I like that they are comparing the scanner output and not the optical print as I would sacrifice a little resolution for the ability to manipulate the picture in Photoshop. I even like the comparison of the affordable scanner output to digital as that is what I can buy. What I don't like is cropping 35mm film to APS size and then comparing to 6MP digital. That way you can compare large format to 6MP digital and digital would win and only because of lack of noise, that is just stupid.
> > Most of the comparisons are cropping film to the size of APS and > > then comparing with digital, that is not fair. > > More to the point, they are comparing scanned film to digital. > They are really comparing whatever scanner they are using to a > digital camera. > > The fair comparison is to compare a high quality optical print to > digital. > Do that, and yer 6 megapixie dslr starts to look like cheap junk. > > William Robb > >
