Tom, responses interleaved:

 

From: Tom Gollier [mailto:[email protected]] 
Sent: 15-Oct-14 8:17 PM



Gary, you asked:

     What other ways to you have in mind?

I would have to say I think any logical relationship can link an index and icon.

[GF] OK, but in Peirce’s view, there is only “one primary and fundamental 
logical relation, that of illation, expressed by ergo” (CP 3.440, quoted 
previously).

  Thus, "myself and my fingerprints" might even be a better example for the 
point I'm trying to make.  Instead of the implicative relationship associated 
with "is," and the prescission needed to a "denote" a quasi-thing like "red," 
we have the equivalence of what is denoted by "myself" as an index and what is 
indicated by the qualities expressed by "my fingerprints" as an icon.  Both 
"denote," each in their own way, the same person.

[GF] OK, but except for the terminological point about “denote”, this just 
explains why Peirce dispensed with the “copula” in his analysis of the 
proposition, making the word “is” (when it occurs) part of the predicate, as 
explained in NP 3.4; and why the syntax of the Dicisign replaces the old 
“copula” with another index, as explained in NP 3.7.

I don't think what I'm "overlooking here is the existential aspect of 
indexicality."  I'm just insisting on the existential aspect of the icon via 
the analogy between it and what it represents.

[GF] For Peirce, there’s nothing existential about an analogy or resemblance. 
An icon without an index can only be a Rheme, which cannot represent the 
existence of anything; that’s why there are no iconic Dicisigns among the ten 
classes of triadic relations.

  The two kinds of "denotation" are no doubt different in several ways, but 
their combination is enough to establish logical relationships, on the one 
hand, and claims of truth or falsity, on the other, with regard to our 
experience.

[GF] Yes, that’s why Peirce says that the Dicisign has to be an index involving 
an icon. That’s the only way they can be “combined”, because the icon is more 
“degenerate” than the index, as explained in KS, so you can’t have an icon 
involving an index. But neither can convey information without the other. In 
the case of your fingerprints, the index is their uniqueness, and the fact that 
only your having actually touched something at the crime scene could account 
for their being there. But if someone made an enlargement of your fingerprints 
on canvas, framed it and hung it on the wall of an art gallery, with the title 
“Untitled”, then it would be an icon without an index connecting it to you, and 
thus it would not denote you at all, for the viewers of the canvas — not even 
if they happened to know you personally.

Tom

gary f.

-----------------------------
PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L 
to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To 
UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the 
line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at 
http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .




Reply via email to