Dear Stefan and Jerry: I want to add some personal experience to Stefan's observation:
"We learn to see things, the things are not just there." I assume that you do not mean the things are not there; rather, that they are not "just there." In other words, we do not see them just because they are there, we often have to learn to see them. *An Example of Tastes "just there" and "there"* A third of a century ago, I became interested in beer. I bought a lot of books on beer, and even went to several national microbrew conferences. I was asked by the editor of our local newspaper to write a bi-weekly column about it, which I did for a couple of years in the mid-1980s. Eventually my columns were published as a book, *The Birth of the Craft Brew Revolution, <https://www.amazon.com/Birth-Craft-Brew-Revolution/dp/1484076265>* When I first became interested, the biggest problem was how to taste the differences in beers. One experience: just about every book on beer I ever read lauded Pilsner Urquell as the finest beer in the world. So, I tried to drink Pilsner Urquell at every opportunity. I got cases of it from the local distributor. To get it on tap, I had to go to cities (it was the early 1980s). Since I often visited DC and NYC, I only went to restaurants that had it on tap. Here the problem was, what was so great about it? Yes, I liked it, but I didn't find anything that called for such unanimous praise. So, I drank it off and on for two years. Gradually I began to notice some other tastes in it. Then one day I will never forget, it happened. I took a drink, sloshed it around, and suddenly I was tasting it all. It was like I had a symphony orchestra of tastes in my mouth. Wow! The same thing happened with other beers. I learned the scent of different hops, and how different barleys (two row or six row), and different roastings tasted. I became able to judge, i.e., discriminate among different beers, depending on the quality of their ingredients and the craft or art in their brewing. All this was a learning process. All the tastes were "there," but they were "just there"; it took a long time for me to distinguish them, and therefore to experience them. Only then were they really there for me. *Imagination* Only after I had gone through that experience, could I really begin imagining different tastes. This led to later discovering beers that fulfilled my dreams. Yes, I discovered beers of which I could say, "this is better than anything I have ever dreamed of." But I also came to experience the sometimes greater joy of finding a beer of which I could say, "this is what I have dreamed of, but never thought I would actually taste; yet, here it is, in reality, in my mouth and on my taste buds." It is kind of like what a scientist experiences upon finally confirming a new hypothesis..... I suppose this is the same for learning science. Many learn a method, a set of procedures, and only see what they have been trained to see, just as many people never learn to appreciate new or even great tastes because they never outgrow the taste of their mother's cooking. For them, just as for those who learn "science" as a set of procedures, there is no discussing other ways of imagining things. For both, the rule is equally true: *De gustibus non est disputandum, *meaning "In matters of taste, there can be no disputes" (literally "about tastes, it should not be disputed/discussed"). I offer all this as an example of things discussed by several in this string of emails. First, how our consciousness organizes or sifts experience; second, how we can learn to experience things that, unless we put in the effort, are "just there," i.e., a little beyond our ability to experience them as actually there. Finally, there my experience of learning about beer has also led me to realize that there is or may be much about historical experience that we may never know. For example, plants themselves, in addition to soils and climate, are always changing. We may never be able to taste how barley or hops tasted a century ago. Another example: Anchor Steam beer is, historically, the only original American style of beer. Yet, we know of it only from verbal descriptions; we do not know exactly how it was made, and we have not figured out how to recreate it. But, even if we knew these, we could not be sure that the barley and hops have not subtly changed. So, no matter how hard we try to duplicate recipes, we are very likely to get a different beer than what we are trying to duplicate. (BEER LOVERS NOTE: The beers produced by Anchor Steam beer today are undoubtedly some of the best brews in America, largely due to the dedication of Fritz Maytag in leaning and applying the science--and art--of brewing. For anyone who cares, every year Anchor Steam creates a new and different Christmas Ale, available only in late November till New Years, which are dreams come true for me. But his 2011 brew was the best for me: it was the beer I always dreamed of and never thought I would actually taste...) This is true of science, too. Many years ago I was contacted by a mathematics professor who thought I knew Latin. He explained that he was doing research on the history of mathematics, and discovered that many of the great advances by persons described what they were doing,and why, quite differently than how we describe these advances today. Unfortunately, my Latin is so basic that I could be of little help. We are into Kuhn's different paradigms... Second, I think it is of importance also for consciousness studies. Our taste sense reports to us much that our conscious mind takes no notice of. Yes, they are there, but "just there." So what is about consciousness that can learn to sense what is beyond our notice? And how can our consciousness "learn" to sense more "things, " by bringing them from "just there" to "there"? Third, I introduce all this about tasting beers in order to give an example that illustrates the importance of aesthetics , where here the "beautiful " is experienced in the senses of taste and scent, rather than in the senses of seeing, hearing, or touching. Peirce said that different ages can be distinguished by the dominant logic of the period. Elsewhere I once read that ages can be distinguished by their dominant sense. For the ancients, the sense of sight was dominant, hence their ideal was t*o kalon*, the beautiful. For the Middle Ages, the sense of hearing was dominant; the world was understood through hearing the gospels; "truth" became the ultimate value. In the modern age, the sense of touch or feeling seems to be dominant. "How does it feel?" "how are you feeling?" "does it feel good? are our ultimate issues. (Since I care deeply about the sense of taste, it gives me hope that the next age will be distinguished by one of the two remaining senses: taste or scent.) *The Point* What is consciousness, how is consciousness, that it can learn, that it can organize itself so differently? It seems clear to me that aesthetics play a major role. But how is it, that what is aesthetically pleasing so important to our consciousness? Who or What is our consciousness trying to please? Jerry Rhee brings it together this way: Yet, there is unique opportunity in this example for education and treating attitudes because the phi ratio is *divine.* The spiral enters through the senses as an esthetic image of a natural material, nature promises definite [I would amend this to *infinite*--BenN) interrelations that can be made intelligible through use and development … Importantly, there is promise of ascent to perfection that takes care to cultivate the spirited, appetitive and rational parts along the way. Sincerely, Ben Novak *Ben Novak <http://bennovak.net>* 5129 Taylor Drive, Ave Maria, FL 34142 Telephone: (814) 808-5702 *"All art is mortal, **not merely the individual artifacts, but the arts themselves.* *One day the last portrait of Rembrandt* *and the last bar of Mozart will have ceased to be—**though possibly a colored canvas and a sheet of notes may remain—**because the last eye and the last ear accessible to their message **will have gone." *Oswald Spengler On Wed, Jul 20, 2016 at 12:50 AM, Jerry Rhee <[email protected]> wrote: > Stefan, Jon, list: > > > > I think you hit an important point. There are so few ideal examples; so > few Beautiful examples that take you the “long way” to an explanation of > *the* scientific method that does justice to why liberal education. This > places us in a situation where there’s no knock down argument for why one > choice over another; no beautiful example that allows you to *safely* > *understand > the low in light of the high*. Whatever works is just as good as any > other. Why even bother about the relations between esthetics, ethics and > logic? Practicing scientists don’t. It’s all myth. No proof for *the* > scientific method. > > > > But there are professional estheticians and ethicists and logicians. So, > why are they wasting their time? What could they be up to and what could > they have to offer? What would great thinkers of the past say about the > best scientific method? > > > > Peirce presents pragmatism oddly in *Definition and Description of > Pragmatism*: > > > > “[Pragmatism] is merely a method of ascertaining the meanings of hard > words and of abstract concepts… All pragmatists will further agree that > their method of ascertaining the meanings of words and concepts is no other > than that experimental method by which all the successful sciences (in > which number nobody in his senses would include metaphysics) have reached > the degrees of certainty that are severally proper to them today; this > experimental method being itself nothing but a particular application of an > older logical rule, “By their fruits ye shall know them.” > > > > Here, the normative method is fundamental for thinking and meaning-making, > which serves as the foundation for doing science. Again, the theory is not > specifically designed for the individual; it is developed to make the > community happy. One wants to do well and fare well. If it is a diverse > community and they respect one another- consider each other neighbors-, > then there are constraints and responsibilities for the way information is > shared. It must be done with care toward economically organizing > experience. Otherwise, members will get bored or frustrated and join > alternative communities. This is one reason why silos are inevitable. But > why, then, do we seek convergence of silos? Unity must be desirable. > > > > So, where is this Beautiful example to judge the low in light of the > high? > > Why not phi spiral abduction? For by its fruits ye shall know it. > > But again, too much promise; not enough performance. > > Community doesn’t have time to “get it”. Too busy. > > > > Yet, there is unique opportunity in this example for education and > treating attitudes because the phi ratio is *divine.* The spiral enters > through the senses as an esthetic image of a natural material, nature > promises definite interrelations that can be made intelligible through use > and development of modern technology… Importantly, there is promise of > ascent to perfection that takes care to cultivate the spirited, appetitive > and rational parts along the way. This wholeness/completeness directly > treats the nonage problem. > > > > I mean, what does one expect from a Beautiful example of a normative > method, anyways? > > > > Best, > Jerry Rhee > > On Tue, Jul 19, 2016 at 8:15 PM, Jon Alan Schmidt < > [email protected]> wrote: > >> Stefan, List: >> >> You wrote ... >> >> It would be much better to teach practicing scientists the philosophy, >> history and sociology of science. This would be enlightenment in science... >> >> The same is true for engineers and engineering, but I have found that >> most of my fellow engineers have little to no interest in such matters. As >> I titled a conference presentation a few years ago, "Engineers Don't Think >> Enough About Engineering." I suspect that the same is true of scientists >> and other professionals; they focus on simply doing the job, day in and day >> out, and do not perceive the value of reflecting on HOW they go about it. >> >> Regards, >> >> Jon Alan Schmidt - Olathe, Kansas, USA >> Professional Engineer, Amateur Philosopher, Lutheran Layman >> www.LinkedIn.com/in/JonAlanSchmidt - twitter.com/JonAlanSchmidt >> >> >> ----------------------------- >> PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON >> PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to >> [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L >> but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the >> BODY of the message. More at >> http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm . >> >> >> >> >> >> > > > ----------------------------- > PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON > PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to > [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L > but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the > BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm > . > > > > > >
----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .
