commentators smear Tunisians with ignorance of facts and perpetuate the myth that Arabs are incapable of rising up against dictators. Mr. Gaddafi railed against WikiLeaks because he, too, wants to blame something other than the power of the people and cables from Tripoli portray him as a Botox-using neurotic inseparable from a voluptuous Ukrainian nurse. Mr. Gaddafi's Libya has had its own protests over the past few days. Nothing on the scale of Tunisia, but enough that his speech to Tunisians could be summarised thus: I am scared witless by what happened in your country. That's why I insist we stop and appreciate Tunisia: relish the revolution that is no longer a euphemism for a coup. © Guardian Newspapers Limited, 2011 (Mona Eltahawy is a writer and lecturer on Arab issues.) .................................................................... Monde 18/01/2011 à 00h00 «Nous navons pas encore notre Lech Walesa ou notre Vaclav Havel» Interview Pour Abdelwahab Meddeb, écrivain, la transition prendra nécessairement du temps : Par MARC SEMO http://www.liberation.fr/monde/01012314311-nous-n-avons-pas-encore-notre-lec h-walesa-ou-notre-vaclav-havel Ecrivain et essayiste (1), Abdelwahab Meddeb évoque les enjeux et les défis du processus démocratique quentame la Tunisie après vingt-trois ans de dictature du clan Ben Ali. Quels sont les premiers défis à relever? Même sil passe pour intègre, le Premier ministre Mohamed Ghannouchi [qui na pas quitté son poste, ndlr] reste un homme de lancien régime, une ombre de ce théâtre dombres, car seul décidait vraiment Ben Ali. Or la politique est aussi de lordre du symbolique et, sur ce plan, cest catastrophique. Il faut au plus vite tourner la page sur tout ce qui peut rappeler le pouvoir de celui que nous surnommions ironiquement Chéri-Bibi. Il faut durgence un geste fort comme, par exemple, la dissolution du RCD, parti- Etat devenu parti-mafia, qui pourrait être un signal en ce sens. Le défi est de savoir comment mener ce processus nécessairement assez long et définir un certain nombre de priorités. Dans limmédiat, il me semble nécessaire de se conformer à lactuelle légalité constitutionnelle. La Constitution a été malmenée, défigurée, dabord par Habib Bourguiba lui-même, quand il a créé la présidence à vie, puis par Ben Ali. Mais malgré ces déformations, le noyau de ce texte datant de 1957 est à préserver, car il affirme des points toujours essentiels, comme la laïcité ou légalité de tous les citoyens quels que soient leur sexe, leur religion, leur ethnie. Dans cette constitution, il ny a pas de trace de la charia, aucune référence à la loi islamique comme inspiratrice du droit, contrairement aux constitutions de nombreux autres pays arabo-musulmans. Mais il faut durgence nettoyer ce texte de tout ce qui en a dénaturé lesprit. Et la loi électorale a été modifiée afin de donner plus de temps que soixante jours pour la tenue des premières élections libres. Une nouvelle constitution ne peut sélaborer dans lurgence, mais après un grand débat national, qui peut durer des années et qui seul permettra de fertiliser le désert de lespace public laissé par Ben Ali. Quels peuvent être, selon vous, les principaux acteurs de la transition démocratique ? On parle aujourdhui, en Tunisie, de gouvernement de salut public avec un vocabulaire évoquant un peu la Révolution française. Mais lopposition - aussi bien lopposition légale représentée dans le pseudo-Parlement du régime que celle des partis clandestins - ne dispose que dun personnel politique dassez piètre niveau. Elle contraste avec la qualité des opposants issus de la société civile qui se sont engagés dans le mouvement : des militants syndicaux de lUGTT, les membres des associations davocats ou dorganisations de défense des droits de lhomme. Il y a ce hiatus, dautant que ce mouvement sans précédent na pas encore produit la personnalité charismatique qui lincarnerait. Nous nous trouvons face à un paysage politique dévasté. La situation nest pas sans rappeler celle de lEurope de lEst au moment de leffondrement du communisme. La figure de Mohamed Bouazizi [le jeune chômeur diplômé dont le suicide, le 17 décembre dernier, a déclenché la révolte] rappelle celle du jeune Tchèque Jan Palach, qui sétait aussi immolé par le feu pour protester contre linvasion soviétique daoût 1968. Mais si nous avons notre Jan Palach, nous navons pas encore notre Lech Walesa ou notre Vaclav Havel. Etes-vous préoccupé par les risques dune montée des partis islamistes avec les premières élections libres ? Jusquici, ils nont pas eu vraiment de rôle dans le mouvement qui a renversé la dictature de Ben Ali. Ils étaient absents aussi de la protestation populaire qui, à Sidi-Bouzid, a donné le coup denvoi de la révolte, que parmi les couches moyennes éduquées et très francophones qui ont pris le relais. Mais les directs de la télévision Al-Jezira mettent systématiquement en avant des islamistes ou des gens proches de cette mouvance, et cela peut avoir pour effet de les remettre sur le devant de la scène politique. Linquiétude est déjà palpable parmi ces jeunes de la blogosphère qui furent parmi les premiers à sengager dans la bataille. Mais il ne faut pas en faire un épouvantail, car il y a dans de nombreux secteurs de la société tunisienne un rejet profond de tout ce qui peut évoquer lislamisme. Ce problème ne se résout pas par les interdictions, ni par la violence dun Etat policier, mais par le débat démocratique, la confrontation didées. Sils utilisent les armes et prônent la violence, ils doivent alors être traités comme des séditieux. Les islamistes représentent-ils à terme le principal défi pour la Tunisie ? Les islamistes tunisiens pourront, jespère, évoluer comme les islamistes turcs de lAKP qui, malgré des ambiguïtés, ont effectué une mutation et ont accepté la démocratie. Jétais un intégriste laïc et jai évolué. On ne peut pas imposer den haut et par la force la laïcité et la démocratie. La liberté est un droit naturel. (1) Dernier ouvrage paru : Pari de civilisation. Seuil (2009) ...................................................................... MIXED FEELINGS http://www.telegraphindia.com/1110118/jsp/opinion/story_13454086.jsp Revolutions are not a thing of the past. But that is not the only lesson the overthrow of the 23-year-old regime of Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali in Tunisia is teaching the world. The upheaval in the north African nation that followed a mass movement against the president shows the potency popular uprisings still retain. It also reaffirms the fact that contrary to the presumption of an increasingly Islamophobic world, religion is not the sole factor motivating a Muslim-majority nation. The reasons behind the downfall of Mr Ben Ali were high unemployment, wide economic disparities, incessant price rise and corruption. These are not factors affecting Tunisia alone. In fact, a combination of these has brought on similar mass movements in many of Tunisias neighbours in Africa, particularly Algeria, which has witnessed a simultaneous mass aggression on the same issues. The reason why the movement in Tunisia led to a sudden regime change may take some more time to fathom. But there is no doubt that the aspirations Mr Ben Ali had created with his liberal reforms and emphasis on literacy had come up against a wall when faced with the other more repressive and regressive facets of his dictatorial regime. Mr Ben Alis inability to deal with the contradiction in his policies and the lack of support from the traditional backers of his government, such as France, may have forced him to throw in the towel and seek asylum in Saudi Arabia. The success of the mass uprising in Tunisia, the first of its kind in the Arab world, should have been greeted with joy. Yet, it is causing a lot of apprehension, both in the West and in Muslim-majority nations. The latter fear that Tunisias experiment with democracy could have a domino effect on other nations in the Arab world that are undergoing similar economic crises. There are even chances that Mr Ben Alis failed liberalism may set off these nations on a more regressive path. The fears of the West are even more real. Tunisia, given its place in the Islamic Maghreb, was seen as a bulwark against the religious radicalism of the Levant, and its attendant ills. Mr Ben Alis willingness to play his part in this was also one reason the West turned a blind eye to his dictatorial style. With him gone, and chaos reigning unabated in Tunisia, it may not be too long before the Islamic radicals, once banned by Mr Ben Ali, seize their chance. ................................................................... Why the Tunisian revolution won't spread Posted By Stephen M. Walt Sunday, January 16, 2011 - 4:50 PM Share http://walt.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/01/15/why_the_tunisian_revolution_w ont_spread The toppling of the Tunisian regime led by Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali has led a lot of smart people -- including my FP colleague Marc Lynch -- to suggest that this might be the catalyst for a wave of democratization throughout the Arab world. The basic idea is that events in Tunisia will have a powerful demonstration effect (magnified by various forms of new media), leading other unhappy masses to rise up and challenge the stultifying dictatorships in places like Egypt or Syria. The obvious analogy (though not everyone makes it) is to the velvet revolutions in Eastern Europe, or perhaps the various "color revolutions" that took place in places like Ukraine or Georgia. Color me skeptical. In fact, the history of world revolution suggests that this sort of revolutionary cascade is quite rare, and even when some sort of revolutionary contagion does take place, it happens pretty slowly and is often accompanied by overt foreign invasion. For starters, the French revolution did not in fact ignite sympathetic revolutions across Europe. True, assorted monarchies were eventually toppled, but that was mostly done by the bayonets of the French army. Similarly, although many people feared that Bolshevism would spread across Europe after 1917, it did not in fact prove to be very contagious and the expansion of international communism didn't take place until World War II, once again largely backed by the might of the Red Army (or by indigenous communists like Mao Zedong, and only after decades of civil war). The Iranian revolution in 1979 did not prove to be an especially contagious model either; although sympathizers did emerge in several places (e.g., Lebanon), we've hardly seen a wave of Khomeini-style revolutions over the past 30 years. The velvet revolution in Easter Europe are a partial exception, but mostly because the Soviet Union's Eastern Europe satellites were all dependent on the threat of Soviet invasion to keep their artificial regimes in power. Once the common keystone of Soviet power was no longer credible, however, all of these dominos could in fact fall down in a row. But that's not the case in the Arab world. Although most Arab governments are authoritarian, they are also all independent and depend on a slightly different mix of political institutions and measures to keep the rulers in power. The fact that Ben Ali ultimately mismanaged a challenge and was driven from power does not mean that other Arab leaders won't be able to deflect, deter, or suppress challenges to their rule. There are three other reasons why the Tunisian example is unlikely to lead to similar upheavals elsewhere. First, as Timur Kuran http://www.citeulike.org/user/pauljohn32/article/5433535 and others have shown, the actual revolutionary potential of any society is very difficult to read in advance, and a rising revolutionary wave often depends on very particular preferences and information effects within society. Put differently, whether a genuine upheavel breaks out and gathers steam is a highly contingent process. Second, Tunisia is an obvious warning sign to other Arab dictatorships, and they are bound to be especially vigilant in the months ahead, lest some sort of similar revolutionary wave begin to emerge. Third, Tunisia's experience may not look very attractive over the next few weeks or months, especially if the collapse of the government leads to widespread anarchy, violence and economic hardship. If that is the case, then restive populations elsewhere may be less inclined to challenge unpopular leaders, reasoning that "hey, our government sucks, but it's better than no government at all." All of this is not to say that a cascade is impossible, that events in Tunisia won't exert a long-term effect on political discussion elsewhere, or that it is not a telling sign of democratic aspirations that are likely to bear fruit eventually. But "eventually" could be a rather long time, and if you are expecting to see a rapid transformation of the Arab world in the wake of these events, you're likely to be disappointed. For more extended reflections on some of these points, see this http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2000/11/01/fads_fevers_and_firestorms or this. .................................................................. Jan 19, 2011 'Mr Tunisia' goes out with a whimper By Sami Moubayed http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/MA19Ak02.html DAMASCUS - After 23 years of autocratic rule, Tunisian President Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali was toppled from power in one of the most dramatic and inspiring events in contemporary Arab history. It wasn't United States tanks that rolled into Tunis on Friday night, like the ones that brought down Saddam Hussein in 2003. It wasn't turbaned clerics seizing power, like what happened when the Shah of Iran was deposed in 1979. Nor was it flamboyant officers with no political experience like those who toppled King Farouk of Egypt in 1952. It was the people of Tunis - the young and old, the educated and ordinary citizen - who rose with one voice and demanded the downfall of Ben Ali. It all started when Tunisian police confiscated a fruit and vegetable cart on the streets of Sidi Bouzid, 200 kilometers from the capital Tunis, on December 17, 2010. Its owner, Mohammad Bouazizi, 26, seemingly did not have a peddler's permit. Bouazizi, a fresh university graduate who had been unable to find a decent job, was furious. He tried to lodge a complaint at a local municipal office, with no luck. He then left his mother a farewell note on Facebook, stood before a government building, and set himself ablaze. Three weeks later, he died from his wounds, igniting street protests and demonstrations that demanded an end to political persecution, more jobs, better pay, and more freedoms. Five thousand mourners took part in his funeral, chanting: "We will avenge you Mohammad." Police shot at the young men on the streets, dispersing them with brute force, while on January 10, Ben Ali described them as "masked bandits" manipulated by outside powers. The demonstrations, originally staged by unions but quickly snowballing into an unstoppable youth movement, soon reached far and wide, forcing Ben Ali to sack his top officials. Last Thursday, he gave an ostensibly emotional speech to his citizens saying: "I understand you; please stop the violence." He promised more freedoms, in addition to 300,000 new jobs, and pledged that he would not seek re-election in 2014. It was too late; the die had been cast and there was no turning back for the angry people of Tunisia. Twenty-four hours later, Ben Ali stepped down in disgrace. Realizing that he was politically finished, the 75-year-old president boarded a plane along with members of his family and left the country on January 14. Looting, robbery, and chaos swept through the country as security collapsed - criminals were set free from prisons, stores were stormed and vandalized and self-armed militias emerged on the streets, protecting entire neighborhoods. By Saturday, Ben Ali's speaker of parliament, Fouad Mebazaa, was in power as an interim president, appointing Prime Minister Mohamed Ghannouchi to form a caretaker government that would supervise elections, which would take place in six to seven months. The humiliated Ben Ali tried to head to France, a country that had ardently supported him for two decades, but his ally President Nicolas Sarkozy refused to grant him asylum. He tried Malta, the United Arab Emirates, and Italy, with no avail. He finally ended up in Saudi Arabia, at the same residence once occupied by Ugandan ex-president Idi Amin. Amin, a brutal despot by all accounts, had spent the final 13 years of his life at the same villa, dreaming of a comeback to power in Uganda. He died there miserably in 2003. The residence, with all its political symbolism, must have psychologically difficult for Ben Ali to accept. So was the fact that after fighting veiled woman during his entire career, and preventing mosques from loud prayer in Tunis, he suddenly found himself in a country filled with veiled women, surrounded by mosque prayers. Arab youth were fixated on the Tunis revolt, which some have also called the Bouazizi revolt. They were tuned into al-Jazeera and al-Arabiya, while millions changed their profile pictures on Facebook into the flag of Tunis. Others typed in a status that read: "Go away Ben Ali", "Game Over" or "Viva Tunis." Most of the Arabs watching the saga unfold in Tunis knew very little about Tunisia or Ben Ali. Apart from hosting the Palestinian Liberation Organization in the 1980s and early 1990s, Tunis was never at the heart of the Arab-Israeli conflict. Ben Ali was rarely mentioned in the Arabic press, certainly no match for Saddam Hussein, Yasser Arafat or Hosni Mubarak - but all Arabs below the age of 25 were born during his presidency and had grown up knowing that he was "Mr Tunisia". Arabs, however, were inspired by his thundering fall, dreaming of a day they could carry out similar revolts in countries ruled for far too long by aged and ailing dictators like Libya's Muammar Gaddafi and Egypt's Mubarak. Gaddafi's defense of Ben Ali only made things worse for unpopular Arab leaders. Over the weekend, he broke all silence within Arab officialdom by coming out in defense of his old friend and neighbor, Ben Ali. "You have suffered a great" loss he told the Tunisians, "There is nobody better to govern Tunis." As far as he was concerned, Ben Ali - who by now had taken up temporary residence in Saudi Arabia - was still the "legitimate president of Tunisia". No sooner had Ben Ali left his country than demonstrations were staged outside the Tunisian Embassy in Cairo, with Egyptians calling on Mubarak - who has been in power since 1981 and plans on running for presidential office again in 2011, at the age of 84 - to step down. As the violence began to settle in different parts of Tunis, ordinary citizens began to take a long hard look at what happened in their country. Ironically, the circumstances that led to Ben Ali's rise to power in 1987 were very similar to the ones that toppled him in 2011. Back then, it was also an uprising, known as an "intifada of bread" triggered by ordinary citizens protesting the high cost of living, unemployment and a government decision to lift subsidies over certain basic commodities. The aging president Habib Bourguiba carried out a series of symbolic changes to please his angry countrymen, sacking the minister of interior and summoning his ambassador from Warsaw - General Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali - and appointing him director of national security. Ben Ali struck with an iron fist, arresting union leaders who had staged the revolt, along with heavyweights in the Islamic opposition. Then in November 1987, he staged what has been called a "medical coup" against president Bourguiba, declaring him unfit to resume his duties. Ben Ali rose to the presidency at the relatively young age of 49, sidelining Bourguiba s wife, who had her own plans for who would succeed her husband as president of Tunis. The masses originally cheered Ben Ali, who quickly released the same men he had placed behind bars only two years earlier, and banned both torture in jails and arbitrary arrests. Those reforms eventually evaporated into thin air, as Ben Ali evolved into an autocrat, identical to his political godfather, Bourguiba. There are numerous lessons to be learned from Tunisia 2011. One is that the will of the people - which brought down the king of Egypt in 1952 and the Shah of Iran in 1979 - still matters in North Africa, the Middle East and Arab Gulf. This might explain why there are two kinds of leaders in the Arab world; those who rely on their people for support, and those who rely on the West. Ben Ali, Farouk and the Shah relied on the West, but the West abandoned them without even blinking when it was clear that their regimes were no longer useful. The other kinds of leaders are those like president Gamal Abdul Nasser of Egypt, and Bashar al-Assad of Syria. When Nasser faced the Suez war of 1956, the people of Egypt came out in his defense. When he stepped down in 1967, the people of Egypt came out in millions, asking him to stay in power. The same applied to Syria's Assad, whose people rallied around him during the difficult years of the George W Bush White House, especially in 2003-2005. This is the hard lesson of what happened to Ben Ali, who gambled on the French and the Americans during his 23 years in power. Both countries knew exactly what kind of rule Ben Ali was applying in Tunis, with WikiLeaks recently saying that the US Embassy in Tunisia described the government there as a mafia. At curtain fall, however, the US did not lift a finger to protect him, although it was about to grant him US$12 million in military aid this year. United States President Barack Obama, whose country has turned a blind eye to all of Ben Ali's repressive measures, came out with a booming statement last Friday about the "brave and determined struggle for the universal rights we must all uphold". Sami Moubayed is a Syrian political analyst. ..................................................................... Did Iraq have something to do with Tunisia's uprising? That's the question posed by Elizabeth Rubin, a conservative blogger for the Washington Post. By Dan Murphy, Staff writer / January 17, 2011 http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Backchannels/2011/0117/Did-Iraq-have-somethin g-to-do-with-Tunisia-s-uprising Elizabeth Rubin, a conservative commentator who writes the "Right Turn" blog for the Washington Post has an extended set of musings on Tunisia's Jasmine Revolution today, in which she criticizes Hillary Clinton for a "wishy-washy" statement in support of the nation's protesters and advises President Obama to push the region to give its people a real political voice. Dan Murphy, who has reported from Iraq, Afghanistan, Egypt, and more than a dozen other countries, writes and edits Backchannels. The focus? War and international relations, leaning toward things Middle East. Obama should adopt "concrete polices that can assist democracy advocates not only in Tunisia, but in Jordan, Egypt and elsewhere. If Obama wants to do some more productive "Muslim Outreach," he should stop trying to ingratiate himself with despotic leaders and show that America is, and will continue to be, on the side of those yearning for freedom," she writes. The problem has always been what concrete action Obama, or any American president, should take as they seek to balance America's often competing interests in the region. Sacrifice intelligence sharing with Egypt or Yemen in exchange for a principled stand and cutting off military aid? Demand fair elections that might well deliver political forces hostile to the US agenda in the region into power? And in the specific case of Tunisia, the fact that the uprising that drove President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali was both spontaneous and entirely local, has been one of its great assets in the eyes of activists that would like to emulate the Jasmine Revolution in places like Egypt or Algeria. There's an argument to be made that the US should express support for democratic change in Tunisia, but avoid getting in the way of a revolution it's had nothing to do with so far and whose ultimate outcomes remain unguessable. (Kristen Chick, the Monitor's correspondent in Tunis, writes this afternoon that many protesters are vowing to resist an interim government that is packed full of Ben Ali's erstwhile underlings.) One question in Ms. Rubin's column does have a clear answer however. "How much did the emergence of a democratic Iraq have to do with this popular revolt in Tunisia?" she asks. Having covered Iraq and Egypt full time between 2003-2008, and having explored the question of whether the US invasion of Iraq would spur regional political change at length with academics, politicians, and average folks in and out of the region over a period of years (and talked to people in touch with current events in Tunisia the past few days) the answer to her question is clear: "Little to nothing." The sectarian bloodletting in Iraq, the insurgency, and the US role in combating it claimed tens of thousands of Iraqi lives, and Iraq remains unstable today. The regional view of the Iraq war was and is overwhelmingly negative, the model of Iraq something to be avoided at all costs. Before I read Rubin's piece earlier today, Simon Hawkins, an anthropology professor at Franklin and Marshall, was kind enough to chat with me about Tunisian politics and history. Hawkins, whose dissertation was about Tunisia, has been coming and going from the country since the late 1980s. He recounted (unprompted) how the word "democracy" had been given a bad name among many of the Tunisian youth (the same sorts who led the uprising against Ben Ali) because of the Iraq experience, "That's democracy," a group of Tunisian youths said to him in 2006 of Iraq. "No thanks." The Obama Administration's policies towards the Arab world, largely focused on counterterrorism cooperation and avoiding pushing hard for political reform in autocracies like Egypt, are in fact an almost straight continuation of President Bush's approach, particularly in his second term. It's true that Bush made a ringing call for freedom in the Middle East a centerpiece of his inaugural address, but soon came up against the hard reality that close regional allies like Egypt, Bahrain and Saudi Arabia weren't much interested in tolerating challenges to their rule. After the Muslim Brotherhood tripled its share in Egypt's parliament in one of the fairest (but still fraud marred) Egyptian elections in decades and the Islamist group Hamas swept free and fair Palestinian elections in 2006, the US took a big step back from Arab democracy promotion. That's a situation that persists today. [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] ------------------------------------ -------------------------- Want to discuss this topic? Head on over to our discussion list, [email protected]. -------------------------- Brooks Isoldi, editor [email protected] http://www.intellnet.org Post message: [email protected] Subscribe: [email protected] Unsubscribe: [email protected] *** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtmlYahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/ <*> Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional <*> To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join (Yahoo! ID required) <*> To change settings via email: [email protected] [email protected] <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [email protected] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
