Maybe you ought to try a few color 4x5"s of the bride and groom
and enlarge to about 11x14. Maybe digital is good enough.....
until you see that!

JCO

-----Original Message-----
From: Bruce Dayton [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: Wednesday, August 25, 2004 12:20 PM
To: J. C. O'Connell
Subject: Re: It's over (was Re: Ilford in trouble? and digi snappers)


I fully agree with you in regards to quality.  Even when I compared my
67 stuff to 6mp digital, there is clearly more detail in the 67.  If I
was shooting scenics and landscapes mostly, I might still be shooting
film.  But for closer, frame filling subjects, like weddings and
portraits, the digital is plenty good enough.  I wouldn't want to be
carting around a 4X5 for that kind of work.

-- 
Best regards,
Bruce


Wednesday, August 25, 2004, 8:54:06 AM, you wrote:

JCOC> Digital still cant match what you can do with a 4x5 FILM camera 
JCOC> and lens that costs less than a DSLR body alone.

JCOC> For people who's reference of quality is 35mm or Medium format 
JCOC> film, sure DSLR can replace that, but it isnt even close to 4x5 
JCOC> quality and wont be for quite some time to come unless very large 
JCOC> sensors suddenly become cheap and all the indications are they 
JCOC> wont.

JCOC> Im am not trying to say that the average person should be shooting

JCOC> 4x5 film, I'm just saying for those who know and want really good 
JCOC> quality, there is no affordable digital at this time or in the 
JCOC> near future. That is still the domain of FILM.

JCOC> JCO

JCOC> -----Original Message-----
JCOC> From: Bruce Dayton [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
JCOC> Sent: Wednesday, August 25, 2004 11:34 AM
JCOC> To: Cotty
JCOC> Subject: Re: It's over (was Re: Ilford in trouble? and digi
snappers)


JCOC> I've only got about 9 months one mine now, but with two bodies
probably
JCOC> in the neighborhood of 13,000 frames and my face hurts from
grinning.

JCOC> It is ironic how often those who actually start to use a DSRL,
thinking
JCOC> they will use film cameras along with it, find that they rarely
use the
JCOC> film cameras anymore.

JCOC> One thing to remember, is that almost all those who like digital
used to
JCOC> shoot film.  It's not as if they have no clue what shooting film
is
JCOC> like.  They have tried both and found digital to be more
preferable (not
JCOC> without issues, but film has issues too).  Remember I am talking
about
JCOC> comparably handling cameras - film SLR vs. DSLR.  When I had a
Coolpix
JCOC> 990 P&S digital and my film cameras, I still shot film for
anything
JCOC> beyond quick snaps.  With a DSLR, well I sold all my film
equipment.



Reply via email to