Stefan, I would concur with everything you say here. “Revolt against authority” 
as a founding myth of “modern science” is, to me, not a hypothesis but an 
oversimplified story (all stories are simplified to some degree). One can find 
traces of it in, for example, the “Cosmos” television series, both the original 
with Carl Sagan and the more recent one with Neil deGrasse Tyson.

 

gary

 

From: sb [mailto:[email protected]] 
Sent: 14-Jul-16 05:29



 

Gary F.,

yes i agree, Peirce reading of the history of science is based on the idea that 
we are standing on shoulders of giants.

But i doubt the revolt against authority hypothesis. Take for example Galileo, 
he never revolted against the church. He was deeply rooted in the tradition of 
christian natural philosophy. And the catholic church of the middle ages was 
quite tolerant towards natural philosophy. Galileo referred to this tolerant 
tradition in his defense. The intolerance against natural philosophy was 
something new and was a product of the church internal war between jesuits and 
dominicans. In this view Galileos ideas were the battle field but not the 
source of the battle. 

Or take Newton as another example. Did he revolt against tradition? No, he was 
deeply rooted in the hermetic tradition and most of his work is dedidicated to 
alchemy. The close relation between his work on gravity and his alchemical work 
has been shown by history of science. 

Newton as an alchemist shows that there was already a tradition of 
experimenting. Lots of it esoteric, but also proto-scientific or already 
serious chemistry. And were Galileos instruments constructed without 
experimenting?

Also many of the great scientist wanted their discoveries in accordance with 
their christian faith: Galileo, Newton, later Darwin and also Peirce did so.

Yes, the whole world view changed in the 16th century, but it is not that easy 
like the modern revolutionaries that rebell against authority on one side and 
the outdated antimodern on the other side. Knowledge production in that time 
was a complex web of social relations in which a complex set of ideas 
circulated. 

I know your not making it that simple (your comment about the source of the 
hypothesis) but many people in science still believe in the founding myth.

Putting the said above in the context of the original exchange between Olga, 
John and Gary my point is that when we look closer the sharp line between 
science and non-science gets blurred. I think it is important to keep the 
difference between the organizational borders of the sociological phenomenon 
science, the individual scientific skills (scientific craftsmanship like 
statistics, experiments etc.) and the scientifc ethos in mind. In my opinion 
the ethos is the most important whether someone is within an scientific 
organization and has scientific skills or not, because the latter are neither 
necessary nor sufficient conditions.

Best
Stefan




-----------------------------
PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L 
to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To 
UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the 
line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at 
http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .




Reply via email to