----- Original Message -----
From: Rob Brigham
Subject: RE: fa 85mm 1.4 vs 77mm limited


> I would never accuse Velvia of being 'outside the mainstream',
nor would
> just about most people who take landscapes IMHO.  It may be an
extreme,
> but its one of the most used slide films in the world and is
pretty much
> the definition of mainstream to me.

Funny you should say that. I shoot a lot of landscapes, a lot on
4x5. I tried Velvia when it came out, and found it to be too
contrasty and too saturated.
The stuff doesn't look real to me, and has too short a tonal
range to be useable IMO. Now I do use very contrasty lenses,
which I am sure makes a difference.

William Robb

Reply via email to