On Mon, Apr 6, 2020, at 17:52, Greg Troxel wrote: > Skyler Hawthorne <[email protected]> writes: > > > Hmm, maybe service roads and access have nothing to do with the > > problem. If I try to route to the fountain out front, it does the > > right thing, but the issue happens when I click on the building and > > navigate to that. > > I said this before, but: > > It seems in this area that many routers are having trouble, and osmand > is known to do ok with terminal private segments when private access > is enabled. > > Therefore i think it is far more likely that there is something wrong > with the OSM data, than that osmand has a bug which produces the > observed behavior.
Sorry, perhaps I could have made this clearer, but in that particular message you're quoting, I was talking about the case I found navigating to the movie theater. No roads leading up to the theater are private, so I don't think access has anything to do with why it's routing like it is in my screenshot. > I have private accesss turned on in osmand. I routinely drive to places > that are reachable by access=private ways (with permission!), and osmand > routes on those ways just fine. > > There are larger issues about doing this right, and I don't claim osmand > or any other router is fully correct. Just that I think it unlikely you > are suffering from an osmand bug vs something else we don't understand. Yeah, I'm not sure either if the issue leading into the mobile home park is osmAnd specific, although the route to the movie theater does seem to be specific to osmAnd. > > I did run the JOSM validator on the trailer park data. It found a few > things, but they were minor and I uploaded fixes. The only notable one > was overlapping ways for the entrance/exit roads, that I think you > introduced - and I fixed them. To be fair, there are lots of relations > to give names to multi-way roads, and this is more complicated than is > typical. (I am of the opinion, perhaps wrong, that using editors other > than josm to deal with relations is asking for trouble.) Oh interesting. If you'd be so inclined, I'd love it if you could send me a private email that lets me know what the issues were so I can avoid them in the future! -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "OsmAnd" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/osmand/0ee169ef-5d41-46f5-a162-de3c724aa77f%40www.fastmail.com.
